Re: Forum Mafia Game: The Tomb known as Tristram
Laarz is being straight out useless for the progression of the thread as usual.
I agree.
Sdbramwell, you said that if Es Mors is not D, then it's me because my power hasn't helped anyone yet. Now, there's only one way you could know this for sure, and that's being the only surviving night killer. Care to retort?
yeah, my guess is its you because, your pointing fingers like mad. i have yet to do that. im simply stating that your my guess. expressing my thoughts. i have also stated that my logic isnt always fool-proof, but thus-so-far, hasn't been too bad.
DAY I
You claimed the first post in the whole thread, saying "so who's going to be the first to die?" I'm a bit surprised no one thought ill of this comment.
I don't see why anyone should read into this. it was the first post of the entire thread, and i simply stated it because someone is bound to die.
For the next few posts you bring out the fact that you're new to the game very strongly.
because ive obviously made several mistakes in this game, as my head is on the chopping block. however, i was simply apologizing and confessing my naivety if i were to ruin the game.
Afer a few filler posts, you were the first one to claim a role outside of your good ol' regular townie. This is a mistake done by those new to the game and who've something to hide. After your claim you state your freshness to the game again.
again, i didnt realize claiming my role was a huge 'mafia tell', thus i apologized using the same reasoning, apologize to the town for being ignorant.
After this you pose a question how your claim would paint a target on your back, as who'd waste a NK to a powerless role? Setting us up for you surviving all the nights here, eh?
once again, i did not know this was a 'mafia tell', and i probably apologized again shortly after.
Your next post indicated unwillingness to rid of the inactives. After this, you were the one to bring up the idea that GuardianHadriel was maybe muted, and planted the thought that he should be left alive. Because you knew he was your older brother? Hoping he'd show up?
Actually, i recalled him being on vacation from the sign up thread. i didnt mention this, but that was why i was HESITANT to vote inactives, they werent even given a chance to defend themselves. in hind-sight, im glad he was modkilled. he was the first prime evil to die, and lead us to another prime evil kill.
You voted for Essojay after he was already locked, before this your vote stood on Asrrin.
i think asrrin could even confess to this. he was pointing a heavy finger at gorny, but the second gorny claimed he was the tree stump, i raised an eyebrow at him. it was at this point that i also said we are up two on the mafia, wasting a lynch on GORNY wouldn't be a bad idea because it would prove his innocence or guilt. which it did, and it also proved a heavy trust in asrrin, which i still have.
To start, a thought about Diablo himself; who's to say he shows up as Diablo to the cop and not something else?
This is a very good point.
DAY II in the adventures of Sdbramwell
You start by reassuring your town drunk role. Town Drunk's traditionally have either a) a blocking ability b) they see someone at night who goes about their business or c) they're like the village idiot, wanting to get lynched, you deny all of these
a) im not a town drunk. im a vanilla townie. i have never said anything that would remotely come close to saying i have some power, let alone a blocking ability.
b) i do not see what people do at night, the only info i have is from the thread and Mar's story.
c) i am not a village idiot, do not lynch me, if you do i will not share victory
i am still denying all these, as i said, farnham is my character, hes a town drunk, not my actual role. adria was a witch who could make potions and such, i would think shed have some type of power for me. id also like to point out that it seems there havent been any NPC's that have had a power role.
You voted for Gorny. Because you know he's not on your side?
I voted for Gorny because he claimed he was the treestump. and i also said before my logic, we had two nights free of nk, and we need the truth from gorny to assert how honest asrrin was behaving. if gorny hadnt been lying, he would have lived. too bad for him.
You said "yeah but we had two nights free of nks, so far were up two on the mafia, at this point we can waste a lynch." Waste a lynch? HUH?
if retorted to this several times now. see above.
In a post where you doubt Noodle's claim to be the bus driver, you say "In addition it sounds like Mar spent a lot of time picking out roles that would match up pretty well to D2 character classes." when you question the fact that there's nothing switch related in the Amazon trees. Yet, you're a drunk with no abilities?
