logoutzero
Active member
- Nov 9, 2005
- 1,539
- 91
- 28
I am going to smack anyone that touches my car.
10 people proceed to touch my car. It is very clear that I now have 10 smacks to hand out. There is no ambiguity, the word everyone equals anyone in this context. (1)
And how can I not be sarcastic when people ask dumb questions? (I am not saying yoir questions are dumb).
I don't know how to address it further, I tried to not let it dominate otherwise it comes down to a "me vs logout" which does the town no good if logout is a town listener. My very first post said it was unbelievable, which means I dont believe it. I know I didnt say it (which is obvious) and the one thing I can figure out (if logout made it up or if he really is a listener) I tried to do. It is easy to just say it is his fabrication due to his scum list afterwards does not include me and his vote is not on me, but that leaves the town with no choice and no discussion. But apparently that is what drixx, pyro, moar, and others want.
I can't believe the few people who could somehow think I am the sk out of this. That should be looked at closer.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
1.) I agree 100% with this logic. However, you only have 2 hands, so no matter how hard you try, you cannot smack 10 people in 1 motion. If you start smacking the 10 people (and remember, 1 of the people that touched your car was yourself, so say "cheese!") then you confirm the statement of "I am going to smack anyone that touches my car."
On the other hand, if you choose to let anyone touch your car willy-nilly, without any recourse, then either someone put you up to claim that you will smack anyone that touches your car, or, the car that the 10 people touched was not yours. If any of these 10 people are smacked, we subsequently know that, in-fact, your car was touched, and can extrapolate that you smacked them. If not a single one of these 10 people are smacked, then we know that either the car touched was not yours, or that someone put you up to saying that. I totally just repeated myself there....
As to the rest of it, I'm not sure I follow what you are saying.
"It is easy to just say it is his fabrication due to his scum list afterwards does not include me and his vote is not on me, but that leaves the town with no choice and no discussion."
So, you are saying that, it will be easy to shrug my listen post off as my own fabrication after I am lynched and turn up scum, because I am not currently voting to lynch you? If this is what you mean, what happens when I am lynched and turn up Town? Major egg on your face!
This post reeks scum.
@logoutzero
Have you played mafia in any way before this game?
I have never played forum mafia, or parlour mafia, in any form before this game. I have, however, taken part in many "who-done-its" and murder mystery type events, which have many similar aspects. The only difference is there is typically only 1 "badguy" in one of these scenarios, but several actors are given "bad" roles to carry out, to cause confusion.