Returning to the Roots - Mini mafia game

[Kestegs]

Kestegs, apart from giving us some Forum Mafia statistics, have you anything else to add? As a hardcore spammer, your lack of activity is already giving me a huge Scum read on you. Bad Ash looks to be doing some serious LAMIST action.

Vote: kestegs

Sorry for having a life outside of mafia.

I didn't even really do the things you said, but whatever. If you rally think that me "lurking" is a scum tell, then okay I guess.

My list:

Gory: first vote is a bit troubling
Phil: he's felt scummy all game, can't exactly put it to words, but it's there past what others have said.
Solar: omgus if you will, but it's a piss poor reason to vote for me and he knows it.

 

[Zokar1]

Vote: Philli

Talking, but not about this game. A good way to appear visible and yet stay hidden.

What makes you more comfortable voting for him over Moar or Gwaihir?

 

[Solar Ice]

Sorry for having a life outside of mafia.

Apology accepted!

I didn't even really do the things you said, but whatever. If you rally think that me "lurking" is a scum tell, then okay I guess.


My list:

Gory: first vote is a bit troubling
Phil: he's felt scummy all game, can't exactly put it to words, but it's there past what others have said.
Solar: omgus if you will, but it's a piss poor reason to vote for me and he knows it.

Yet I see no interest from you to find out about any of the players that you mentioned or anyone else. I see no votes from you for them or anyone else. That is why my vote stands.

 

[Kestegs]

Apology accepted!



Yet I see no interest from you to find out about any of the players that you mentioned or anyone else. I see no votes from you for them or anyone else. That is why my vote stands.

That was sarcasm. Apology accepted rejected.

I think enough questions have been asked and those two people have already responded to my satisfaction or not posted since the questions have been posed and I have no further questions at this time.

There's no reason to vote right now, I only vote early if I'm actually convinced of something, not just on suspicion.

 

[Gwaihir]

Apology accepted rejected.

Wait, you can do that? Woah!

 

[Kestegs]

Yes, I have skills.

 

[Solar Ice]

That was sarcasm. Apology accepted rejected.

Do take note of the smiley in my previous post.

I think enough questions have been asked and those two people have already responded to my satisfaction or not posted since the questions have been posed and I have no further questions at this time.

There's no reason to vote right now, I only vote early if I'm actually convinced of something, not just on suspicion.

I do not quite follow your logic.

You state that you are satisfied with the responses given thus far, or saw no response as of yet (in Goryani's case, I presume) and those responses are enough to place someone on your Scumlist. Yet no vote for a person that you consider Mafia? Conclusion: you are not really interested in lynching Scum? And I think I do not have to state which group is not interested in lynching Scum.

 

[Goryani]

Did cg say there would be day talk for mafia? Or is that a slip

3) Day will be 48 hours, night 24 hours. No posting in thread during night. We will be starting with a day phase. Mafia will have day talk.

^ .

 

[Goryani]

Random Question for Everyone:
If you were mafia, which of the 6 setups would you most hate to face?

All the replies I've seen so far have said cop + JK. I gotta disagree. I think the toughest would be JK + doc. In a game with 9 players, a single prevented NK is like adding 2 VTs to the townie side. JK + doc effectively have 3 chances per night to stop a NK. The kicker: JK + doc can help the town without claiming. Also: when a JK + doc claims, there might be more confirmed townies than when a JK + cop claim.

 

[Goryani]

You come out with a vote on Bad Ash right off the bat in Assassin in the Castle with an equally flimsy reason. You were the Assassin in that game. Coincidence?

No coincidence as it was deliberate. I wanted to see who would first point this out and how long it took them. You win!

I like how you shoot down my reason and at the same time put more pressure on BA. If you wanted to put pressure on BA, why not throw and extra vote on the train and see what happens? Or is that too risky for your team?

 

[Kestegs]

Do take note of the smiley in my previous post.




I do not quite follow your logic.

You state that you are satisfied with the responses given thus far, or saw no response as of yet (in Goryani's case, I presume) and those responses are enough to place someone on your Scumlist. Yet no vote for a person that you consider Mafia? Conclusion: you are not really interested in lynching Scum? And I think I do not have to state which group is not interested in lynching Scum.

Yes, I saw your " " scumtell.

Yes, those people are on my scum list. No, I am not convinced any of them are for sure scum yet. I already explained why I didn't vote for any of them yet.

 

[Goryani]

We'll depend much more on basic scumhunting and there are less possibilities for scum to hide.

Random Vote: Ankeli

Reason: A coinflip? Really?

Example of basic scumhunting or example of scum hiding? I can't decide.

 

[Goryani]

Not going to vote yet until there's some more discussion, more chances to catch someone slipping up.

Someone wants to vote but not participate in discussion... and admits it.

 

[Solar Ice]

No coincidence as it was deliberate. I wanted to see who would first point this out and how long it took them. You win!

I like how you shoot down my reason and at the same time put more pressure on BA. If you wanted to put pressure on BA, why not throw and extra vote on the train and see what happens? Or is that too risky for your team?

Only thing is, I was unsure of what *your* motivations were for casting that vote in the first place. Why would I hop into your train when I found the train conductor's destination questionable?

 

[Goryani]

In the more complicated games, there tends to be ways of catching mafia in a lie with a mass claim. I can't really see that helping town at any point in this game, as mafia can lie to easily and be uncatchable in this setup.

I took out an aside to make the sentence easier to read.

A mass claim can still catch mafia in a lie. If we all claim today, will mafia risk claiming a power role or will they all claim VT? Mafia won't have the benefit of a NK to hide behind.

Random question for everyone:
Do you think massclaim today, on D1, is beneficial for the town? If not, what day is the last day for a mass claim to be helpful? (ok, two questions)

 

[Goryani]

How is cop/jailer better than cop/doc?

cop/doc is stronger only if the cop claims first and a doc is around to save the cop. Barring that situation, jailer is just stronger than a doc.

 

[Goryani]

Mafia actions are not limited by their numbers. In other words, so long as the rolecop is alive, mafia may use both abilities each night.

The goon performs the kills if he is alive.

Whoa. Especially the goon = hitman part.

 

[Goryani]

http://www.purediablo.com/forums/showthread.php?795323-Forum-mafia-statistics-and-awards/page44

Link to mafiascum is on that page.

I'm reading the links and they say the opposite:
"The Mafia Role Cop is allowed to both submit the nightkill and perform his Role Cop action, no matter whether the Goon is dead or not; see this thread, among others, for discussion on the matter."

The bolded is the important part. It's opposite of what you said and what CG posted.

Unvote: Bad Ash
Vote: Moar

 

[Goryani]

There's no reason to vote right now, I only vote early if I'm actually convinced of something, not just on suspicion.

It's possible to show interest without voting, you know.

 

[Moar]

Didn't think about that. I assumed the goon was the killer as long as he lived. Checked the link from the other thread and it says there that the role cop can do both no matter if the goon is alive.

This I said before CG said what he said.

I'm reading the links and they say the opposite:
"The Mafia Role Cop is allowed to both submit the nightkill and perform his Role Cop action, no matter whether the Goon is dead or not; see this thread, among others, for discussion on the matter."

The bolded is the important part. It's opposite of what you said and what CG posted.

Unvote: Bad Ash
Vote: Moar