You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
City Mafia Game Thread
- Thread starter Caluin Graye
- Start date
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
I see what you did with the hyperlink here, very creative I must say and sort of resembles something else I've seen before...I'm not trying to turn this on you specifically, I was listing out things that I found that seemed odd throughout the course of the game and that was one of them. The main reason I placed my vote on you was due to your previous interaction with Flubb, which just seemed very out of place and out of the things I was considering at the time I weighted that heavier then what other players were doing. Since playing defensively can get me in trouble I might as well go on the offensive for once and see what kind of response I get from each person however, I would prefer if you chose not to get your revenge because as I saw from watching last game that can be pretty devastating.
Pyrotechnician's "He only followed up with that because... locking me without a defense would be scum tastic":
Not really. If the day had been close to an end, and you still had not written a reply, I would have locked you anyway. Fortunately for you, you made a very solid defense, and, usually, the "believe in me or I'll virtually suicide to prove I'm right" is a product of the newcomer townie's frustration. I know it because I did the same thing the first time I played. Still, you're a backstabber, and I'll get my revenge on a following game.
I see what you did with the hyperlink here, very creative I must say and sort of resembles something else I've seen before...I'm not trying to turn this on you specifically, I was listing out things that I found that seemed odd throughout the course of the game and that was one of them. The main reason I placed my vote on you was due to your previous interaction with Flubb, which just seemed very out of place and out of the things I was considering at the time I weighted that heavier then what other players were doing. Since playing defensively can get me in trouble I might as well go on the offensive for once and see what kind of response I get from each person however, I would prefer if you chose not to get your revenge because as I saw from watching last game that can be pretty devastating.
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Another thought: Ankeli could have the godfather role with his bid positioning and he did make an effort to make us all think he is the treestump. TC having the theif role 2nd to last pick...I guess its plausible. It could be that he killed the real theif and took their role. Too much WIFOM making my head hurt.
Another thought: Ankeli could have the godfather role with his bid positioning and he did make an effort to make us all think he is the treestump. TC having the theif role 2nd to last pick...I guess its plausible. It could be that he killed the real theif and took their role. Too much WIFOM making my head hurt.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Unvote: Valhauros
I'm guessing you mean that he killed the real theif and claimed to have that role after the first night? I guess this could be possible since it definately would be difficult to prove.
Unvote: Valhauros
I'm guessing you mean that he killed the real theif and claimed to have that role after the first night? I guess this could be possible since it definately would be difficult to prove.
RlyehExiled
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Woah lots of posts...
Sorry my post counts sucked today, been super busy since the weekend, I have an hour or so now so I'll read what I can and I'll post before day end (which is 5 hours by my count)
Unvote: Pyrotechnician
Woah lots of posts...
Sorry my post counts sucked today, been super busy since the weekend, I have an hour or so now so I'll read what I can and I'll post before day end (which is 5 hours by my count)
Unvote: Pyrotechnician
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Laarz hasn't made one post this day phase and now would be the time for him to speak up since he could definately confirm or deny a lot right now.
Laarz hasn't made one post this day phase and now would be the time for him to speak up since he could definately confirm or deny a lot right now.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
I guess I see the options as follows:
A) We lynch Laarz, if he comes up the role cop then we know that TC was lying and we have our target for tomorrow
B) We lynch Ankeli, if he comes up godfather, then good for the town, if he doesn't then either a bus driver/roleblocker was in the works or once again TC was bluffing.
C) We lynch Flubb, this won't confirm or deny anyone else as far as I'm aware.
We have to remember that I will be able to use the role thief ability tonight so we may be able to confirm or deny another suspect as well.
I guess I see the options as follows:
A) We lynch Laarz, if he comes up the role cop then we know that TC was lying and we have our target for tomorrow
B) We lynch Ankeli, if he comes up godfather, then good for the town, if he doesn't then either a bus driver/roleblocker was in the works or once again TC was bluffing.
C) We lynch Flubb, this won't confirm or deny anyone else as far as I'm aware.
