Can you describe to us how omg was doing more scumhunting than anyone? He was suspicious of Noodle, and yet every one of his posts were about his role but one and the post where he votes. That doesn't justify him being around when we lost nothing by lynching him, especially as late in the day as you came in and failed to act!
So you just described Autti as having only talked about voting and omg and you can't think of anyone who omg was doing more scumhunting than? While I'll agree that most of his posts were about his role, he did have some analysis of Laarz, Malevolent, Noodle and kestegs(p177 and p209). If he'd have had more such posts past the point I departed and we had lynched one mafia, I'd have no problem keeping him around longer.
coju votes kestegs first without a reason(p155) and then claims his reason is that because kestegs called omg a godfather, he was trying to get him investigated(p166). That sounds like complete nonsense to me. (p286) is bantering between kestegs and MartinLong, and mentions pcm being linked to kestegs. He fails to give much reasoning when switching to ML(p384). (p385,424,434) Comments on voting and vaguely on why he's not voting omg. I'd only call his participation equal to omg.
flubbucket (p185,187,269) posts on Noodle, (p317) a little Question to ML, alot of roleplaying, no voting that I remember.
Omg a little better than him.
frozzzen (p183) Question to coju/goryani on why kestegs. (p342) likes Goryani's point about kestegs, votes ML, seems to give vague flips will give info reason.
Omg Better than him.
Gwaihir (p204,p206) omg discussion and vote. (p235,243) Some questions toward ML. (p253) A question toward Noodle on what he thought vote 2 would be for. (p350) Repeats the same questions posed by Solar Ice two posts up, time stamps are at least 30 mins apart. (p403,405,406,408,415) A lot of talk on why you should roleclaim as town. (p431) Banter with Moar and kestegs and a question to Solar if his suspicion of goryani was gut feeling.
All in all, Gwaihir's scumhunting was about equal to omg.
Jcakes (p157) ask for reasoning of coju's vote. (p179) votes omg, points out one of kestegs posts as being LAMIST.
(p202) Refutes flub 3 reasons on why Noodle would be scum. Say's flub does that everygame to FoE's post, and agrees with Goryani's theory vs pcm from (p191). (p277) A no order scum list- Kegs, nulio, ML, Mal; then revotes omg. (p320) Becomes the third person to ask if Noodle had a guilty conscience. Makes a bunch of analysis on ML and then votes.
Maybe a little ahead of omg. Its close, most of Jcakes scumhunting is directed toward already popular targets.
Laarz(p174,p213) Discusses omg and then votes omg. (p357) picks up ML badge comment. (p369) When ML says its just a synonym for "throwing in the towel", claims it might have been a last ditch effort to not get lynched and votes ML.
I'd say omg has done more here. Though I've got to give Laarz credit for finding the badge comment, as it seemed to lead to ML saying more later on about his role.
Loz(p231) V1/V2 stuff and not wanting to lynch Noodle for posting more. (p255) Agrees with Moar's post and says he's willing to vote omg. (p374) Agrees with Solar, seems to like a kestegs vote but that ML would be a better test because of leads though isn't descriptive on how. Points out Noodle's vote 2 as not counting(no space between vote and 2), though Thyiad ends up counting it anyways. Then votes V1 ML and V2 omg.
Really not too much input for Loz, I'd say omg has the lead here.
Malevolent(p188) Some about Noodle, (p245,246) votes ML, talks about omg. (p301) kestegs odd like a politician in answers, ML#1 scum, more on omg. (p419) comments on wanting to see who votes Moar. (p430) Discussion with Moar on her lynch not being guaranteed.
Not too much early for Mal, but does a little more late. Either equal or a little ahead of omg.
Noodle(p156) Postman idea, (p199) Response vs flub of how SK is not more likely a revealed postman (p210) Mistakes FoE's post on flub for himself and responds (p362) Has a slightly invalid vote on omg that is counted by Thyiad.
I'd say omg certainly has the lead here.
nulio Roleplaying posts
again easy lead for omg
pcm (p178) about omg, (p241) some response to goryani's theory vs him. Talks about's flubs breadcrumb/rp and speculation on who mafia is. p(291) not sold on kestegs yet, still wants his Mal vote, agrees on with Martin on nulio, wants to know about bartender role. (p297) still concerned vs nulio p(302-3) talks about three bartenders of Cheers. (p371) cites the need for lynches this game vs some other sp game, Prefers Mal but thinks with Moar's there's a good chance of scum ML and votes ML.
About equal to omg. He really seems interested in the bartender. Though I'd think the scum would have talked about rolefishing in their QT after Mal from the first day. He was absent the first day, did he not check there before posting?
TL,DR;
I'd say omg was better than Autti, flubbucket, frozzzen, Laarz, Loz, Noodle and nulio. And equal or close to equal with coju, Gwaihir, Jcakes, Malevolent, pcm and me. Thirteen out of twenty two players. CG and Pyro I'd rank as just a little bit ahead of the last group.
---
And now to try to catch up with what has been posted today.
Google
