Zombies invade Atlantis. Stargate zombie Mafia game.

[Jcakes1]

And if you weren't a mafia role cop and were just a regular role cop and received CBG as a zombie what would you be doing?

If you were genuinely concerned about the well being of the town you would have, ya know, used your power role to help us narrow down the list of candidates.

Irrelevant since you are a mafia role cop, you may not even be a role cop at all given we've not seen any information from you that wasn't already available in thread.

The facts as they stand from my point of view I got a non-zombie result from CGB. CGB dies over night and you are claiming that you investigated him and he came up zombie. What am I to make of that? If I do get lynched then atleast you will follow me if numbers is good on his word. I did attempt to use it on Drixx. He deliberately dodged the ability (he quoted every other post of mine except that one), make of that what you will.

 

[Bad Ash]

Jcakes has nothing to do with my vote or reason for posting or thinking on this matter. Only Drixx' scumminess.

Indeed.

Liar

Irrelevant since you are a mafia role cop, you may not even be a role cop at all given we've not seen any information from you that wasn't already available in thread.

The facts as they stand from my point of view I got a non-zombie result from CGB. CGB dies over night and you are claiming that you investigated him and he came up zombie. What am I to make of that? If I do get lynched then atleast you will follow me if numbers is good on his word. I did attempt to use it on Drixx. He deliberately dodged the ability (he quoted every other post of mine except that one), make of that what you will.

Then why isn't your vote for me? Would love to hear that answer


Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk

 

[flubbucket1]

Liar



Then why isn't your vote for me? Would love to hear that answer


Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk

Fatty...Indeed

 

[Jcakes1]

Then why isn't your vote for me? Would love to hear that answer

It is quite simple.
- I know that I am town
- I am also fairly confident that you and drixx are part of a scum team
- I'd rather have scum lynched then town.
- It is more likely that I can get enough people to lynch drixx than you
- hence I vote for Drixx

basically if it came down to a choice between me and you, I think town would chose to lynch me. This is bad for the town from my point of view because I know that I am town. There is a higher chance of town lynching Drixx and thus I think it is better for the town for me to vote that way.

to summarize

I vote for you => it is likely that I get lynched instead => townie lynched => numbers has to use his ability on you overnight => two less town votes tomorrow (me and numbers) = bad for town
I vote for drixx => chance that drixx gets lynched instead of me => scum lynched => good for town

 

[ThunderCat]

Vote tally Day 7 (5/6):
Jcakes - 4 (Bad Ash, Drixx, korialstraz, AnnualAntAnswers)
Drixx - 3 (Moar, Jcakes, flubbucket)

 

[Jcakes1]

Vote tally Day 7 (5/6):
Jcakes - 4 (Bad Ash, Drixx, korialstraz, AnnualAntAnswers)
Drixx - 3 (Moar, Jcakes, flubbucket)

Well I am off to bed and given that it looks likely I will be lynched today, just wanted to make my scum list perfectly clear.

1. BA (wont be an issue as Numbers should take care of him tonight once I am cleared)
2. Drixx
3. I am starting to think Laarz might be scum number 3, particularly given the only evidence we have is BA clearing him. I mean so far we've not had a single save from him other than a supposed failed save on BPC. Not sure what to make of that. Other candidates for the number 3 spot are flubb and antswers.

As for town. I think Korial and Numbers are town. Moar I am a little iffy on, but she doesn't appear to be working with Drixx so she has that going for her.

BTW I think it is likely there are three mafia remaining, so make sure before you do anything you consider MYLO and LYLO. Good luck town we're going to need it as currently mafia are calling all the shots.

 

[Bad Ash]

Irrelevant since you are a mafia role cop, you may not even be a role cop at all given we've not seen any information from you that wasn't already available in thread.

The facts as they stand from my point of view I got a non-zombie result from CGB. CGB dies over night and you are claiming that you investigated him and he came up zombie. What am I to make of that? If I do get lynched then atleast you will follow me if numbers is good on his word. I did attempt to use it on Drixx. He deliberately dodged the ability (he quoted every other post of mine except that one), make of that what you will.

Make of it what I will? I am a role cop who has investigated Drixx and got vanilla. So I will make of it that if he is anti-town I am almost 100% certain that he is not a zombie which means you made up your ability otherwise you might have actually tried to use it for something.