We have to remember that I will be able to use the role thief ability tonight so we may be able to confirm or deny another suspect as well.
RlyehExiled
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
I can get behind an Ankeli vote, like I said before his post where he said "you all think I took stumpy" seemed fishy. If he is acctually stumpy he wouldn't die anyway.
Pyrotechnition I'd policy vote still on the grounds it kills the role theif and confrims (somewhat) BAs story, but as of now, the general consenus seems to be to move on (And scum voting > policy voting anyway...unless it's jesters...just kill them)
Vote: Ankeli
Subject to change later tonight when I crunch through everything.
I can get behind an Ankeli vote, like I said before his post where he said "you all think I took stumpy" seemed fishy. If he is acctually stumpy he wouldn't die anyway.
Pyrotechnition I'd policy vote still on the grounds it kills the role theif and confrims (somewhat) BAs story, but as of now, the general consenus seems to be to move on (And scum voting > policy voting anyway...unless it's jesters...just kill them)
Vote: Ankeli
Subject to change later tonight when I crunch through everything.
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Who is we? The regular cop is on the list of roles available to the town. Godfather not being immune to role cop is one of the reasons why I thought godfather is less powerful than ninja for mafia. I expect the role cop to receive godfather as a result from investigating the godfather.
Bus driver alone won't cause the no result. Bus driver + interaction with another role is required. That other role is a mystery. It sounds to me like you were blocked or targeted the hider.
What prompted you to google for jailkeeper?The only reason I say these things is because I had to google what a jail keeper was.
Like I said, unless a blocker or bus driver had anything to do with this, godfather seems to be the only plausible option. The godfather is explained as immune to cop investigation. Being that we only have a role-cop and not any other flavor, what other result would I receive?
Who is we? The regular cop is on the list of roles available to the town. Godfather not being immune to role cop is one of the reasons why I thought godfather is less powerful than ninja for mafia. I expect the role cop to receive godfather as a result from investigating the godfather.
Bus driver alone won't cause the no result. Bus driver + interaction with another role is required. That other role is a mystery. It sounds to me like you were blocked or targeted the hider.
You sound certain a bus driver is involved.You are actually right. Right now, either the bus driver reveals himself and we get who was Ankeli switched for, allowing us to kill the godfather, or Ankeli goes. Bucketfull can wait..
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Sorry, been a rough week so far
Goryani, second time you have wanted me lynched,if you are the tracker and i'm so suspect to you, why didn't you check me? I'm not or never was the role-thief or role-cop, I think you are trying to draw attention away from pryo.
Sorry, been a rough week so far
Goryani, second time you have wanted me lynched,if you are the tracker and i'm so suspect to you, why didn't you check me? I'm not or never was the role-thief or role-cop, I think you are trying to draw attention away from pryo.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
The way Goryani puts it makes TC's story less and less convincing. I'm not sure if immune to cop includes rolecop but since it doesn't specifically say its difficult to tell. If somehow his power ended up targeting me (hider) last night it wouldn't have been blocked (obviously since BA was able to take my role) so that is ruled out. Roleblocker is the only logical one out of those if the godfather role works the way Goryani stated.
Who is we? The regular cop is on the list of roles available to the town. Godfather not being immune to role cop is one of the reasons why I thought godfather is less powerful than ninja for mafia. I expect the role cop to receive godfather as a result from investigating the godfather.
Bus driver alone won't cause the no result. Bus driver + interaction with another role is required. That other role is a mystery. It sounds to me like you were blocked or targeted the hider.
The way Goryani puts it makes TC's story less and less convincing. I'm not sure if immune to cop includes rolecop but since it doesn't specifically say its difficult to tell. If somehow his power ended up targeting me (hider) last night it wouldn't have been blocked (obviously since BA was able to take my role) so that is ruled out. Roleblocker is the only logical one out of those if the godfather role works the way Goryani stated.
FredOfErik
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Unvote: Pyrotechnician
Last post of the day for me and it's gonna be a quick one. The day ends in the middle of the night for me and I need to work tomorrow, soo.
