Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

[Noammr]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

@Noammr what are your thoughts on this? Do you feel there's been enough interactions with zemaj?

Abso-freakin-lutely. Do you disagree?


While I agree Drixx's play is very disruptive, I'd rather follow through with zemaj before considering Drixx for a lynch. Besides, switching targets now might result in another nolynch day.

 

[Noodle]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I'm going to be in and out of meetings all day, so I'll cast my vote now. I feel there have been enough opportunities for zemaj to defend himself.

vote: zemaj

 

[Sathoris]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I'm predicting we'll end up in a deadlock due to the great amount of votes required and mafia throwing in sticks to our wheels if we split our votes. And a no lynch again. And yeah, I think he has to go, but not yet.

Way too early to be saying that. You're basically saying we should just lynch whomever you want lynched because if someone else bothers to think about a target we'll get divided and we'll end up with a no lynch.

You really do need some perspective. You just picked someone at random and decided to want him lynched and won't acceot any other (better) alternative. Formal case laterâ„¢

Why does his message have to contain information only gained through a power role? We don't even know what the message is, so you're just assuming the info that is encrypted is gained from having a power role.

You didn't read my post properly. VT's are vanilla townies. They don't have power roles and therefor only have their vote and voice. If they learn something then it's from a power role. Be it from themselves or from someone else. Basically reiterating what I already said here..

I've since looked up the cop role, and the cop role has several other names (with no mention of a different ability than a standard cop), one being sheriff. But maybe the sources I'm using is incorrect, so if you have other information on what a sheriff role could be, then do please enlighten me.

He seems to think the sherrif can translate the code. That's enough for me to assume the sherrif isn't a standard cop. Usually a sherrif is ascociated with a jailkeep ability, not an investigative ability. Especially in an NCIS themed game we expect the NCIS crew to investigate, not a local sherrif.

Again you assume the information he encrypted is gained from a power role, while we actually don't know anything about the message that is there. Either you're too quick on jumping to conclusions, or I'm too slow... so to speak.

Drixx has in fact since said the information is useless. Holding on to his VT claim. If that's true then he's just deliberately wasting our time, which we might be doing.

FLIP

FLOP

FLIP

FLOP

FLOP FLIPPITY


So why don't you want to lynch zemaj?????

My word what a truly utterly horrible post that is. Taking posts out of their timeline and moreover taking sarcastic comments as truth to fit your (apparent) case?

I can't even respond to that cause doing so would cut my intelligence in half. I can only laugh at it. Is there a worst post award yet?

I can say you are making this an enjoyable game Feysal! :thankyou:

I hate it.

@Gorny, why is my vote on Zemaj when I voted for Drixx?

---

I'm a bit busy and only managed to read the last 15 new pages. I'll try and make a post about why you should vote for Drixx instead of Zemaj in about 2 to 3 hours.

 

[korialstraz]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

You didn't read my post properly. VT's are vanilla townies. They don't have power roles and therefor only have their vote and voice. If they learn something then it's from a power role. Be it from themselves or from someone else. Basically reiterating what I already said here..

Actually I read it very well. And just because someone is VT doesn't mean they can't try and send someone a message. You're just assuming that only a power role can have any information worthwile to keep the mafia from finding out. Maybe I'm just keeping a too open minded approach to the game, I don't know, but we've clearly viewed this in a vastly different ways

He seems to think the sherrif can translate the code. That's enough for me to assume the sherrif isn't a standard cop. Usually a sherrif is ascociated with a jailkeep ability, not an investigative ability. Especially in an NCIS themed game we expect the NCIS crew to investigate, not a local sherrif.

Again you assume that the code is meant for someone with a power to translate the code. I've already made my comment on this before.

Drixx has in fact since said the information is useless. Holding on to his VT claim. If that's true then he's just deliberately wasting our time, which we might be doing.

At least this we can agree on. I was annoyed tbh when Drixx posted that, as it was very detrimental to the town. But I'm sure I was in some ways the first times I played this with you guys. I'm not going to speculate on if it's delibirate or not, and hopefully we can start focusing on something else now, which the latter part of your posts seems to suggest you intend to.

