Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
I'll be completely honest and say that I am having a great difficulty in keeping this game sorted out. Between the fact that I know nothing about NCIS, we had 26 people on game start, and 90+ pages in thee day cycles I am just trying to keep up. When I questioned Corax's lynch I thought that there would be better targets available that day and that lynching a lurker might not have been the optimal thing to do that day. Today I'm even more confused than yesterday, and I have changed my opinion and think starting on the lurkers is a good idea.
I also commend Laarz's lurking skills, as his name didn't even come to my mind when thinking about lurkers, which is the exact thing they usually want to accomplish. I would be equally willing to vote laarz as noodle, but as others have said, there is something not quite right with noodle's posts as there normally is, and it should be followed up on.
Of course, since I've made my vote I also am starting to see other players act scummily. Mal is definitely pinging my radar, and what I thought was an auto town confirm on corax seems to be slipping in light of his posts.
So there are a lot of potential lynch targets I see today.
I was mainly after those people who pushing on Noodle due to his 'lurking' (*coughASRRINandCORAX*cough*). I find that line of reasoning to be extremely scummy, mainly because Laarz has a lower post count. The gap widens slightly more when you remove any 'fluff' posts (those with no real content - noodle has two, Laarz three).
Yes, it's true that Laarz was absent Day 1, but even with a few posts (three is about his average?) that only puts him in the ballpark of being even with Noodle.
So... my point was; if we're forming a lynch on Noodle because he's a lurker, then why has nobody mentioned Laarz yet, who's lurking harder than Noodle?
That's why I find corax scummy right now. He sees an easy lynch forming on Noodle and isn't doing any real scum hunting of his own.
Asrrin I find scummy for a slightly different reason, but I wanted to hear his reasoning behind his Noodle vote before I mentioned it. Since I'm already divulging, might as well say it now.
This little bit of hypocriticism I find interesting.
I'll be completely honest and say that I am having a great difficulty in keeping this game sorted out. Between the fact that I know nothing about NCIS, we had 26 people on game start, and 90+ pages in thee day cycles I am just trying to keep up. When I questioned Corax's lynch I thought that there would be better targets available that day and that lynching a lurker might not have been the optimal thing to do that day. Today I'm even more confused than yesterday, and I have changed my opinion and think starting on the lurkers is a good idea.
I also commend Laarz's lurking skills, as his name didn't even come to my mind when thinking about lurkers, which is the exact thing they usually want to accomplish. I would be equally willing to vote laarz as noodle, but as others have said, there is something not quite right with noodle's posts as there normally is, and it should be followed up on.
Of course, since I've made my vote I also am starting to see other players act scummily. Mal is definitely pinging my radar, and what I thought was an auto town confirm on corax seems to be slipping in light of his posts.
So there are a lot of potential lynch targets I see today.