I'm still not certain about Pyro. I agree his defense was pretty thorough and it did make him seem quite less scummy to me, but I still have a hard time with him picking hider.
Vote: Ankeli
Unvote: Pyrotechnician
Last post of the day for me and it's gonna be a quick one. The day ends in the middle of the night for me and I need to work tomorrow, soo.
I'm still not certain about Pyro. I agree his defense was pretty thorough and it did make him seem quite less scummy to me, but I still have a hard time with him picking hider.
Vote: Ankeli
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Are you going to give us any more information then that Laarz? Goryani posted who he tracked and why, he must have thought those targets were more important at the time.
Are you going to give us any more information then that Laarz? Goryani posted who he tracked and why, he must have thought those targets were more important at the time.
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
What Goryani said
Roleclaim time:
I'm the tracker. N1 I tracked Ankeli but Ankeli didn't target anyone. N2 I tracked Noodle the voteless but Noodle didn't target anyone. I'm confident I can tell if I'm roleblocked. I wasn't rolebloked either night.
I must have missed the why he tracked who he did, maybe you could point it out to me.
What more do you want from me?
Are you going to give us any more information then that Laarz? Goryani posted who he tracked and why, he must have thought those targets were more important at the time.
What Goryani said
Roleclaim time:
I'm the tracker. N1 I tracked Ankeli but Ankeli didn't target anyone. N2 I tracked Noodle the voteless but Noodle didn't target anyone. I'm confident I can tell if I'm roleblocked. I wasn't rolebloked either night.
I must have missed the why he tracked who he did, maybe you could point it out to me.
What more do you want from me?
Caluin Graye
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Two hour warning. Day ends in two hours, 9 minutes.
Current vote count:
Ankeli (4): Valhauros; RlyehExiled; Bad Ash; FredofErik
Pyrotechnician (2): ThunderCat; flubbucket
flubbucket (1): Ankeli
Laarz (1): Goryani
Two hour warning. Day ends in two hours, 9 minutes.
Current vote count:
Ankeli (4): Valhauros; RlyehExiled; Bad Ash; FredofErik
Pyrotechnician (2): ThunderCat; flubbucket
flubbucket (1): Ankeli
Laarz (1): Goryani
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
I'm sorry, you are right, he did not mention why he choose those targets, it was TC that said why he choose Ankeli with his power.
I guess what I'm trying to get at is what do you think regarding the reads on the other players, do you think Ankeli is anti-town and TC's story checks out?
Following up on that this almost seems to convienent in a way, knowing my alignment (even if some of you don't believe me) I guess I don't see why Ankeli would defend me if he was anti-town. I know this will probably give you all the more reason to vote for him or me. It just seemed as it became less likely that I would be lynched TC decided it was a good time to reveal his information and his information is very reliant on specific conditions (godfather being immune to rolecop, or a roleblocker). I know this will bite me in the butt if Ankeli actually does come up anti-town but I guess in that situation he may have been trying to gain the towns trust when I would have flipped if thats the only reason he was defending me. Still, the town needs a lynch and the information we get from the flip will help determine tomorrows actions.
Vote: Ankeli
I'm sorry, you are right, he did not mention why he choose those targets, it was TC that said why he choose Ankeli with his power.
I guess what I'm trying to get at is what do you think regarding the reads on the other players, do you think Ankeli is anti-town and TC's story checks out?
Following up on that this almost seems to convienent in a way, knowing my alignment (even if some of you don't believe me) I guess I don't see why Ankeli would defend me if he was anti-town. I know this will probably give you all the more reason to vote for him or me. It just seemed as it became less likely that I would be lynched TC decided it was a good time to reveal his information and his information is very reliant on specific conditions (godfather being immune to rolecop, or a roleblocker). I know this will bite me in the butt if Ankeli actually does come up anti-town but I guess in that situation he may have been trying to gain the towns trust when I would have flipped if thats the only reason he was defending me. Still, the town needs a lynch and the information we get from the flip will help determine tomorrows actions.
Vote: Ankeli
