The Most Extreme Elimination Challenge Mafia Edition
- Thread starter BipolarChemist
- Start date
Well fiddlesticks. That did not go as planned.
Unvote: coju
I think Gwaihir and Jcakes are the two most likely to be scum (although, to be honest, coju isn't a whole lot townier). I voted coju and made up a "case" in the hopes one of both would take the bait by voting coju and/or me. Instead, Jcakes just ignored it and Gwaihir is MIA. I don't want to leave the vote up overnight.
Gwaihir - He's playing an ideal vanilla scum game (or godfather-ish). Posting just enough but not too much. Making sure to have votes down at the end of the day but not leading any. Talking about players but not straying too far from a neutral stance. Too townie to be townie is a good way of putting it.
Jcakes - His "@Goryani, Noodle, Gwaihir: I am happy to be somewhat guided by you guys as well." post did not sit well. At all. Reminds me of Valhauros et al.
Unvote: coju
I think Gwaihir and Jcakes are the two most likely to be scum (although, to be honest, coju isn't a whole lot townier). I voted coju and made up a "case" in the hopes one of both would take the bait by voting coju and/or me. Instead, Jcakes just ignored it and Gwaihir is MIA. I don't want to leave the vote up overnight.
Gwaihir - He's playing an ideal vanilla scum game (or godfather-ish). Posting just enough but not too much. Making sure to have votes down at the end of the day but not leading any. Talking about players but not straying too far from a neutral stance. Too townie to be townie is a good way of putting it.
Jcakes - His "@Goryani, Noodle, Gwaihir: I am happy to be somewhat guided by you guys as well." post did not sit well. At all. Reminds me of Valhauros et al.
- Dec 6, 2010
- 5,584
- 309
- 83
I reckon the game is based off of the show, which the wiki is based off of.
Yes, I did say that. Logout wound up being town, did he not? I later said that he was posting very strangely. Also did not know why he would fake a claim like that.
The "event staff" theory was not proven yet when he made that claim. It is now, and was (basically), when goldtru made her claim, which is why I was so exasperated why she would make a claim like that.
Question: Have any of you watched the show before?
I have but it's been a while. I remembered some of the voice mannerisms emulated by the mods: "Right you are Kenny!" but I couldn't tell you which character said it (probably not kenny).
Haha Right you are, Phar. An exciting day indeed!
Today, our pit under the rotating surfboard of death is sponsered by Yobogoya, the Cheapest bucket of beef in Illonoi-A!
Today, our pit under the rotating surfboard of death is sponsered by Yobogoya, the Cheapest bucket of beef in Illonoi-A!
To explain my point better: The only reason I would see to have Laarz submit both a replay and a NK (especially with Drixx's claim) is if all remaining mafia had either:
1) A stronger active ability than the replay (busdriver would definitely count)
2) A strong passive ability (yes, an investigative immunity would count as would lynch immunity or daytalk facilitator, or some other good passive power.)
If there is a normal goon out there, why risk using getting a mafia power role caught? I will admit, the busdriver flip was very big surprise, I did not expect to see an active on someone who was not seen targeting Drixx.
As for your cases: I have come to expect at some point in late game for you tend to start leading. You come out with a case against someone. In this game, you hop on a case around the middle with a couple of reasons listed.
I am curious why you think one of the second group has to be scum. Are Numbers and Gory completely cleared for you?
Sorry, busy with Thanksgiving stuff. Hopefully will have more time tomorrow.
Actually, I find this kind of funny as I am basically accusing you of the same thing.
Nope.
If you look at the vote trends, it's really quite frustrating. Basically everyone's votes are around the middle of all the various trains, except for one post lock vote by goryani on logoutzero's train. A lot of sitting back and seeing what happens, no direction or cases except from coju, jcakes, and myself...which is, as said before, very bothersome.
Basically, all I'm saying here is good job scum. I think everyone is sorta scum, which is pretty bad.
Coju: Prior to leading the train on goldtru, scummiest of all, however, if scum it would have been very easy to just sit back and let the vote resolve itself without any involvement on your part. Still leaning scum.
Jcakes: Attempted to deflect a train away from scum, but led a train on other scum. 50/50
Gwaihir: Voted on all the scum trains, and was a necessary vote for the lynches. Leaning town.
Goryani: Town power role, still alive at this point? AND someone who is repeatedly pointed out as a good player, and someone who is generally nk'd early if town as a result. Still being alive is very weird, but confirmed JOAT, and a scum JOAT seems very unlikely. We're also aware of two active powers on the scum team at least(bus driver and replayer), is 3 active powers a reasonable expectation? Very slightly leaning town.
Coju: Prior to leading the train on goldtru, scummiest of all, however, if scum it would have been very easy to just sit back and let the vote resolve itself without any involvement on your part. Still leaning scum.
Jcakes: Attempted to deflect a train away from scum, but led a train on other scum. 50/50
Gwaihir: Voted on all the scum trains, and was a necessary vote for the lynches. Leaning town.
Goryani: Town power role, still alive at this point? AND someone who is repeatedly pointed out as a good player, and someone who is generally nk'd early if town as a result. Still being alive is very weird, but confirmed JOAT, and a scum JOAT seems very unlikely. We're also aware of two active powers on the scum team at least(bus driver and replayer), is 3 active powers a reasonable expectation? Very slightly leaning town.
I can see your point except that I didn't sit around and wait for you guys to post. I provided my thoughts i.e that we should lynch one of either coju or numbers and that I didn't believe Gold to be scum.
- Dec 6, 2010
- 5,584
- 309
- 83
@Gwaihir: No, Numbers and Goryani isn't getting a pass. I almost expect goryani to be scum. As to why the 2nd group has to be scum: They weren't targeting drixx that night, and we lynched a scum member from the group that targeted drixx. I half-way didn't expect two scum actions on the same character (especially if they were killing him).
- Dec 6, 2010
- 5,584
- 309
- 83
What did you find out? I didn't see any mention of your action in the next days.
- Dec 6, 2010
- 5,584
- 309
- 83
Does anyone know how many times JOAT has been scum/town? I vaguely remember that role being scum in the, erm, game with dragons? Bad Ash hosted, maybe? The one where the Host used forumites not playing in the stories to make those more interesting. The stories had prizes with them as well.
Oh: Gets across whatever even the game is on flawlessly.
Moonwalked across to try and one-up the jackase
Oh: Gets across whatever even the game is on flawlessly.
Moonwalked across to try and one-up the jackase
we suspect that a lightning rod ability was used that night. Everyone on that list claims to have targeted someone else.
There was a Joat mafia in the BG mafia game. There was also one in the Gods of Ancient Greece mafia game as well.
- Dec 6, 2010
- 5,584
- 309
- 83
@goryani: Would you have let me get lynched if the votes would have came in with your information?
or
what would you have done if a couple more people had voted me with your information? How long would you have kept it to yourself?
Unvote: Jcakes
or
what would you have done if a couple more people had voted me with your information? How long would you have kept it to yourself?
do you still feel this way?
How has this passed as Gwaihir being town? Simply it means he is non-PR
bad ash claimed JOAT?
Unvote: Jcakes
Google