Zombies invade Atlantis. Stargate zombie Mafia game.
- Thread starter ThunderCat
- Start date
Don't do things halfway - you should also claim to have some very conclusive evidence that I'm scum. Which I'm not.
I don't have conclusive evidence, i just think you're the best bet since no one is interested in Moar or Sathoris and you've played a bit more defensively this game than what I'm (and others) familiar with.
"A bit more defensively"? I explained the situation with Bad Ash and I to someone who had never witnessed it before. If I was playing defensively, I probably would have responded to Bipolarchemist's voting for me instead of ignoring it like I have. I think your definition of "defensively" doesn't coincide with the dictionary's.
Not that. I was fine with that and I may have said so in the thread. I don't remember
lol
Eh, going back and finding your posts there was less than I thought there was. Obviously it felt off to me and still does, though. Not used to seeing effort being put into something like this
Pharphis:
I voted him for two reasons. The first one was his "I got evidence and I'm telling later." He hadn't come up with it yet before my bedtime. So I expressed my opinion with a vote since I knew I wouldn't be around til about now. This part of my vote was not based on him as a person, but on general experience. I'd have voted for anyone doing that. The 2nd reason is based on his gameplay and that is the way he singled me out in twilight. Last game I played with him and he was town, he was acting comletely different. He was more balanced and trying to reason, not playing agressively. He kind of looked at arguments from both sides. The playstyle he has this game I associate with him being mafia. None of the post he made since I went to bed last night convince me that he is town.
Noodle:
He is posting far more than he usually does. Most is BS just like normal though. The post standing out is him explaining something to a newcomer. I still don't see that as a bad thing. I don't get a scum vibe of him, but then I usually never get a vibe of him since he's so lurky. I don't see a reason to lynch him today, but I will vote for him before a no lynch.
Gory:
Way to go with a good power you got. Instead of scumhunting yourself you just sit back and ask others to convince you. Sure, I get it, that's a way of scumhunting also. But saying that outright will make any scum not try to convince you too much and slip. In the end you'll use your own reasoning anyway. You'd not be Gory if you wouldn't. Unless you are scum Gory. Then you'd just try to get the most townie points. I'd vote you, but not today. The chance of lynching a townie on D1 is too high to risk the voting advantage if it is in town hands.
AAA:
Don't know him yet, so can't read him. I won't vote for him.
Drixx:
First game I don't think he's scum, so he probably is. Won't vote him either today though.
Rest of the field:
Ain't got no clue.
I voted him for two reasons. The first one was his "I got evidence and I'm telling later." He hadn't come up with it yet before my bedtime. So I expressed my opinion with a vote since I knew I wouldn't be around til about now. This part of my vote was not based on him as a person, but on general experience. I'd have voted for anyone doing that. The 2nd reason is based on his gameplay and that is the way he singled me out in twilight. Last game I played with him and he was town, he was acting comletely different. He was more balanced and trying to reason, not playing agressively. He kind of looked at arguments from both sides. The playstyle he has this game I associate with him being mafia. None of the post he made since I went to bed last night convince me that he is town.
Noodle:
He is posting far more than he usually does. Most is BS just like normal though. The post standing out is him explaining something to a newcomer. I still don't see that as a bad thing. I don't get a scum vibe of him, but then I usually never get a vibe of him since he's so lurky. I don't see a reason to lynch him today, but I will vote for him before a no lynch.
Gory:
Way to go with a good power you got. Instead of scumhunting yourself you just sit back and ask others to convince you. Sure, I get it, that's a way of scumhunting also. But saying that outright will make any scum not try to convince you too much and slip. In the end you'll use your own reasoning anyway. You'd not be Gory if you wouldn't. Unless you are scum Gory. Then you'd just try to get the most townie points. I'd vote you, but not today. The chance of lynching a townie on D1 is too high to risk the voting advantage if it is in town hands.
AAA:
Don't know him yet, so can't read him. I won't vote for him.
Drixx:
First game I don't think he's scum, so he probably is. Won't vote him either today though.
