Mafia game thread
- Thread starter Sathoris
- Start date
Solar Ice
Well-known member
- Nov 4, 2008
- 4,525
- 39
- 48
I know full well that he does have a vote on you. It did not make the merits of your analysis less valid from what I saw.
I think we should lynch a Harry since one of them is probably already "converted". Problem is that we only have 2 claims for Harry. Anda converted one would not claim that he is Harry. So we probably should lynch somebody that has not claimed or claimed something else. Or the converted Harry would claim Harry to look innocent. ARRRGHHH! I don't think I should play mafia games...
What is going on? This got very odd very fast. I can supply our last missing name, and a Gory style PM - it is close, but something may or may not have been changed.
I find our odd man out to be the most worrisome. When everyone else is in the movie and he is not - seems unlikely to be true.
Vote: Malevolent
Sathoris said:
I find our odd man out to be the most worrisome. When everyone else is in the movie and he is not - seems unlikely to be true.
Vote: Malevolent
I can't help but feel that based on what's been said, and one of my previous posts, I am inclined to do the same...
Unvote: kestegs
Vote: Malevolent
Unless Mal can provide a good reason to not do so that is...
Solar Ice
Well-known member
- Nov 4, 2008
- 4,525
- 39
- 48
Solar Ice
Well-known member
- Nov 4, 2008
- 4,525
- 39
- 48
Vote: Pyrotechnician
I won't vote for Malevolent today. For one, he's not giving the same vibes as he normally gives. His vibes, while still there, are different this game. For another, Mal's past scumminess hasn't been to spill significant mafia secrets (such as if mafia know there are multiple Harry's, Norman's Ted's and Beth's). He said those things BEFORE Harry got personal with the sphere and BEFORE recruitment talk.
I'd rather not vote for kestegs today. I'm certainly not ready to declare kestegs townie, but he's passed up several opportunities to prod someone for infoz - something he's had trouble refraining from in the past.
I very much doubt I'll vote for anyone who has claimed today.
I won't vote for Malevolent today. For one, he's not giving the same vibes as he normally gives. His vibes, while still there, are different this game. For another, Mal's past scumminess hasn't been to spill significant mafia secrets (such as if mafia know there are multiple Harry's, Norman's Ted's and Beth's). He said those things BEFORE Harry got personal with the sphere and BEFORE recruitment talk.
I'd rather not vote for kestegs today. I'm certainly not ready to declare kestegs townie, but he's passed up several opportunities to prod someone for infoz - something he's had trouble refraining from in the past.
I very much doubt I'll vote for anyone who has claimed today.
I go with Mal as well. He could very well be the converted Harry who doesn't wanted to admitt being one of the 4. There are 3 more named characters in the wiki entry. If he was one of them, he could easily said so. IIRC he said "somebody not in the film". Additionally he was quite scummy. Might be his general style, but then he has been mafia in previous games that I have been in/read.
Vote: Malevolent
Vote: Malevolent
Because of his participation in the "distancing" discussion and his responses to my questions about said distancing discussion.
No avoiding, it just seemed oddly convienent that your post stating that if you could give a vote on anyone it would be CG and then the very next post is CG stating that there is nothing to find, and that you obviously must be scum (which apparently was a joke). So in this case CG was distancing himself from you.
Hm, so we should lynch anyone that does not have your name, how convienent.
I am also one of the main four, Elizabeth, you changed the word to intimidated from something else. Just incase there is another Beth I will not say what this word was originally so that possibly someone else can be confirmed.
Kestegs
New member
- Aug 27, 2008
- 49,770
- 12
- 3
No, I said we should either lynch Harry or a neutral. That leaves (likely) 12 people I'm not wanting to lynch right now.
I dont think that is quite right, Moar, all three of them have the power from the sphere, because at the end they all wish to forget what they saw. I tthink Harrys fear was the Squid,Normans was Snakes and Beth's was a suicide wish.
So, I am also Beth. I was waiting for someone to fake claim it, but I guess in this game, the only faking may be "I did/didn't" receive any night PMs.
You're right on which word changed, I too will wait on who else claims Beth (4 of each char maybe?) and for the last claim, which would most likely be fake, we can get them to provide the correct word. Below is my light breadcrumb, in the character trait, posted before any claims of Beth.
Role PM:
Elizabeth Halpern
You are Beth Halpern. You’re both gentle and caring while at the same time fierce, combative, and confrontational. As the biologist and only female of the group you often see yourself **** by the male scientists, though some of these times only in your head. This leads to you being the most out of touch with your emotions.
Currently you have no abilities other than your gentleness.
But you didn't say neutral, you said uncliamed, and at that point the only claims were Harrys, Normans, and Mal's "other".
Google