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

@Gorny, why is my vote on Zemaj when I voted for Drixx?




BECAUSE HE SCUM!!!!!




---

I'm a bit busy and only managed to read the last 15 new pages. I'll try and make a post about why you should vote for Drixx instead of Zemaj in about 2 to 3 hours.

Ought to be well thought out and insightful unlike the drivel I spew, eh??

I'll be waiting...Scumbathoris

Will you try to kill me during the next night phase?? :scratchchin:

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

My word what a truly utterly horrible post that is. Taking posts out of their timeline and moreover taking sarcastic comments as truth to fit your (apparent) case?

I can't even respond to that cause doing so would cut my intelligence in half. I can only laugh at it. Is there a worst post award yet?
.

Interesting that you edited out everything you ACTUALLY SAID IN THE ORDER YOU ACTUALLY SAID IT.

Really quite Scumtastic :thumbup:

 

[Sathoris]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I have no idea why you're trying to paint some sort of thing between us flubb.

I will just ignore you.

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

...I will just ignore you.

I'm getting quite used to that from this whole affair...

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Still seems paper thin.

Real life crept up so I went camping...no reason to expain beforehand (not that this silly game is relavent). Perhaps a short, terse "I'm outta here, lemme know how it turns out. I'm going camping."

Whatever....ramble.... shuffle..... drool......tinkle........uh oh

 

[Noammr]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Man, some of you are soooooooo serious.

any reasoning aside from just going with the flow? Path of least resistance would is very tempting when you are trying to just lay low... Best I recall, you were one of the ones "waiting for me to make a post", well now I have & yet you have nothing to say about it, other than the above when questioned by Uraj about my lack of posts... all of which I explained to the best I could here.

Your best recall is wrong. At no point was I waiting for your post. My stance was 'you had a chance to defend your early posts -> your defense was awful (including a 'hey, last game you wrongly lynched me, you're probably wrong again this time' argument -> you disappeared for the rest of the day in the hopes people will lose interest and forget your early plays.'. Nothing you said since returning changed anything in that regard, you should've been lynched yesterday.

 

[korialstraz]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

the above is directed at everyone voting for me but was "waiting for a post" from me, aside from Ankeli who just wants me dead so he can have my bones to gnaw on, not just those quoted. They were just the easiest for me to quote atm.

Because I see no better candidate atm, even with your explenation taken into account.

And yes I do think Drixx is less scummy than you, although I'm still waiting for Sathoris's post, as I really want to see what kind of case he's building up against Drixx.

 

[Sathoris]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I actually don't have the time to go through the whole thread and find the correct quotes and bits to make a proper case on Drixx. However since we've reached an impasse in which either Zemaj or Drixx will be lynched I will compare the cases a bit.

The attack on Zemaj started with Ankeli here by saying he pinged his radar. Zemaj responds in post #36 with some OMGUS. Zemaj then explains his post here with a very reasonable explanation I might add and moreover announces that RL will take up most of his time and he might not be there for a while.

Ankeli makes no further attempt to make a case on him and holds on to the idea the he dissapeared because he was under pressure. Everyone blindly follows a bandwagon on someone without a case who in fact has already defended his early post which so many of you wanted a defense for.

Now Drixx on the other hand (has posted so much I won't go through his posts because it'll take too long) has OMGUS voted nearly everyone making a remark at him. Remember that's what you guys attacked Zemaj for aswell? He's numerously hinted at having a power role to possibly avoid getting attention. He would withhold information that would help the town. He's posting (if we take his word for it) useless codes that, knowing full well, will take a up a nice amount of discussion and set us off track. In other words, he's wasting our time. He's had imteractions with a lot of people that can be used as associative tells.

I guess this ended up more as a defense of Zemaj, but it was needed to show you people what a stupid case you're voting on. Drixx is the best lynch by far.

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

..I guess this ended up more as a defense of Zemaj, but it was needed to show you people what a stupid case you're voting on...

Hallelujah! Sathoris has shown me the err of my ways...Let him forever be praised, Amen.

