Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
- Thread starter Uraj
- Start date
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
Why would you claim now? We've got plenty of hours left till deadline, you haven't got nearly enough votes to be in danger yet. Unless it's another ploy like the other posts to stop us voting you.
Or you claimed now so we'd have more time to switch, but leaving softclaims of a power role is bound to attract attention and may force you to claim. Or it were just breadcrums, but they weren't specific about any role.
All very WIFOMy, but I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt. TC is back on!
Unvote: Marahumm
Vote: Thundercat
Why would you claim now? We've got plenty of hours left till deadline, you haven't got nearly enough votes to be in danger yet. Unless it's another ploy like the other posts to stop us voting you.
Or you claimed now so we'd have more time to switch, but leaving softclaims of a power role is bound to attract attention and may force you to claim. Or it were just breadcrums, but they weren't specific about any role.
All very WIFOMy, but I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt. TC is back on!
Unvote: Marahumm
Vote: Thundercat
ThunderCat
Active member
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
Very well Marahumm, but I will be expecting a valid lynch target from you.
Very well Marahumm, but I will be expecting a valid lynch target from you.
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
I have three posts left after this, and I'm likely to need them at the end of the day, so I will save them until then. For now, to answer some questions I've seen, the topics I'm allowed to discuss are not limited in any way, and I don't know anything about my restriction I wouldn't have told you already, though I have a wild theory that the restriction may be a symptom of deteriorating health after being poisoned last night, which is little more than a random guess.
It seems to have been conveniently forgotten that Marahumm asked others to check profiles because it was not practical for him to do it on phone. I don't think that suspecting him because of this makes any sense, even though I disagreed with his suggestion, I do not think he would make it as scum.
I've encountered this tell before in a game on mafiascum.net, where a scum player was caught for his noncommittal attitude and lack of suspects.
Unvote: Krazeyivan
Vote: Zarniwoop
I have three posts left after this, and I'm likely to need them at the end of the day, so I will save them until then. For now, to answer some questions I've seen, the topics I'm allowed to discuss are not limited in any way, and I don't know anything about my restriction I wouldn't have told you already, though I have a wild theory that the restriction may be a symptom of deteriorating health after being poisoned last night, which is little more than a random guess.
It seems to have been conveniently forgotten that Marahumm asked others to check profiles because it was not practical for him to do it on phone. I don't think that suspecting him because of this makes any sense, even though I disagreed with his suggestion, I do not think he would make it as scum.
I've encountered this tell before in a game on mafiascum.net, where a scum player was caught for his noncommittal attitude and lack of suspects.
Unvote: Krazeyivan
Vote: Zarniwoop
LozHinge the Unhinged
Active member
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
No, I suggest we do no probing whatsoever and hope that the Mafia just decide to move on. :whistling:
Yes, I will. See below.
Zarni, I share your dislike for the idea of "I know something and won't tell you". Sometimes it's necessary. But see below.
I was quite suspicious of Gorny. Discounting the possibility of him being a PR, I believed that he failed to signal back to me something he should have been able to do, if he was what I thought he was. Just my luck, Gorny was a PR. I was playing percentages and lost.
I too have played a game where I was mafia, but strategy dictated that I forego a NK. I had a Spanish accent that game
The point is that everyone (at the time I posted) who suggested that there was little or no chance that the mafia would choose not to send in a NK was over-looking the fact that in a game consisting of newcomers and experienced players, it is a valid tactic for a team of fully experienced mafia to mimic a newbie error, that of a new-to-mafia team failing to send in a NK PM.
Mara, my read of Gorny was wrong,. but the percentages said to me that he was a good choice for a Day 1 lynch. Your actions subsequently made me suspicious of you.
My vote stays on Mara as I think he is the best bet for securing a lynch. My only other leaning is towards Technomancer.
As to why I was suspicious of Gorny, I cannot yet give full details but he appeared to signal me in response to my signal to him, but he then failed to follow up with confirmation that would have made me trust him. I took this as an attempt to falsely declare his status to me, which made me suspicious. That's as clear as I can be without giving too much info away.
No, I suggest we do no probing whatsoever and hope that the Mafia just decide to move on. :whistling:
Yes, I will. See below.
Zarni, I share your dislike for the idea of "I know something and won't tell you". Sometimes it's necessary. But see below.
I was quite suspicious of Gorny. Discounting the possibility of him being a PR, I believed that he failed to signal back to me something he should have been able to do, if he was what I thought he was. Just my luck, Gorny was a PR. I was playing percentages and lost.
I too have played a game where I was mafia, but strategy dictated that I forego a NK. I had a Spanish accent that game
The point is that everyone (at the time I posted) who suggested that there was little or no chance that the mafia would choose not to send in a NK was over-looking the fact that in a game consisting of newcomers and experienced players, it is a valid tactic for a team of fully experienced mafia to mimic a newbie error, that of a new-to-mafia team failing to send in a NK PM.