Want to know what I am 100% sure of? That CBG was a zombie which makes you a liar.

Reasons JCakes is scum:
-Tried to steer the lynch off DJM yesterday
-Cleared CBG as a non-zombie, CBG was a zombie
-Didn't use his "town power-role" to the benfit of the town
-Didn't discuss the use of his "town power-role" with the rest of the town
-Barely acknowledges that he has a "town power-role" anymore
-Won't answer hpotheticals
-Has the support of the other accused potential zombie flub
-Won't acknowledge known facts from previous days that discredit him

 

[Bad Ash]

Hijacked by Cakes. Throw this bullet onto the list:

-thinks the 99% confirmed doc is anti-town

lol. How much more zombie does it get?

 

[Drixx]

I see this post as most troublesome for three reasons.

1) How can you be 99.99% sure of Bad Ash' truthfulness??

Because Bad Ash revealing Jcakes as a zombie lines up with Jcakes' actions yesterday and today. The only way Jcakes is logically not a zombie is if Bad Ash is lying, but Jcakes isn't trying to discredit Bad Ash. Instead he's tried to come after me and get this to be between me and him, but I'm not the one who brought forward evidence against him. He claims that he's 100% townie (about 10 times in the last 2 pages) but he's acting like scum. Scum try to stay alive at any cost. A townie (especially one whose ability makes almost no sense in the wider context of the game and is no longer useful) would gladly trade themselves for a scum.

Jcakes should be pleased as punch to die today because if he were telling the truth that would mean his death gets at least 1 scum (Bad Ash) and possibly two (if I were BA's scum partner). Instead he's doing everything he can to stay alive. It's not townie play. Thus, I'm 99.99% sure that BA is telling us the truth, because what he has told us lines up completely with everything we know and with how Jcakes is behaving today.

2) When is alignment ever irrelevant??

In this case, and any case where we have an investigator giving us someone they are confirming as scum, the alignment of the investigator is irrelevant. We cannot afford to let a probable zombie stay alive. He claims to be town but if he really was town he would be happy to be lynched because his "ability" is useless and if he was town and flipped town, it would mean Bad Ash dies and I'm fairly sure me shortly afterward. And yet he's clinging to his undeath with such fervor. It doesn't logically make any sense.

I particularly like the part where he's claimed I'm both scum AND a zombie, since I apparently "dodged" his test of me.

3) The remaining fluffiness in the post seems little more than subterfuge should Jcakes turn up town.

If Jcakes were to flip town, we already know how the next bit plays out. Numbers shoots Bad Ash tonight, the scum kill someone tonight, and then tomorrow I get killed. I'm fully cognizant of the bad turn in store for me if I believed the wrong person.

Jcakes has nothing to do with my vote or reason for posting or thinking on this matter. Only Drixx' scumminess.

Indeed.

Jcakes should have something to do with your vote. Leaving a zombie alive is never wise.

 

[Moar]

Card game was the usual. Some fun some PITA. I love Settlers of Catan. It's great for a rainy afternoon with friends.

Been playing POE all day and didn't check here. I'll vote Jcakes. He's on my scum list as well as Drixx and AAA. I think Jcakes and Drixx/AAA are from two factions and are the last 3 anti town around. So I do not necessarily agree with shooting BA tonight. Can somebody please give me a clear case why BA has to be town if Jcakes is a Zombie? I think BA can very well be a mafia role cop, I just don't see what that has to do with Jcakes being a Zombie or town. There was no result on Jcakes revealed. It all seems to be bout CGB. CGB could have been infected last night, so Jcakes gets his read before infection (and probably infects him by night) while BA gets his read after infection has taken place.

So please, for the logically challenged, explain to me exacly why BA should be shot tonight if Jcakes proves to be town.

 

[Moar]

Forgot to unvote and to state that I would prefer to be the locking vote to avoid anybody I think is town running into a bomb. I'll be around til days end.

Unvote: Drixx

Also, Drixx is still my #1 scum suspect and I will want to lynch him tomorrow if nothing counterindicating happens.

 

[Laarz]

Numbers, I want you to place a vote to see if it counts, I dont care who you vote just do it.

 

[Laarz]

I'm not voting until I see it and I dont think others should either.

