Kestegs
New member
- Aug 27, 2008
- 49,770
- 12
- 3
I do agree that it was a weird subversive play by pyro, he usually presents things more straight forward. There's no reason why any two people in the game can't have different lists right now.
Outbreak: Amish Mafia style - Mini Mafia Game
- Thread starter Goryani
- Start date
I do agree that it was a weird subversive play by pyro, he usually presents things more straight forward. There's no reason why any two people in the game can't have different lists right now.
Kestegs
New member
- Aug 27, 2008
- 49,770
- 12
- 3
Because that's what it looked like to me. He didn't say that until multiple people started calling me scum or possible scum. He didn't say anything about me until then.
I also quoted a very recent post at that time. I read ~20 posts this morning when I woke up and that's the one that stuck out as scummy to me. Now I think i'm just being mixed up by differences with this game setup. I need to think more about it
I'm not saying they have to agree, but usually to have an opinion of someone being townie you usually agree with something they are saying. Do you not agree?
Still fishing.
I'm trying to be more flubbesque, is it making me more difficult to understand?
Kestegs
New member
- Aug 27, 2008
- 49,770
- 12
- 3
I'm not saying they have to agree, but usually to have an opinion of someone being townie you usually agree with something they are saying. Do you not agree?
Still fishing.
I'm trying to be more flubbesque, is it making me more difficult to understand?
Still waiting.
Flub = flub
Pyro = pyro
Pyro + flub = scum
Math.
Your math is all wrong, you forgot to carry the pharphis and add the kestegs to make super scum pharkegaphistegs.
See my previous post where I quoted both of them, their lists are similar to a point but yet have me and CG on completely opposit ends, oh and of course name eachother as most likely townies.
I can't easily see a situation with three was my point. Someone asked me how I came upon a possible vigilante or other town power roles in a small game it's the natural extension of thinking there might be three mafia otherwise the balance just doesn't work.
Hate this post. Its like it's LAMISM
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
- Apr 8, 2006
- 3,629
- 4
- 3
Insofar as I can tell, I don't have one. I suppose since I'm an Amish woman my occupation is popping out babies once a year and tending to the chores and fixing supper?
Hate it all you want. I could claim that I'm the cop and you cannot test me. Claiming today would be stupid for mafia because they will be asked to give results tomorrow. It's even more foolish for town because they cannot give any info yet and make themselves a target tonight since we wouldn't want to send them today as tonight is really their one shot to be useful.
Ergo, it's claims tomorrow you want to be careful of, because, and I repeat... you cannot test them. I don't know what LAMISM is? (Look at me I'm so mafia?) ... and I'm sorry if I'm pointing out the obvious, but other folks have commented that they hadn't gotten that far along yet so it helped I hope.
Ok, so they agree about everything but you and CG.
Why should they agree on you but not CG?
Kestegs
New member
- Aug 27, 2008
- 49,770
- 12
- 3
I rank people based on what I think of them, not based on what others think of them. And I quite commonly have different opinions on who is scum. Saths play to me seems townie. I think the list mechanic could be very useful for outing mafia, assuming one gets a vaccine.
I agree with most of his reads, but I have different opinions on 2. Specifically I felt like you were acting similar to last game with your hit and run posting. Although you have actually held on to a topic here, which seems to be different. CG on the other hand I have no real read on, where as the lowest 4 I have doubts for various reasons.
I think at this point, everyone should have one or two people they'd be willing to vote for, besides themselves. I think it'd be helpful if we listed said people, and help us come to a consensus.
My personal choices, for the moment:
1) Bad Ash
2) Gwaihir
My personal choices, for the moment:
1) Bad Ash
2) Gwaihir
- Apr 8, 2006
- 3,629
- 4
- 3
Right back at ya. My pm didn't mention anything about a job or an occupation, and you asking seems incompatible with what I know to be a vanilla townie role pm, so if you think I should have some sort of occupation information, you've outed yourself as scum or a power role.
I am not comfortable giving anyone a free pass to the box atm.
That would be me, jumping from is there power roles to there is a vig was a big leap for me that didn't make sense.
I didn't say they shouldn't, but I know more about myself then I know of CG at the moment.
I don't agree with this reasoning.
MegaNegaVote: kestegs
A reasonable explanation which I am willing to accept for the time being.
I'll do a lisrt shortly, but I might as well throw this out there or the day phase might go on forever.
Vote: Gwaihir
To the box as of right now.
pharphis - - Don't know/noish
Drixx - Don't know/yesish
kestegs - No
BipolarChemist - Don't know
Bad Ash - Don't know
Gwaihir - Yes
Caluin Graye - Don't know
Sathoris - Yes
pharphis - - Don't know/noish
Drixx - Don't know/yesish
kestegs - No
BipolarChemist - Don't know
Bad Ash - Don't know
Gwaihir - Yes
Caluin Graye - Don't know
Sathoris - Yes
I'm not sold on Sathoris yet but not ruling him out. I still am curious about the early vote before anything was really said.
Any reason for it Sath? Gut feeling/convo starter?
The town PR with three mafia is because that pretty much guarantees a mafia in the (boo?) box WITHOUT power roles and I think that's not balanced. I however think this convo could be distracting and has gone on far enough since we probably won't know till the end.
I'd be willing to vote in Pyro mainly on a gut call. And think Gwaihir has a slight edge to CG for my second spot but not sold on either.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Related to his role or his comments about the women?
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Google