We have only lynched one mafia, so there need to be 2-3 (I believe 2, since we have Zombies as well). We need to find them asap. I aked yesterday that somebody do the numbers on Lylo/Mylo. The only answers were "nah, I can't". Look at those people for scum I think.
I said it was impossible to make reliable assumptions based upon the info we had yesterday. There was no way to know with certainty that we were dealing with two factions and how many might be in each. Now it seems fairly clear (if you believe BA) that there are two anti-town factions, and it appears that there were at least 3 zombies, and most likely 4 since it looks like Jcakes is team zombie. So you seem to have hit it on the head that there would be 2-3 mafia on the other team (that would be 1/3 anti-town at start of game).
Add one to the number to make a worst case. With 9 people alive and Jcakes presumably a zombie, it seems prudent to assume 2-3 mafia remaining, which makes today or tomorrow MYLO.
By the way, I didn't see
you doing any legwork on figuring it out yesterday. None of us had enough information to know for sure. So if we're meant to look at the people who weren't just making up numbers and calling them scum, we should include you, right? I mean, I personally feel like making up numbers would be irresponsible and a scummy thing to do, but you seem to think opposite.
I have a clear scum list:
Drixx
We went over this yesterday, but I'll humor you one more time. Your entire "case" against me is your assertion that I knew your ascension mechanic when I shouldn't have been able to know it. You posit that I'm the mafia godfather and that my team has some kind of investigative role which would give detailed mechanic information (a role that, to my knowledge, has never existed before). You're talking about 1 in 21 chances of me being that particular role, assuming it's even in the game, and then you have to further believe in the existence of a new mechanics investigator type role.
As a general rule, if you have to make something really complicated and unlikely, it isn't very probable. I assumed that you would ascend when you died. It makes sense that death triggers ascension since we killed Noodle, he went away for a day, then ascended. It doesn't make sense that only death by lynch causes this to happen. As it turns out, it was a pretty safe assumption since you later claimed that you would ascend and become a treestump no matter how you died.
Numbers, I forgot Numbers. I put him on my town list.
There's a whole host of reasons why Numbers might not be town, although his answers to you and I yesterday when we asked very similar questions were pretty spot on townie, imo.
Brain working slow tonight. I need to have a vote out to fullfill the ascention requirement. So I'll vote for the person I want to see lynched the most. I'll vote for any on my scum list though come tomorrow.
Vote: Drixx
I totally understand that you think you caught me in some kind of slip of knowing something I shouldn't have, but that simply isn't the case. Until you confirmed it, my understanding of the ascension mechanic was based upon an assumption and some basic logic. I think just about everyone in the game probably had the same basic thought.
If you believe Bad Ash (and I see no reason not to nor any reason why you wouldn't since you have him listed as probable town), we have a confirmed zombie in Jcakes, and yet you think the best play today is to lynch me, confirmed vanilla?
You keep trying to steer us into acting against our own best interests. We have someone caught in a lie in what appears to have been a bold play by team zombie. Town wins by lynching scum and it's counterproductive to lynch an unknown when you have scum right in front of you to lynch first. If you were right, I should still be here tomorrow to be lynched, right?
The more you press for us to act against our best play, the more I wonder if you aren't actually the mafia godfather. It kind of makes sense in a TC game that the godfather might have an ascension ability and instead of investigating as vanilla to a rolecop and pro-town to an alignment cop would return unknown/pro-town instead. You've also conveniently claimed a role where there's no reason to question why you are around every day. Why would the town or the anti-town bother to kill a treestump?
I think you just have some gut feeling that you refer to that I'm a baddie and that's your style. Earlier you made some comments about how you're a bad player, but you actually did put together something of a case against me, so clearly you're not operating on just gut feeling anymore. In this case; however, the slip you think you've caught me in simply doesn't make sense. I'd sure appreciate it if you logically re-evaluated the substance of your case against me.
It almost feels like how Sathoris came after me in my first game. I thought I was vanilla at that time (It was a Gorny game so I had a backup role that I didn't know about) and he came after me so relentlessly I actually intentionally got myself modkilled in an attempt to get the town a chance to get scum.
In any case, whether you re-evaluate your case against me or not, and whatever your gut might say about my alignment, we do actually have a nearly 100% confirmed person to lynch today. If you are really pro-town, logic dictates that you take out the known scum and leave tomorrow for tomorrow.
I think I've covered your questions concerning MYLO as well as your suspicions about me in pretty good detail. Unless someone has a specific question, this is the last I have to say in my defense because all I can do is just rehash the same info over and over and that's not in the least bit useful.
P.S. - @Moar - Have fun with the card game
Don't tell me to go reread your posts when I'm just answering a question you asked to the best of my abilities. It doesn't matter if it was surprising or not, it matters that we have new information now that we did not have yesterday, which we can use to judge the truth of his statements.
