Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
- Thread starter Gorny1
- Start date
korialstraz
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
Alright I'm finally back home!
N0: Feysal. My only reasoning for this was he's played excellently as pro-town in the past, and is a good theory crafter.
N1: Ankeli. I can't recall exactly why I chose Ankeli, but I believe it was for his strong opening. Probably not my wisest choice in this game.
N2: Drixx. Should be self-explenatory if you've been paying attention.
N3: Boogy. I believe it was after he came forward with a similar claim as mine regarding corax. That decision was made IIRC after the fact that the corax lynch failed.
N4: Sathoris after his claim and revealing the information he did.
N5: Didn't have a chance to send in my night action.
Alright I'm finally back home!
N0: Feysal. My only reasoning for this was he's played excellently as pro-town in the past, and is a good theory crafter.
N1: Ankeli. I can't recall exactly why I chose Ankeli, but I believe it was for his strong opening. Probably not my wisest choice in this game.
N2: Drixx. Should be self-explenatory if you've been paying attention.
N3: Boogy. I believe it was after he came forward with a similar claim as mine regarding corax. That decision was made IIRC after the fact that the corax lynch failed.
N4: Sathoris after his claim and revealing the information he did.
N5: Didn't have a chance to send in my night action.
RlyehExiled
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
I just noticed that Gorys character is the only one from NCIS:LA and not NCIS. Unsure what to make of that, as there are enough unclaimed characters to not need to go into a spinoff.
At the moment that's the only thing that seems out of place that I've noticed.
(Also his ability is a more focused version of a Lightning Rod, rather than a busdriver.)
Still want to hear from leo and Val first though.
I just noticed that Gorys character is the only one from NCIS:LA and not NCIS. Unsure what to make of that, as there are enough unclaimed characters to not need to go into a spinoff.
At the moment that's the only thing that seems out of place that I've noticed.
(Also his ability is a more focused version of a Lightning Rod, rather than a busdriver.)
Still want to hear from leo and Val first though.
korialstraz
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
It's past midnight for me, and I'm happy you noticed that small fact about Gory's claim RE.
So since I'll be gone from now until the day is over...
Vote: Goryani
It's past midnight for me, and I'm happy you noticed that small fact about Gory's claim RE.
So since I'll be gone from now until the day is over...
Vote: Goryani
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
OK - weakest claims so far:
Gory w/ as said not even NCIS - plus put me off since the begining of the game with the "Abby" avatar!
I was going to throw one in after I claimed.
Gullik: G Jackson was replaced by Jimmy early in the series (AFAIK) so find it strange to have that "low-key" of a character show?
Uraj: J Shepard has been dead since 2008. Please let me know what other characters are being used in this storyline that are that "long gone" because I truly don't know the time line of NCIS.
I can switch between Gory and Gullik - Uraj is more of an after-thought and I could be off. Checking my notes I noticed it seemed Gory was fishing for newbs D1 which I found interesting (more than scummy).
OK - weakest claims so far:
Gory w/ as said not even NCIS - plus put me off since the begining of the game with the "Abby" avatar!
I was going to throw one in after I claimed.Gullik: G Jackson was replaced by Jimmy early in the series (AFAIK) so find it strange to have that "low-key" of a character show?
Uraj: J Shepard has been dead since 2008. Please let me know what other characters are being used in this storyline that are that "long gone" because I truly don't know the time line of NCIS.
I can switch between Gory and Gullik - Uraj is more of an after-thought and I could be off. Checking my notes I noticed it seemed Gory was fishing for newbs D1 which I found interesting (more than scummy).
RlyehExiled
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
Jackson was replaced by Palmer after Ari shot him in Bete Noir in season 1. Although he didn't resign from NCIS until season 3 (He was on leave for rehab). He appeared in Kill Ari in season 3.
Jen is dead yes, KIA sometime in season 4 or 5 I beleive. However Kate is also dead, Killed by Ari in season 2 finale, and Michelle Lee is also dead iirc (Mal's flipped role). Victoria Mallard also died a few seasons ago off camera of natural causes.
anyway:
Vote: Goryani
I wanted to wait until leo and Val said something but with 2 hours left doesn't look like that's going to happen.
OK - weakest claims so far:
Gory w/ as said not even NCIS - plus put me off since the begining of the game with the "Abby" avatar!
Gullik: G Jackson was replaced by Jimmy early in the series (AFAIK) so find it strange to have that "low-key" of a character show?
Uraj: J Shepard has been dead since 2008. Please let me know what other characters are being used in this storyline that are that "long gone" because I truly don't know the time line of NCIS.
I can switch between Gory and Gullik - Uraj is more of an after-thought and I could be off. Checking my notes I noticed it seemed Gory was fishing for newbs D1 which I found interesting (more than scummy).
Jackson was replaced by Palmer after Ari shot him in Bete Noir in season 1. Although he didn't resign from NCIS until season 3 (He was on leave for rehab). He appeared in Kill Ari in season 3.
Jen is dead yes, KIA sometime in season 4 or 5 I beleive. However Kate is also dead, Killed by Ari in season 2 finale, and Michelle Lee is also dead iirc (Mal's flipped role). Victoria Mallard also died a few seasons ago off camera of natural causes.
anyway:
Vote: Goryani
I wanted to wait until leo and Val said something but with 2 hours left doesn't look like that's going to happen.
RlyehExiled
New member
flubbucket1
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
My concerns are these....
