Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
On modkilling:
Leo got a warning and never responded.
Asrrin got a warning and responded.
Feysal got a warning and responded.
Boogyman19946347191987 sent me a PM and advised that he should be modkilled because he was not posting due to RL.
The above had to to with not meeting the post requirement/not posting.
Flubbucket got modkilled for posting after the end of day, and did not take it well:
Flubbucket said:
flubbucket said:
Gorny said:
You're now dead, and the dead tell no tales.
You'll find the MTAC thread here:
http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/ukiF7UTTQ8v
Welcome to capricious application of the rules...
http://www.purediablo.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8062417#post8062417
Feysal...14) You will get mod killed if you are inactive (at least 2 contributive posts a day).
How would you feel if you were treated like this?
It still seems hypocritical given Feysal’s obvious infraction. However, you are the host so you can decide to do whatever you choose. I only joined this game because 1) you invited me and 2) your games are usually fun and unique (I also like NCIS). This late in the game your action felt unexpectedly punitive.
My whole point and reason for modkilling flub was totally different from what happened with Feysal, I pointed out the difference being that Feysal and Asrrin weren't posting enough and were due a warning just like I would give to anyone else in the situation of not posting, and indeed just as other hosts have done in the past.
I also pointed out that Flub's modkill was for posting
after the end of the day when he knew he should now (infact, everyone knows not to), regardless of if the game mod formally ends the day with a closing post. I also pointed out that the flub had posted after the end of the day on two different occasions on separate days this game, the first being visible in the link provided by Flub. He, Flip, Malevolent, Zemaj and Drixx kept posting for a full 18 minutes at the end of day two when they clearly should have stopped.
I overlooked it and gave none of them a warning.
On Day 10, Flub again posted after the end of day, 10 minutes after the start of the night phase. I understand a minute or two and in some instances maybe as much as 5 minutes. But taking into consideration that Flub and 4 others kept posting 18 minutes into the night on day 2 and then on Day 10 Flub posts 10 minutes into the night, I felt a modkill was warranted.
We all know when the day ends, and we know not to post, even if the game mod announces the end of day or not.
Sorry to Flub but I feel that my decision to modkill you was correct and unbiased and not hypocritical, even if you were invited by me, after all you are the one who chose to post after the end of day.
Would I have modkilled someone else in that situation? Yes.
thanks once again!
I liked that, so thanks
