Zombies invade Atlantis. Stargate zombie Mafia game.

[ThunderCat]

Vote tally Day 3 (8/9):
Noodle - 3 (Moar, AnnualAntAnswers, Caluin Graye)
IWantToUseNumbersInMyName - 3 (Jcakes, Drixx, korialstraz)

 

[Jcakes1]

Yes he does. He also used to work for the Goa'uld. You still think it is highly unlikely that he could be with the Goa'uld faction?

Given that Noodle claimed Adria, I suspect Ori rather than Goa'uld. That said I am very surprised at Aria being neutral, she is the most Anti-town person I could think of and very very powerful. It is because of this I am going to

Unvote: Numbers
?Vote: Noodle

 

[korialstraz]

Given that Noodle claimed Adria, I suspect Ori rather than Goa'uld. That said I am very surprised at Aria being neutral, she is the most Anti-town person I could think of and very very powerful. It is because of this I am going to

Unvote: Numbers
?Vote: Noodle

Actually Jcakes, you're probably right. For some reason I was convinced we would have a Goa'uld faction of scum, but despite Pyro being a Goa'uld, it does seem more likely for it to be Ori.

So by doubting Noodle's claim, you're also doubting Bipolar. I guess the most obvious question to ask then is what is yout throughts on Bipolar?

 

[Kestegs]

My first thought upon reading BPC's list and subsequent declaration that he wasn't going to actually give us the info on who he investigated made me automatically assume that Bad Ash being on the top of his list as likely scum was the result of an investigation. I didn't recall seeing anything from BPC prior to that list that led me to believe he felt Bad Ash was scummy. That might be poor play, but that was my read on the situation. Although, I, unlike you, can't even think of a single reason why keeping his results from us would be a good thing.

It took me this long but I can now think of a reason. It's really quite obvious once you see it.

 

[Kestegs]

At least we can agree that neither of us thinks there is a pro-town recruiter. It is worrying that you asked me to reveal that information if I had it though. Are you worried about a town recruiter stealing your recruits?


That was a very poor use of a smiley, something that didn't occur to me yesterday, so feel free to disregard it. Or not that is all up to you, but I'm standing by what I've said so far about you, and you are still on my scum list.
[/B]

I wasn't really thinking you had role based info on the mechanic, but that you might have a lore theory or something along those lines.

Noted.

Damn it, I think I deleted part of your quote I needed to respond to....

 

[Kestegs]

You seem awfully interested in the usage of power roles in this game. IIRC you've made a couple posts previously as well (excluding the one quoted in this post). Might be my mind playing tricks on me though.
[/B]

I'm not going to deny I've been inquiring somewhat about power roles, but that's not what I was doing here at all. It was a response to CG because he seemed to see info that I didn't and I wanted clarification on it.

 

[Kestegs]

I really feel better about numbers today than Noodle. But I think they both need to go

The only thing I worry about is that Noodle did actually get recruited last night and if he really is very powerful that could be bad. I'm still leaning towards him not getting recruited though. So :

vote1: Numbers

 

[Moar]

I'd like to see a vote from Numbers and BPC to be followed by a vote count. Doesn't matter who you vote for. It's just to see if your votes count.

 

[flubbucket1]

We do indeed need to lynch scum instead of neutrals.

I would like to ask an opinion question, would lynching Noodle do anything to cement BipolarChemist as a townie??

I'm going to vote now but I'll be available to change later if need be.

Vote: IWantToUseNumbersInMyName

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

It's not about proving yourself to the town, but you tried hard to come up with a way to confirm you as town. So which one is it?

Also what exactly about your claim makes it harder for mafia to choose? The choice seems simple. Get rid of the person that can confirm scum (and who already have given 1 scum 1 neutral) or... they can get rid of someone who claims vig and seems very trigger happy, and who will potentially hit (already have) town. I know what I'd do if I was scum.



What mastermind? You make a role claim that doesn't hold up to scrutiny, contradict yourself, and providing scenarios for you to act out which will place you in confirmed townie camp, when in reality nothing you've provided can confirm you without the help of someone else.

Re-read edit: That whole paragraph sounds really harsh, but not sure how else to phrase it.

I'm not following this. Exactly what information could he release after a lock that wouldn't be relevant before a lock? He's already revealed Noodle's colors, and Noodle confirmed it. Guess maybe I need this one spelled out for me.

If he found another scum, Noodle being locked or not doesn't matter all that much tbh. Although I want to see Noodle go, I'd rather see your flip today I think. Then we can deal with Noodle and whatever Bipolar confirms tomorrow. Heck we can start the pressure on person x even after the lock.

Unvote: Noodle
Vote: NumbersInMyName

I wouldn't say I tried hard, but that I'd rather accomplish multiple goals simultaneously. I never said I was a mastermind, but Drixx and one other person both said that it seemed like i had engineered this entire scenario specifically to create a situation where I could confirm myself as town. The information before and after a lock can change who gets locked? And as long as he makes sure the information gets out before day end, him getting nk'd has at least confirmed some town for us. For example, had I not claimed in order to save the town a day spent lynching noodle, who might not be the best target right now, we wouldn't have votes split between two individuals with 6 hours to go. Honestly it's rather unlikely that BPC, if town, would manipulate the town by having them lynch a neutral over a scum, had he found one., but it's at least a possibility.