Will Valhauros and Leopold Stotch skate in here at the last minute to avoid a mod-kill?
Is their avoidance a sign of scumminess?
Should I just shut up with my inane questions and vote?
Vote: Goryani
My concerns are these....
Will Valhauros and Leopold Stotch skate in here at the last minute to avoid a mod-kill?
Is their avoidance a sign of scumminess?
Should I just shut up with my inane questions and vote?
Vote: Goryani
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
Well - everyone's been quiet. Leo was an alternate who didn't have a ton of time?
I'd also like to hear Gory's defence before a lock... but I do prefer a lynch so....
Vote: Goryani
Well - everyone's been quiet. Leo was an alternate who didn't have a ton of time?
I'd also like to hear Gory's defence before a lock... but I do prefer a lynch so....
Vote: Goryani
flubbucket1
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
Yup...This sucked!!!
If you check the sign up thread, I asked Gorny to be Kate. Kind of a "dead" give away if you were really resourceful.
Yup...This sucked!!!
If you check the sign up thread, I asked Gorny to be Kate. Kind of a "dead" give away if you were really resourceful.
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
I'll assume that since you've responded twice, you've double-checked. Your reason for choosing boogy seems flawed. Unless I've missed something, boogy has never self-voted. The only people I recall self-voting are zemaj and flub.
Goryani has done a little scumhunting but I did get the impression that there's he's spent more effort on speculation.
I'd include Asrrin with Feysal. Feysal's claimed role is a little more odd but to me, Asrrin's claimed role only works if Feysal's claimed name is real. Gullik's is only odd to me because of Drixx and korial getting doc powers with theirs. His claimed role was actually a somewhat main character on the series whereas Feysal's and Asrrin's were more minor. Though I agree with flub that Gullik's claim post looked odd.
Gory's role does seem the odd one out. From a fake claim perspective, claiming something from the spinoff pretty much eliminates any chance you'll be counter-claimed. Ideally I'd have liked to hear from Leo and Val first before making any decisions on who to go after, but with less than one and half hours left who knows when either will make it online.
Vote: Goryani
I'll assume that since you've responded twice, you've double-checked. Your reason for choosing boogy seems flawed. Unless I've missed something, boogy has never self-voted. The only people I recall self-voting are zemaj and flub.
Goryani has done a little scumhunting but I did get the impression that there's he's spent more effort on speculation.
I'd include Asrrin with Feysal. Feysal's claimed role is a little more odd but to me, Asrrin's claimed role only works if Feysal's claimed name is real. Gullik's is only odd to me because of Drixx and korial getting doc powers with theirs. His claimed role was actually a somewhat main character on the series whereas Feysal's and Asrrin's were more minor. Though I agree with flub that Gullik's claim post looked odd.
Gory's role does seem the odd one out. From a fake claim perspective, claiming something from the spinoff pretty much eliminates any chance you'll be counter-claimed. Ideally I'd have liked to hear from Leo and Val first before making any decisions on who to go after, but with less than one and half hours left who knows when either will make it online.
Vote: Goryani
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
I think you're going to need to redo this vote, space between vote: and goryani. Capitalization doesn't seem to matter, but vote format does.
I think you're going to need to redo this vote, space between vote: and goryani. Capitalization doesn't seem to matter, but vote format does.
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
Correct, I'm counting your vote as enough for a lynch and if corax revotes I think that would be the locking vote.
Correct, I'm counting your vote as enough for a lynch and if corax revotes I think that would be the locking vote.
boogyman19946
New member
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
I had to use ziva-isms (mess up on american slang).
I had to use ziva-isms (mess up on american slang).
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
I was hoping scum would try to night kill me while I redirected the NK to one of their own. I was trying to target scum like a cop role, so I used my cop role methodology: don't target the most obvious scum, but the not so obvious but still scum leaning.
N0 - random choice
N1 - Laarz role was too important to modkill. Laarz told Gorny about his absence but didn't tell the rest of us. The combo usually spells anti-town.
N2 - Spent a lot of time talking about post restriction and less time talking about the rest of the game.
N4 - "Glad we didn't accidentally lynch a power role" comment
N5 - flubbucket has been my primary scum choice ever since he went fishing for busdriver switches. I tried getting him lynched but no one else seemed interested in talking about the issue. I had to remove flubb from my most obvious scum list and try to take him out directly.
I was hoping scum would try to night kill me while I redirected the NK to one of their own. I was trying to target scum like a cop role, so I used my cop role methodology: don't target the most obvious scum, but the not so obvious but still scum leaning.
N0 - random choice
N1 - Laarz role was too important to modkill. Laarz told Gorny about his absence but didn't tell the rest of us. The combo usually spells anti-town.
N2 - Spent a lot of time talking about post restriction and less time talking about the rest of the game.
N4 - "Glad we didn't accidentally lynch a power role" comment
N5 - flubbucket has been my primary scum choice ever since he went fishing for busdriver switches. I tried getting him lynched but no one else seemed interested in talking about the issue. I had to remove flubb from my most obvious scum list and try to take him out directly.
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread
Did you just call me scummy because I don't have the same play style as you? Ad hominem is as Ad hominem does.
I spent two days talking about flubbucket, which almost the entire rest of the players seemed to ignore.
Did you just call me scummy because I don't have the same play style as you? Ad hominem is as Ad hominem does.
I spent two days talking about flubbucket, which almost the entire rest of the players seemed to ignore.
