My thoughts...
The word "tonight" has me intrigued. To me, this seems to strongly hint that CG is indeed scum but just was not called upon to make a kill that night.
I made the following comment:
CG's reply:
While I know I'm not scum, he nobody else does obviously. I wondered if I was wrong to call out me not having a PM but, I don't think I was.
That last bit, I think I gave in and backed down. I'm not convinced in this situation in this game it's to my benefit to just sit back and not contribute information that might help isolate scum.
Solar's reply to CG's comment I find very fitting to how I'm seeing the situation:
Exactly the following, that line I think gives away more than I originally got from it:
With two people looking heavily in his direction, calling him out, he doesn't seem interested in responding, instead he posts this stuff:
His aggressive comments, then his disappearance and subsequent jokes combined with the story fragment makes me extremely suspicious of CG.
We have three claimed Normans in the game still alive. Of course, I know I'm town, so from my perspective, I see the following:
Since I'm town, and my running assumption is that mafioso do not get our abilities the only possible person left in the Norman group is CG. So he is going to get my vote today.
(I'm not sure any of the abilities are even useful to them are they? If I was scum wouldn't I just use the powers on townies that aren't targeted? I wouldn't want to give any info out that's useful, so find people that the town strongly believes is already town and play dumb. The doc ability isn't useful either is it?)
For everybody else, perhaps it's a bit more complicated given that you don't know my true alignment even if I tell you. If you run off the assumption that scum do not get our abilities, then Solar can be seen as townie. That leaves the rest of the town to decide between me and CG. Again, the running assumption is that there is mafia in each group. So, how would any of you go about deciding between the two of us. Well, the story itself I think gives a very good hint. Also, look at his postings this last day and then mine, he just reads scummier (imo).
I know we have a few other targets that are being floated around today, but I get a very strong feeling that CG is about as close to a sure thing as we have right now, and I think for the long term, it's a better path to take right now.
All this being said, if there is something wrong with my line of thought let me know and I will re-evaluate my position.
Vote: Caluin Graye
I tracked Caluin Graye last night.
Although me being me, I already know I’m not doing anything evil tonight, he smiled. Then his face turned solemn again.
The word "tonight" has me intrigued. To me, this seems to strongly hint that CG is indeed scum but just was not called upon to make a kill that night.
I made the following comment:
If a Norman did watch another Norman it was either CG or Solar, I didn't get any PM last night.
CG's reply:
I hate this post. It just screams as if a scum is trying to get another Norman to reveal information prematurely.
While I know I'm not scum, he nobody else does obviously. I wondered if I was wrong to call out me not having a PM but, I don't think I was.
Hmm, I see your point. However, given the random nature of this game it could very easily have been me with the PM (and may very well be me tomorrow, who knows!) and while I don't know for sure, I'm guessing I'd probably end up posting the PM sometime during the day anyway, somebody is bound to ask for a Norman to speak up. That being said, you're probably right about putting it out there like that since somebody is likely to ask anyway, should have just let them ask... *shrugs*
That last bit, I think I gave in and backed down. I'm not convinced in this situation in this game it's to my benefit to just sit back and not contribute information that might help isolate scum.
Solar's reply to CG's comment I find very fitting to how I'm seeing the situation:
It is very strange that you made this post because if Zokar did not track a Norman and you did not, then that leaves myself as the last claimed Norman - hence by process of elimination, you had a good idea that I was the tracker. If I targeted you, Town points to you. If I targeted Zokar then if you are Scum, you would well know that Zokar was Town (or a Scumbuddy) so no harm done in making that statement to the eyes of the Town.
You seem very eager to point out that being tracked absolves a player from being Mafia. Even though you did not do anything last night, I am inclined to push for your lynch right now.
I know that I am not Mafia so either you or Zokar are Scum if the theory of one of each char being mafia holds true and there are no other Normans hiding.
Exactly the following, that line I think gives away more than I originally got from it:
I did not get a PM from Sathoris confirming a result on Caluin Graye. The story-line does indicate the result however.
Yes, Caluin Graye could very, very well be Scum.
With two people looking heavily in his direction, calling him out, he doesn't seem interested in responding, instead he posts this stuff:
I assumed cop because I posses reading comprehension.
Hey, I can only be right 99% of the time. The other 3% I'm just not wrong.
His aggressive comments, then his disappearance and subsequent jokes combined with the story fragment makes me extremely suspicious of CG.
We have three claimed Normans in the game still alive. Of course, I know I'm town, so from my perspective, I see the following:
Since I'm town, and my running assumption is that mafioso do not get our abilities the only possible person left in the Norman group is CG. So he is going to get my vote today.
(I'm not sure any of the abilities are even useful to them are they? If I was scum wouldn't I just use the powers on townies that aren't targeted? I wouldn't want to give any info out that's useful, so find people that the town strongly believes is already town and play dumb. The doc ability isn't useful either is it?)
For everybody else, perhaps it's a bit more complicated given that you don't know my true alignment even if I tell you. If you run off the assumption that scum do not get our abilities, then Solar can be seen as townie. That leaves the rest of the town to decide between me and CG. Again, the running assumption is that there is mafia in each group. So, how would any of you go about deciding between the two of us. Well, the story itself I think gives a very good hint. Also, look at his postings this last day and then mine, he just reads scummier (imo).
I know we have a few other targets that are being floated around today, but I get a very strong feeling that CG is about as close to a sure thing as we have right now, and I think for the long term, it's a better path to take right now.
All this being said, if there is something wrong with my line of thought let me know and I will re-evaluate my position.
Vote: Caluin Graye