Breaking Bad Forum Mafia Game
- Thread starter Bad Ash
- Start date
Usually...... Treestumps don't have a valid vote. They can vote, but it just doesn't count. It's how you test them to see if they are a treestump. Also, treestumps usually can't be voted for. Not always, but it's very rare for a treestump to show as having votes on them. Furthermore, treestumps, more often than not, don't count as a living player for the purposes of counting lynch numbers. So if there were 9 living players but one was a treestump, then it would take 4 votes to lynch and not 5. Sometimes, they don't even appear in the living list. The trigger phrase activation is roughly 50/50.
We don't follow mafiawiki to the T. We don't even follow our own roles to the T. Roles common for us don't appear on mafiawiki and the converse is true.
No. This was a very good direction. The route may be strange but I think the destination is aces.
TJ and coju are town.
Does any townie want to corroborate Thomas' claim that townies weren't role blocked? Does any mafia want to fake it?
- Dec 6, 2010
- 5,584
- 309
- 83
You do this and vote glib?
Did my vote for Johnson not go through?
Vote: ThomasJohnson
Yes, this has been the bane of many players that start with us. I think that's what makes these games so fun, is that we are in the Mod's World, and anything (s)he ((has there been a female host? I say next host female, or asexual being)) goes.
After stewing on this, I think you may be correct. It is hard for me to believe TJ to be town after his attack, but I have been there and done that same thing: just get so focused on one person.
As FoE showed, TJ just wanting to vote willy-nilly for someone... Heh... Not too towny there.
I read your claim but not yet the post in which you voted. Yes, thefrenklin, I post before I finish reading the thread.
So you believe that treestump in this particular game is being implemented in a very different fashion that what you stated was typical? And that it's more likely coju is a treestump being handled in an unusual way, than that he is scum with a one time lynch immunity and a power that removes his ability to vote?
So we have a townie that refuses to share thoughts on who he thinks is town/scum? I tried to prod him, and the only reaction he ever showed was when i voted FoE. Who had just visited you that night.
If what Thomas's Johnson' saying is true re: Global Role Block (I'm leaning toward believe), then I will agree vote restriction is town power.
Also my night action was not restricted either. I know that sounds LAMIST but who cares what you Nancy's think any more. I like the logic that has finally bubbled to the surface here.
Looky at FredwardofErica voting me out of the clear blue...
onder:As much as it Horrifies me to claim.
I feel compelled to say something in order to give Tom's genitals some hope. I am a town thief.
Think of the children!! Won't someone think of the children?!?!
Each night I target someone and receive an item or ability. Might night chat with Goryani was stolen and was a one shot ability.
So two things I find interesting 1) this vote restriction is town based is Tom's Johnson is telling truths 2) Goryani figured out vote restriction was town and ding was mafia based on ..... what ???:fortune:..I am amaze
I wish I could vote.
Noodle, do you have an opinion about whom I might "visit" tonight??
I am sincerely interested in your thoughts.
I am sincerely interested in your thoughts.
First off, I would like to appologize for my behaviour last night. I got a little bit carried away after spending way too much time analyzing votes and building theories. All of which proved useless ofc, and it was a tough realization.
That being said, I'd like to go on record with a small addendum:
When I joined this game, I made it plain, that I am very new at this. In fact I only ever played one game of mafia before and that was several years ago; after that only the all SK game, which hardly constitutes your average mafia game. I was told to go ahead and join; I would be more than welcome. Later when the game needed more players, I asked if complete newbies would be considered and was again told that they would be more than welcome. So I put up a couple of threads and even got a few answers in thread and on pm; none of the ones interested chose to play though - and I'm grateful they didn't. Because let's face it guys - this game and the games you are playing here are not rookie friendly games.
I was expecting mafia vs. town with a few twists; what I found was concealed QT-threads, progressive abilities, rule changes on the fly, daytime actions, an unusual treestump, a sociopath not intent on killing, vote restrictions, post restrictions and lord knows what else might be in there. This, to me, does not constitute a good beginner's game, and I would imagine that you loose quite a few first-time players by including them in such games.
I do not blame anyone for not speaking up; I chose to join and should've anticipated complexity. That being said, I seriously think, that you should consider running two games at the time: one game for the rookies and/or the casual player wishing to pop by half an hour after work and another complicated game for the hardcore mafia-player and/or those who like to spend hours imagining every possible scenario. Either that or consider labeling the games with some sort of difficulty rating - after all, I assume this is supposed to be fun and include as many members as possible.
Anyways that was what I needed to get off my chest - and Goldtru I tried to be brief
That being said, I'd like to go on record with a small addendum:
When I joined this game, I made it plain, that I am very new at this. In fact I only ever played one game of mafia before and that was several years ago; after that only the all SK game, which hardly constitutes your average mafia game. I was told to go ahead and join; I would be more than welcome. Later when the game needed more players, I asked if complete newbies would be considered and was again told that they would be more than welcome. So I put up a couple of threads and even got a few answers in thread and on pm; none of the ones interested chose to play though - and I'm grateful they didn't. Because let's face it guys - this game and the games you are playing here are not rookie friendly games.
I was expecting mafia vs. town with a few twists; what I found was concealed QT-threads, progressive abilities, rule changes on the fly, daytime actions, an unusual treestump, a sociopath not intent on killing, vote restrictions, post restrictions and lord knows what else might be in there. This, to me, does not constitute a good beginner's game, and I would imagine that you loose quite a few first-time players by including them in such games.
I do not blame anyone for not speaking up; I chose to join and should've anticipated complexity. That being said, I seriously think, that you should consider running two games at the time: one game for the rookies and/or the casual player wishing to pop by half an hour after work and another complicated game for the hardcore mafia-player and/or those who like to spend hours imagining every possible scenario. Either that or consider labeling the games with some sort of difficulty rating - after all, I assume this is supposed to be fun and include as many members as possible.
Anyways that was what I needed to get off my chest - and Goldtru I tried to be brief
Not likely. I might host a simple game at some point, if you feel that my idea of 2 games simultaneously is good. I have this Seinfeld idea that I'd like to explore. It's very casual and pretty straight-forward. Requires 13 players and should be over within maybe 6-10 (max of 20 days but will never reach that) days. Everyone pretty much knows major content at the beginning.
But atm. it's just on the drawing board, and like I said: it stays there until such a time as two games might coexist.
Well I'm going to the liquor store today, anyone want anything?? Should prove interesting later...
Steal me some scotch.
Have you stolen any useful information to the town?
Ignore lack of spelling and logic, phonestyle
Google