Unvote: zemaj

Vote: flubbucket

 

[coju]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Hallelujah! Sathoris has shown me the err of my ways...Let him forever be praised, Amen.

Unvote: zemaj

Vote: flubbucket

FINALLY! Some reason!

Vote: flubbucket

Flubster, I applaud you. Praises, forgivenesses, honor, AND voting in the SAME SENTENCE! Wowzors. :alright:

 

[coju]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

You'll make it to the end for your post 564 flub!

Live long and prosper.

 

[korialstraz]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

@Sathoris: That's actually quite interesting. I went back and re-read some posts from first day, and still getting a scummy vibe from them. I did too with Drixx, but like mentioned before he seems a lot more consistent. Besides if we try to change our votes now, I would think we'd end in a no lynch again. Unless anyone has a better idea?


And considering flubb and coju, we're changing the votes now? I'm not so confident we can agree on and lock someone else at this late an hour, but like I said above, I'm all ears for other suggestions.

 

[Sathoris]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

@Sathoris: That's actually quite interesting. I went back and re-read some posts from first day, and still getting a scummy vibe from them. I did too with Drixx, but like mentioned before he seems a lot more consistent. Besides if we try to change our votes now, I would think we'd end in a no lynch again. Unless anyone has a better idea?

Consistent with what? I haven't seen much scumhunting from him, but I'm sure he eventually must. In a game this big I'm pretty sure there are two scumteams or an SK. He must find both.

There are 6 votes on Drixx now when Gorny changes my vote. If Coju doesn't change his vote on the idiotic Flubb and some of you change we can easily get Drixx lynched.

On a related note, PvtCaboose is facing modkill

 

[Malevolent]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I actually don't have the time to go through the whole thread and find the correct quotes and bits to make a proper case on Drixx. However since we've reached an impasse in which either Zemaj or Drixx will be lynched I will compare the cases a bit.

The attack on Zemaj started with Ankeli here by saying he pinged his radar. Zemaj responds in post #36 with some OMGUS. Zemaj then explains his post here with a very reasonable explanation I might add and moreover announces that RL will take up most of his time and he might not be there for a while.

Ankeli makes no further attempt to make a case on him and holds on to the idea the he dissapeared because he was under pressure. Everyone blindly follows a bandwagon on someone without a case who in fact has already defended his early post which so many of you wanted a defense for.

Now Drixx on the other hand (has posted so much I won't go through his posts because it'll take too long) has OMGUS voted nearly everyone making a remark at him. Remember that's what you guys attacked Zemaj for aswell? He's numerously hinted at having a power role to possibly avoid getting attention. He would withhold information that would help the town. He's posting (if we take his word for it) useless codes that, knowing full well, will take a up a nice amount of discussion and set us off track. In other words, he's wasting our time. He's had imteractions with a lot of people that can be used as associative tells.

I guess this ended up more as a defense of Zemaj, but it was needed to show you people what a stupid case you're voting on. Drixx is the best lynch by far.

so zemaj DID explain that he was going to be away!

Drix is just plain annoying everybody, i think that zemaj is more scummy than drix BUT it depends on whats best for the town, get rid of the person annoying everybody and effectibng thier ability tio make reational thoughts, or the likely to be mafia.

unvote: zemaj

i do not wan't to see zemaj lynch locked untill i hear more from both drix and zemaj ( im sure we will be hearing TOO MUCH more from drix any how)

If we lynch drix, and drix is mafia then zemaj will be cleared IMO, if we lynch zemaj and he is scum, then drix will still be annoying. Lynching drix will probably give the town more information IMO, i mean no mafia or SK in there right mind would get rid of him, he just causes too much havoc amongst the town.

Then again i would lynch either of them without a second thought if it was nearer to the end of the day and my vote was needed.

I will be on untill it changes to night so no need to worry about me forgeting to revote.

 

[Sathoris]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

]I will be on untill it changes to night so no need to worry about me forgeting to revote.

Nice preemptive post to throw your buddy under the bus when the time arrives.

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

...Live long and prosper.

Star Trek > Star Wars

Spock FTW!!!