OK, I think its pretty clear that Mar did spend a lot of time getting a good plot and trying to match character abilities with roles/effects of powers. wouldnt you agree? and noodle's claim is very viable, and come to think of it, 'decoy' is probably the closest matching skill to the power of a bus drive in all the classes of d2, so why not choose it.
You back up BoD Trader in the whole : no : thing.
i think you are referring to the misvotes or something, not really sure. but yeah i supported counting his votes. i dont think his format mattered, it was pretty clear who he was voting for. and also, i didnt want my first game ruined, which i clearly stated several times.
Post #415 Laarz casts doubt on you for the same fact I mentioned in my DAY I recap of your actions, you were the one most against lynching GuardianHadriel. This buys him more credibility in my eyes, as useless as his other posts have been, than you.
I also later confessed to having been one of the first persons to mention this, i couldnt find that post but whatever. at any rate, as i have said before, i did some reading on the mafiawiki, but didnt see anything about it, thus i was nearly inquiring, not stating that i did think he was muted.
You voted for Bad Ash since Gorny was modkilled.
You unvoted Bad Ash.
i hate to bring this up, but i was also one of the first people to propose that GH may have been muted; however, i asked that because i thought of it and wasnt sure if it was possible or not. i really dont care who we lynch as long as we get more info for the town.
Vote: Bad Ash
nice, i foudn my post where i admitted it to bringing up the mute, and this is also when i voted for Bad Ash, i was bandwagonning on TC's back, check the thread, there were i think 3 votes for him counting mine, dont read into that vote too much.
After Ash hinted he's the cop, you said you wouldn't vote for him anymore.
yes, i also said that i had an air of trust in everyone who has role claimed, as is why i trust noodle now. and trust you.
i believe this was before we lynched GH, and before i started trusting the role claims.
You suggested protection for TC and Asrrin. Even after the cop had outed himself? Telling the doc who to protect is also a mafia tell.
i dont think anyone listended to me anyways, and guess what, TC died, so i was right, go figure.
You question if lynching Noodle is a good thing to do.
yeah i, would still question it, i dont think its a good idea.
You unvote Noodle, and state that you think Asrrin's roleclaim is viable in your opinion.
im guessing this is when i started trusting role claims.
More insuring that Marahumm put a lot of thought into the roles, after which you say ""im farnham who is NPC and has no abilities thus i cant do squat." I'd refer back to the first point of this post. Now you also seem to think that it's logical for the Amazon to be the bus driver.
im pretty sure i retorted this earlier. you should know that i trust the role claims. i will explain this at the end.
You voted for BoD Trader. You were the fifth to vote if I counted correctly, 7 votes needed to lock.
After it was locked you apologized to BoD Trader.
yeah, because if we were wrong, sorry to end your game so soon. also, i think ive apologized to half the people i voted for.
anyway, hope you believe me, but ive done some digging and have a pretty good theory.
if you take a look at pages 39-42, we go on a little voting spree.
i trust the people who have role-claimed, so this is based on the assumption that you trust the role claims.
Asrrin is highly suspicious of BoD Trader, and votes for him.
There are some comments back and forth, and es mors says its more logical to vote for ankeli, and does so.
an important follow vote is BoD, who knows ankeli isnt mafia (yes ankeli, i trust your druid claim)
the next vote is a known non mafia member (at least based on the cops investigation) KrazeyIvan, he votes for ankeli.
The 4th vote for ankeli is Laarz, which is key. we dont know much about him, iirc, and this is getting pretty close to lynching our doctor.
noodle bandwagons and votes for ankeli to try and secure a lynch.
we then decide that gorny is a safer bet through some back and forth logic and then gorny is modkilled and we decide to go with essojay.
imo, this makes laarz look suspicious. laarz did vote for GH, but him and BoD knew he was probably inactive and agreed there is nothing they could really do to avoid an inactive lynch. imo, i agree about investigating him.
with that being said, go ahead and end the day.
Google