Wow. Leaking scum Goryani.
When does the town ever only lynch mafia? In every game I've played in there are multiple Townie lynches before a Mafia gets lynched. Sometimes we win with a great cop claim. Sometimes we lose with a bussed result.
[highlight]Doing what I suggested would help confirm/deny the recruitment theory.[/highlight]
By lynching all of a role (albeit Beth, Ted, etc), we would see if one of them are mafia. It may take 3 tries, it may take 1 try. Is it really that hard to grasp?
Assume 5 Harry's. One is dead. We lynch the remaining 4 - lets say we get one mafia from them. We lose 3 townies, and what do we know? Do we know there is recruitment? Do we know there is one mafia of each person? How would we tell the difference? I don't see how lynching this way gets more info on game setup than scum hunting. And it seems to me that it is likely to be slower than scumhunting.
This is what makes me think you two are the same person every game. I am very thankful only one of you has an avatar.
I don't think I would have come up with the idea myself, I admit that was a copy on my part.
I think the only useful bit of the roles would be the very last line "You currently have no abilities".
Sath stated to look at the stories he posts and people who receive night PMs will have to act on them. These night PMs could turn people scum, or maybe just give them powers. It seems obvious though that we are all apart of the main cast.
What COULD be a possibility though, is that if anyone IS mafia, their role PM could have just stated "You currently have no abilities, but you are mafia" or something of the likes. A sentence that could VERY easily be altered when faking a claim that was already posted in full.
I think you have a later statement pointing out why this is not the case.
Am I the only soul that thinks OMG's kill was weird? He only had one post in the first two days, so I consider that suspectible to a token lurker lynch. In addition, he did not claim a character. The mafia already knew that a Harry was dead, and thus risking losing another Harry. They had to think that at least some of us would consider lynching a Harry just because if there were only 2 or 3 of them left. It just doesnt make sense.
Another random theory: what if there is no mafia, only Sath as the sphere and we Harry's are to band together and win when there is only Harry's left?
Part 1: Agree. I was trying to figure out why he got targeted, but really have no idea.
Part 2: ..... really?