 

[Bad Ash]

Card game was the usual. Some fun some PITA. I love Settlers of Catan. It's great for a rainy afternoon with friends.

Been playing POE all day and didn't check here. I'll vote Jcakes. He's on my scum list as well as Drixx and AAA. I think Jcakes and Drixx/AAA are from two factions and are the last 3 anti town around. So I do not necessarily agree with shooting BA tonight. Can somebody please give me a clear case why BA has to be town if Jcakes is a Zombie? I think BA can very well be a mafia role cop, I just don't see what that has to do with Jcakes being a Zombie or town. There was no result on Jcakes revealed. It all seems to be bout CGB. CGB could have been infected last night, so Jcakes gets his read before infection (and probably infects him by night) while BA gets his read after infection has taken place.

So please, for the logically challenged, explain to me exacly why BA should be shot tonight if Jcakes proves to be town.

I am not expecting a blanket town expectation based on JCakes alignment and I completely understand how people are still skeptical. All I can do is give my results and tell you guys what I know. I am town.

Also, I highly highly highly doubt that Cakes is town, but I think shooting me if he is is detrimental to the town, I was just saying that I would understand why Numbers would shoot me if he is, and used it as a reason to express how confident I am that Cakes is scum.

 

[Moar]

I'm not voting until I see it and I dont think others should either.

I agree with you there except that I will vote for Jcakes shortly before the day ends. We need a lynch today.

 

[Drixx]

The reasons I'm sure of Jcakes being a zombie:

1.) Yesterday he cleared CGB and said that CGB was not a zombie.
2.) Today Bad Ash told us that CGB was a zombie.

It's possible that both Jcakes and Bad Ash are telling the truth, but the following things would all have to be true, also, for that to be the case:

1.) The zombies would need to be able to recruit power roles (and so far it seems like the only reason vanilla is in the game is to be recruited).
2.) The remaining zombie(s) would have had to have successfully infected CGB last night (if infection was 100% successful AND could get power roles, it would be game over already in favor of the zombies)
3.) The infection would have had to take place immediately (or resolved before the investigation).

It seems very unlikely to me that CGB was infected last night and thus that means either BA is lying or Jcakes lied yesterday. Logically the way we check this is by lynching Jcakes. If Jcakes flipped town, it would be a staggeringly small chance that BA is also town.

 

[Moar]

I am not expecting a blanket town expectation based on JCakes alignment and I completely understand how people are still skeptical. All I can do is give my results and tell you guys what I know. I am town.

Also, I highly highly highly doubt that Cakes is town, but I think shooting me if he is is detrimental to the town, I was just saying that I would understand why Numbers would shoot me if he is, and used it as a reason to express how confident I am that Cakes is scum.

Yes. Your reason is quite alright and is expected od a town you. I want everybody else advocating shoting you to explain to me why that has to be the obvious thingy.

 

[Moar]

The reasons I'm sure of Jcakes being a zombie:

1.) Yesterday he cleared CGB and said that CGB was not a zombie.
2.) Today Bad Ash told us that CGB was a zombie.

It's possible that both Jcakes and Bad Ash are telling the truth, but the following things would all have to be true, also, for that to be the case:

1.) The zombies would need to be able to recruit power roles (and so far it seems like the only reason vanilla is in the game is to be recruited).
2.) The remaining zombie(s) would have had to have successfully infected CGB last night (if infection was 100% successful AND could get power roles, it would be game over already in favor of the zombies)
3.) The infection would have had to take place immediately (or resolved before the investigation).

It seems very unlikely to me that CGB was infected last night and thus that means either BA is lying or Jcakes lied yesterday. Logically the way we check this is by lynching Jcakes. If Jcakes flipped town, it would be a staggeringly small chance that BA is also town.

So you completely exclude that infection could have happened the night before and it took a day to come into play?

 

[Drixx]

So you completely exclude that infection could have happened the night before and it took a day to come into play?

I hadn't thought of that at all actually. That seems kind of mean to Jcakes though. If he's a zombie detector but he can't detect someone who is infected but hasn't transitioned?

Did this occur to you earlier or just now?

 

[Laarz]

I agree with you there except that I will vote for Jcakes shortly before the day ends. We need a lynch today.

I will vote as well but I want to see a vote from numbers that counts, if he cant do that I think CGB's death is from numbers, you need to vote someone numbers, show that it counts.