Rest of the field:
Ain't got no clue.
I can get behind a Noodle vote, but it would only be based off of his first couple of posts being out of character, which isn't a lot to go off of. Pharphis has offered more that make him more scummy to me than Noodle, but the off color posts could mean something, and if it comes down to it I would vote for a Noodle lynch.
Clarifying fact: I'm taking some time off work at the moment, and have a lot more free time than usual. By "taking some time off work" I mean that my position was eliminated, and I was given a year's pay as severance. By "a lot more free time" I mean "nearly infinite free time." Didn't think it was pertinent, but it seems not having to steal a few moments here and there throughout the day has rendered me more able to regularly post.
Oops, I forgot to ask how I singled you out in twilight when you mentioned it. Was it when I asked you what you thought was scummier about Gory than normal?
I wish Sath would show up to answer my question(s)
Wait a sec, are you suggesting you like to post?
Noodle, why don't you give us a short list of who you find scummy/townie? For someone who has some votes on him you've yet to put in any of your newly-available effort into making sure your voice is heard in case you're lynched or NKed
An idle Noodle is the devil's playground....
I'm with Bad Ash. I hate this because it makes me laugh.
Hey I'm town too!!! We could be sisters.
So you're Jesse Pinkman....
Yes.
Here you are doing it again. With Noodle this time. Why are you only asking him? Aren't there plenty others who you'd like to know a scum/town list from in case they die?Wait a sec, are you suggesting you like to post?
Noodle, why don't you give us a short list of who you find scummy/townie? For someone who has some votes on him you've yet to put in any of your newly-available effort into making sure your voice is heard in case you're lynched or NKed
Pharphis, no one strikes me as being quite scummy or pro-town at the moment. Your false claim of having information on AAA was suspicious, but without additional shenanigans I'm inclined to consider it merely reckless at this point. I rarely have strong feelings about people this early in the game, unless I have some sort of power role that gives me info. I don't, in this game.
Because he's a lynch candidate and he isn't behaving like he wants people to know his reads
Of course you have no strong reads. Why would I even ask. And then the vanilla claim at the end. Seems like someone is trying hard not to reveal any info or be lynched
Well I have to go out until sometime after day end so this is my last post.
Not sure why you think I should act like a loose cannon, making wild and unsubstantiated accusations, unless it's because you expect others to act like you do. Have you ever played in a game with me before? This is how I play.
Or someone who has no info to reveal. You and I are very different - when I lack information, I'm honest about it. See above "loose cannon" remark.
Nobody asked, but this is the current state of the text file I'm keeping all of your information in:
1. Caluin Graye
2. pharphis
3. Laarz
4. Bad Ash
5. Gwaihir
6. kestegs
7. BipolarChemist
8. djmbbandie
9. flubbucket
10. Goryani
11. Pyrotechnician
12. AnnualAntAnswers
13. CoolguyBad
14. Sathoris
15. Zokar-Dead
16. Jcakes
17. Noodle
18. Moar
19. Drixx
20. korialstraz
21. IWantToUseNumbersInMyName-obv town
1. Caluin Graye
2. pharphis
3. Laarz
4. Bad Ash
5. Gwaihir
6. kestegs
7. BipolarChemist
8. djmbbandie
9. flubbucket
10. Goryani
11. Pyrotechnician
12. AnnualAntAnswers
13. CoolguyBad
14. Sathoris
15. Zokar-Dead
16. Jcakes
17. Noodle
18. Moar
19. Drixx
20. korialstraz
21. IWantToUseNumbersInMyName-obv town
I think the question was, while DJ's answer would not have been.
Oh, movie quote. That explains a lot then. I was thinking it might have been a slip on him being bussed.
Lol, with friends like these ...
Not actually a vanilla claim.
Anyways, I agree with Moar on Drixx, he seems like he is being very townie. Which makes me suspicious.
I had strong suspicions that phar was pulling a fast one by agreeing with kegs, especially with AA's return comment, but now I am less sure. That said I think he is still the best option for today.
Vote: pharphis
Google