Re: OT: SPF Mafia Round 9 - Clue.
@goltar - Since each game deals you a new role, it makes no sense. None at all.
Let's recap W_m and then my action.
1) W_M makes a joke (duh)
2) You counter with an outright suspicion claim (which I actually took as a rebuttal joke at the time, guess I was wrong)
3) I make a joke at your expense. I didn't try to defend your wife. I just make a joke.
4) Then you come up with a list of mafia suspects, in which your wife is figured prominently due to RL tells(I kinda agree with Nole here though, allthough I suppose there is no way to counter this). I am listed here as well for defending her??? And then you go ahead and state that the theory behind it is that nobody is supposed to pay any attention to you on day 1.
Let's get something straight here. I am not defending water_moon. Frankly, like almost every round so far, I have difficulties getting a read on her. As far as I know, she could just as easily be mafia as a townie. You are correct in so far that I was attacking you though, and I still am.
Your theory does not make sense, especially seeing I have only played one round with you(my very first game as a town snoop, the other one you hosted) I have made it plain I find it silly to refer to previous games(they should have no bearing whatshowever on this round) but since you apparently find this valid ground to base a theory on:
That round come day 1 Liquid came right out of the night with the claim he saw nolecub outside when he was drinking. That became pretty much the centrepoint of that day's discussion then. You stated early on you saw someone out there as well, and came with a name at the end of day 1(NacRuno). I was butting heads with several people at the time(Sint amongst them).
That was day 1. Night 2, you were recruited by the gang and that lasted for many a day, because no one was paying much attention to you... still. I was the one who pointed you out as a likely suspect and flushed you out. I suppose this is your 'let's get even with Merlin for busting me' spree?
Fine, let me put it this way. I am not going to let you fly under the radar for another game, nor let you walk on evidence presented on such a shaky theory.
vote:goltar
As far as water_moon is concerned, I'll just wait and see what role you have. If it turns out I was wrong and you come out clean, she automatically becomes a suspect on my list.
So far day 1 reads confusion, due to Sint being our host(and thus not here to shepherd the flock) and liq, true to his pre game statement, not contributing overly much day 1. Just like I said the last round, we need a plan to flush the mafiosi out. Now, even without a plan, we might still lynch a couple of mafiosi (since 25% of the players are wicked, as I mentioned before). Since we have no idea on what the potions/meals can do (apparently turn someone silvery white), it is difficult to figure out a way to use these novelty roles in a way that works for the town (apart from the way lukin proposed, which can be useful, but is admittedly minor).
I should propose that the housekeeper protects liquid_evil tonight. (If I may be so bold). He usually submits an excellent suspect list come end day 2, and we can use that as a great guideline.
Apart from goltar, I have few suspicions. Mostly because few people have contributed so far.
- I find it odd that Nac has posted almost nothing yet, especially since he makes useful and valid contributions (he did so last round). Of course, he proved to be mafia then
- Slayer also needs to post.
- I think people who vote based on their own personal agenda are suspicious, to be honest, so I suggest we cast a leery eye at omgwtf. Then again, that might just be a bit of an insider joke.
- Liquid seems to have made cygnus his target of the day. Now he has a lot of credentials in my book due to excellent performances in the previous games, but he seems to have no basis for his claim here.
- I suppose Cygnus made a joke post re thyiad. It sounds entirely too far fetched to be feasible in my book. Besides, the faction that has most to gain from declining meals and potions are the mafia? Townie power roles however should quietly eat and drink what is presented to them? I hope you don't believe in this yourself. I'd hate to see the doc ingest a meal and suddenly turn unconscious for two days or so. As far as I am concerned, the townie powerroles should try to remain inconspicuous and certainly not partake of anything that has a chance of debillitating (spelling?) them for 1 or 2 nights.
I think mafia players would probably have most to gain to appear as a normal townie by simply eating or drinking what is presented to them.
Based on liquid's gut feeling and this odd post, I'll put you on my suspect list for now.
- Lukin seems helpful enough, then again, so does lord nikon. Both have made valid points IMHO, and neither currently resides on my suspect list.
- Massive is faintly suspicious due to his odd request at the start of day 1, but not overly much.
- All the others have posted too little for me to get a good bearing on them. I'm tempted to say that Muzzz is suspicious, but I was the one who said we should only look at this round, and not use previous rounds as a deciding factor here. Besides, his mafia spree HAS to end sometime, doesn't it?
Google