Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
Deleted most of the PMs, but he first had an internet background check from Noammr and phone calls made. Gwaihir's flavour had him making more calls than a normal person would, something like that. Which wasn't misinterpretation, Gwaihir did talk to several people and to more people than a townie should. I only thought of Noammr and then Ryleh being recruited so I went for a cult. I got the anti-town right, doesn't matter what kind of anti-town. Also Gorny told us we were the only masons, which in the end was true. After that I got no flavour at all other than Mrs. Mallard's.
Night 0 you obtained role cop information. You were told of Noammr's night talking and investigation of Rlyeh. If Noammr was still alive on mass claim day, any truthful claim he made could be corroborated against the info you obtained. It would have matched.
Night 1 you were blocked, though I'd be curious to know what result you would have obtained from me. Detect night talking since I wasn't a godfather? Detect nothing since the watcher was used? Detect my use of vote block?
Night 2 has no listing, but I think that is a result of sometimes starting from N0 sometimes starting from N1.
Night 3 you watched/tracked someone without a night action, so no flavor. I think that night you were recruited into the mason group while targeting one of the masons. Simply being recruited told you so much more information than flavor could have provided.
Night 4 you also obtained role cop information as Gwaihir was a night talker. Not only was Gwaihir a night talker, but he was a night talker with multiple groups (mafia and FBI/CIA). I'm guessing that was the cause of the more phone calls than normal flavor. If mafia hadn't already found the mole, your comments would have identified him for us. You also said you knew who Gwaihir targeted, as it was different than the player Gwaihir said he targeted. I'm not sure what flavor was associated with it, but I doubt it matched the flavor of Noammr the investigator. If Gwaihir told the truth of each night's targets and if Malevolent had a post restriction that actually looked like a post restriction, then the case against Gwaihir would have been much tougher to make.
Looking over the notes, it says you received info that Gwaihir targeted both Noammr and Rlyeh on N4. I think N1 with Noammr was figured out, but this night seems off kilter as well.
Incidentally, the misinterpretation comment was referring to what Gorny told you in post 18 of the Navy Yard thread: "You are the only four masons, so work with it as best you can." That comment was, I'm guessing, the source of the your idea that your mason group was the only mason group, hence your suspicion of Noammr and Gwaihir. Gorny told us similar info the next night, though he phrased it differently (Last Man Standing #544): "The mason group won't get any bigger. It was meant to be limited."
Night 5 you did the watcher thing and not the tracker thing. You also targeted a mason partner so not much flavor is needed. The same night, you learned corax obtained a pro-town on Caluin Graye. That might not have meant much with multiple godfathers, but you knew CG visited corax. You knew CG wasn't the mafia roleblocker. A number of possibilities exist, such as pro-town doc or anti-town mafia framer type role. However, again, upon a role claim from CG, you could have determined if his claim was a lie or not.
Night 6 you tracked coju, who didn't have a night action but was also one of the godfathers.
Night 7 you tracked kestegs and got a result that kestegs didn't make any night action. However, the same night kestegs roleblocked flubbucket. kestegs was one of the godfathers, so I wonder if godfather ability meant you couldn't obtain info about kestegs' night actions. Hence the irony comment.
Night 8 you tracked the hitman. Not much other flavor is necessary.
Night 9 you tracked mafia with no night action. At this point, we can deduce that you couldn't track all night talk. Apparently, you could only track the night talking of the second mason group.
Night 10 you tracked Feysal and obtained additional flavor that Feysal was indeed Mrs. Mallard and not a crazy fake claim like Asrrin's (relatives of main characters).
Each night you obtained flavor, the flavor you obtained gave you information with which to ascertain the truthfulness of someone's claim. I don't know what else to call that ability other than a role cop. It didn't work 100% of the time, but when it worked, it really really worked. Net effect: your role combined with mason group allowed you to obtain role information on 6 out of 9 townies with a night action and one other townie without a night action.
!
Google