Zombies invade Atlantis. Stargate zombie Mafia game.

Bad Ash said:
Hijacked by Cakes. Throw this bullet onto the list:

-thinks the 99% confirmed doc is anti-town

lol. How much more zombie does it get?
Click to expand...

Confirmed but who? You.....
 
Vote tally Day 7 (5/6):
Jcakes - 6 (Bad Ash, Drixx, korialstraz, AnnualAntAnswers, Laarz, Moar)
Drixx - 2 (Jcakes, flubbucket)
flubbucket - 1 (IWantToUseNumbersInMyName)

Jcakes has been locked.
 
Jcakes said:
Confirmed but who? You.....
Click to expand...

I have a bit more time so I will explain this. You say he is 99% confirmed town. How? The only confirmation we have is from you, he claims to be a doc and claims to have saved bpc and failed. How does that add up to 99% confirmed?
 
Laarz is far from confirmed. BA is the only person who has offered any info about him. The bpc save and fail makes him more likely to be real than not imo. He could have created any sequence of night actions he wanted, as long as he included targeting CG on the night he lost all his injuries. Why would he create a sequence that has him targeting BPC on the same night he's killed?
 
@Moar, you asked to heat from people who supported the vig shot and that would include me, though my enthusiasm has somewhat waned given all the arguments about the late stage of the game and the possibility of investigation being influenced by either an instant infection early in the night or a mechanic which causes a turn to happen with a delay from the time of infection. More than anything, I just wanted to see Numbers actually use the shot so we can have verification of its existence. I lean towards trusting Numbers but it seems possible that the shot was falsely claimed earlier and then Numbers just held off on using it long enough that now we're too afraid to use it because of the chance of mistake. Numbers has been making a point of suggesting vig shots early in the day but has always reneged by day's end. This could be honest but I wanted to have some proof that it works.
 
Drixx said:
Because Bad Ash revealing Jcakes as a zombie lines up with Jcakes' actions yesterday and today. The only way Jcakes is logically not a zombie is if Bad Ash is lying, but Jcakes isn't trying to discredit Bad Ash. Instead he's tried to come after me and get this to be between me and him, but I'm not the one who brought forward evidence against him. He claims that he's 100% townie (about 10 times in the last 2 pages) but he's acting like scum. Scum try to stay alive at any cost. A townie (especially one whose ability makes almost no sense in the wider context of the game and is no longer useful) would gladly trade themselves for a scum.

Jcakes should be pleased as punch to die today because if he were telling the truth that would mean his death gets at least 1 scum (Bad Ash) and possibly two (if I were BA's scum partner). Instead he's doing everything he can to stay alive. It's not townie play. Thus, I'm 99.99% sure that BA is telling us the truth, because what he has told us lines up completely with everything we know and with how Jcakes is behaving today.



In this case, and any case where we have an investigator giving us someone they are confirming as scum, the alignment of the investigator is irrelevant. We cannot afford to let a probable zombie stay alive. He claims to be town but if he really was town he would be happy to be lynched because his "ability" is useless and if he was town and flipped town, it would mean Bad Ash dies and I'm fairly sure me shortly afterward. And yet he's clinging to his undeath with such fervor. It doesn't logically make any sense.

I particularly like the part where he's claimed I'm both scum AND a zombie, since I apparently "dodged" his test of me.



If Jcakes were to flip town, we already know how the next bit plays out. Numbers shoots Bad Ash tonight, the scum kill someone tonight, and then tomorrow I get killed. I'm fully cognizant of the bad turn in store for me if I believed the wrong person.




Jcakes should have something to do with your vote. Leaving a zombie alive is never wise.
Click to expand...

Not going to filter the quote, but I disagree 100% with your statement about being happy with the trade. It is not a 1 for 1 trade, it is my life plus numbers ability (assuming it is not blocked). Tomorrow we are three town votes down (mine, whoever dies tonight and numbers). If numbers ability is blocked it is even worse for town as we are two votes down and have to spend a day phase lynching ba.

Can you see why I'd rather lynch a mafia today then trade my life for one in a day's time? Especially with mylo and lylo soon.
 
Laarz said:
I am town, period!!!! You cast doubt on the doc earlier as being scum, that is one of the reasons I voted you.
Click to expand...

What is your proof? BA cleared you? LOL like that is worth anything?
 
IWantToUseNumbersInMyName said:
Laarz is far from confirmed. BA is the only person who has offered any info about him. The bpc save and fail makes him more likely to be real than not imo. He could have created any sequence of night actions he wanted, as long as he included targeting CG on the night he lost all his injuries. Why would he create a sequence that has him targeting BPC on the same night he's killed?
Click to expand...

Avenge me well numbers, I want BAs death to be as painful as possible :)
 
IWantToUseNumbersInMyName said:
I'd think a role block would still allow me to vote tomorrow, since my ability wouldn't be able to be used. Unless there's some other way of blocking me that you think the scum can likely use?
Click to expand...

You should be able to vote. So in the scenario that your kill doesn't go through town will only be down 2 votes tomorrow, but will need to waste a day lynching ba.
 
Eh, a day spent lynching BA isn't terrible. It's the scenario where I shoot a town, and we lynch a town right now, that's frightening. That's unlikely to occur. ^^ Of course, if you flip town, and we have to get rid of BA, we're kind of shooting randomly from that point forward. :D
 
Town, tomorrow before you do anything consider lylo and mylo. I am pretty sure we have 3 mafia left (4 mafia in a game this big with two factions is about right)
 
Jcakes said:
What is your proof? BA cleared you? LOL like that is worth anything?
Click to expand...

BA doesn't have to clear me,I know what my role is and my alignement, I have told you that I am town, you choose not to beleive me, thats up to you, with all you keep doing you just seem to get more scummy. You just want someone to argue with.
 
IWantToUseNumbersInMyName said:
Eh, a day spent lynching BA isn't terrible. It's the scenario where I shoot a town, and we lynch a town right now, that's frightening. That's unlikely to occur. ^^ Of course, if you flip town, and we have to get rid of BA, we're kind of shooting randomly from that point forward. :D
Click to expand...

Worse than if we'd just lynched drixx today.
 
Laarz said:
BA doesn't have to clear me,I know what my role is and my alignement, I have told you that I am town, you choose not to beleive me, thats up to you, with all you keep doing you just seem to get more scummy. You just want someone to argue with.
Click to expand...

With BA being scum and you still alive after he apparently discovered you, it is less likely you are town.
 
Oh well I am off, see you in the dead thread tomorrow scum ash. Hopefully drixx follows soon after
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top