I'd like to see a vote from Numbers and BPC to be followed by a vote count. Doesn't matter who you vote for. It's just to see if your votes count.

Vote: Jcakes

belated OMGUS! and There you go Moar. However, I would normally vote for Noodle right now, since the choice is apparently between myself and him, and I know he's neutral and I'm town. I would however prefer that our discussion go longer before either myself or Noodle are locked.

 

[Caluin Graye]

We do indeed need to lynch scum instead of neutrals.

We need to lynch known variables before lynching guesswork. Do you know for absolute certain that Numbers is scum? If we lynch Numbers today, how many other probable scum should we lynch before we finally remove the neutral?

I would like to ask an opinion question, would lynching Noodle do anything to cement BipolarChemist as a townie??

Since Noodle has already self-admitted to being non-town, there's nothing to be learned about BPC from Noodle's lynch.

 

[Bad Ash]

I was and am very tired so can someone tell me what I am missing?

Numbers unprovoked and unpressured cops to the Gwaihir kill claims he is a vigilante and wants help deciding who to use another shot on and a lot of people say Noodle and then vote numbers.

There were some long posts in there so not sure there was a key point I missed.


Also @cg if there is a chance for three kills tonight I would like some more insight into your post that you hinted about.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

 

[Caluin Graye]

Also @cg if there is a chance for three kills tonight I would like some more insight into your post that you hinted about.

By talking about it, I put someone else's life on the line tonight, so I'm going to be a bit vague.

There are only two scenarios for two deaths tonight. Scenario A is if I'm one of the victims. Scenario B is not worth discussing today, but might be tomorrow.

All other scenarios lead to either one death or three+ deaths.

 

[Kestegs]

I would like to ask an opinion question, would lynching Noodle do anything to cement BipolarChemist as a townie??

I think the fact that he outed a mafia and a recruitable make his probability of being town very high. We can throw in the possibility of a buss, but there's not much else I see. I don't think that actually lynching Noodle changes anything.

By talking about it, I put someone else's life on the line tonight, so I'm going to be a bit vague.

There are only two scenarios for two deaths tonight. Scenario A is if I'm one of the victims. Scenario B is not worth discussing today, but might be tomorrow.

All other scenarios lead to either one death or three+ deaths.

That makes no sense, but okay.

But you're basically saying that you wouldn't be surprised to see 1, 2, 3 or more deaths, so you're basically saying nothing at all.

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

I was and am very tired so can someone tell me what I am missing?

Numbers unprovoked and unpressured cops to the Gwaihir kill claims he is a vigilante and wants help deciding who to use another shot on and a lot of people say Noodle and then vote numbers.

There were some long posts in there so not sure there was a key point I missed.


Also @cg if there is a chance for three kills tonight I would like some more insight into your post that you hinted about.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

Most people actually said not noodles, because that's a flip they want to see, and others said I simply shouldn't shoot at all tonight. They're voting for me because they're suspicious of my desire to use my shot to help me prove myself as town. It seems to appear to those voting for me that if I were truly town I wouldn't be concerned with confirming myself as town if at all possible. That, coupled with me appearing scummy in general, has led to the votes. At least, that's my understanding of the reasons given. I may have missed some other good reasons.

 

[Caluin Graye]

That makes no sense, but okay.

But you're basically saying that you wouldn't be surprised to see 1, 2, 3 or more deaths, so you're basically saying nothing at all.

It makes perfect sense, you're just not seeing the big picture.

The reason I mention it is because if we see three deaths tonight, the town will likely freak out. I wanted to make it known that such an occurrence was not unforeseen and unlikely to happen again.

 

[Drixx]

CG ... I'm starting to worry about you. The only scenario in which I can think of that would result in 3 deaths, with what we currently know, is if numbers is telling the truth, and there really is two scum factions and both factions and numbers all kill.

You seem to know something we don't and suspect you might die tonight. Don't you think it might be helpful to let us know what you know so that it doesn't go to the grave with you if you turn out right? Ultimately you have to judge whether the info you have that we don't is valuable enough to the town to give it to the scum team(s), but right now I'm just confused and I think I'm not alone.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Don't you think it might be helpful to let us know what you know so that it doesn't go to the grave with you if you turn out right? Ultimately you have to judge whether the info you have that we don't is valuable enough to the town to give it to the scum team(s), but right now I'm just confused and I think I'm not alone.

I respect that you and others are confused, but that's intentional. A unfortunate byproduct of keeping information out of the hands of the scum.

 

[CoolguyBad]

I'm leaning towards Numbers for now, but will vote whichever way guarantees a lynch.

Vote: IWantToUseNumbersInMyName

 

[Laarz]

I only have a couple of minutes and have to head back to work.

I'm leaning toward Noodle needing to go soon but my vote will be on

Vote: Numbers.