Mara, my read of Gorny was wrong,. but the percentages said to me that he was a good choice for a Day 1 lynch. Your actions subsequently made me suspicious of you.
My vote stays on Mara as I think he is the best bet for securing a lynch. My only other leaning is towards Technomancer.
As to why I was suspicious of Gorny, I cannot yet give full details but he appeared to signal me in response to my signal to him, but he then failed to follow up with confirmation that would have made me trust him. I took this as an attempt to falsely declare his status to me, which made me suspicious. That's as clear as I can be without giving too much info away.
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
I'm with Leo on this one. How the hell do these votes work now. I've unvoted Gorny after his modkill, besides votes can't be on players not in the game.
Or you need to unvote and vote in the same post? And why keep the original starting votes? It makes for a very confusing votecount.
Incase it's needed.
Unvote: Gorny
Vote: Thundercat
Yet nobody even mentioned the lack of NK is due to newcomers being mafia.
I'm with Leo on this one. How the hell do these votes work now. I've unvoted Gorny after his modkill, besides votes can't be on players not in the game.
Or you need to unvote and vote in the same post? And why keep the original starting votes? It makes for a very confusing votecount.
Incase it's needed.
Unvote: Gorny
Vote: Thundercat
Yet nobody even mentioned the lack of NK is due to newcomers being mafia.
LozHinge the Unhinged
Active member
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
Sathoris, if you're being subtle enough to try this gambit, you don't then spoil it and telegraph it! You let the town trip over the misconception on their own!
I cannot recall whether anyone mentioned that or not, but that is irrelevant. All I was positing was that there is a potential reason why a mafia team would deliberately choose not to send in a NK on Night 0. I am not suggesting for one minute that that is what actually happened.
Sathoris, if you're being subtle enough to try this gambit, you don't then spoil it and telegraph it! You let the town trip over the misconception on their own!
I cannot recall whether anyone mentioned that or not, but that is irrelevant. All I was positing was that there is a potential reason why a mafia team would deliberately choose not to send in a NK on Night 0. I am not suggesting for one minute that that is what actually happened.
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
Yes, this day phase you need unvotes and votes in the same post. Further day phases you'll be able to unvote and vote anytime you want.
If it's the consensus that voting history is not important information, I'll remove all old votes.
Yes, this day phase you need unvotes and votes in the same post. Further day phases you'll be able to unvote and vote anytime you want.
If it's the consensus that voting history is not important information, I'll remove all old votes.
ThunderCat
Active member
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
[OT]I'll go watch a movie before the day ends (Sixth sense)[/OT] and be back to cast my vote. But as of now, I got nothing plausible to cast a vote on.
[OT]I'll go watch a movie before the day ends (Sixth sense)[/OT] and be back to cast my vote. But as of now, I got nothing plausible to cast a vote on.
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
I claimed earlier mainly because my choices of timing were either then and now as I had no time in between due to work. It gives players that feel the need to challenge my claim ample opportunity to do so, and I felt if I claimed now, there wouldn't be enough time to swerve the opinions of others.
Whenever you decide to play the game as if you cared, you'll notice I listed suspects lozhinge and zarni before I even claimed. Or are they not valid lynch targets for some reason?
I claimed earlier mainly because my choices of timing were either then and now as I had no time in between due to work. It gives players that feel the need to challenge my claim ample opportunity to do so, and I felt if I claimed now, there wouldn't be enough time to swerve the opinions of others.
Whenever you decide to play the game as if you cared, you'll notice I listed suspects lozhinge and zarni before I even claimed. Or are they not valid lynch targets for some reason?
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
hey, everyone. had a late start this morning and the roommate almost walked in on me being nude. other than that, it's been a normal day. lol!
you weren't in Bad Ash's bus driver game were you?
"If you ski outta your league, you're gunna have a bad time."
that and you get used to it and realize other's play tactics. ^_^ i felt the same way when i first started. y'all are fine.
well, hang on Sath. iirc, last game y'all lynched me because i was the only one who had the most votes and "a lynch was better than no lynch!" it sucked a lot because i was at work and was unable to post. if you think what TC is doing is unfair, how do you feel about my lynch last game?
ONE "S", Sath. ONE "S" and two "R"s.
really now? in your next post you can or cannot reply, but do you feel you will live to see tomorrow?
"when Bruce Willis was dead at the end of Sixth Sense...."
hey, everyone. had a late start this morning and the roommate almost walked in on me being nude. other than that, it's been a normal day. lol!
you weren't in Bad Ash's bus driver game were you?
"If you ski outta your league, you're gunna have a bad time."
that and you get used to it and realize other's play tactics. ^_^ i felt the same way when i first started. y'all are fine.
well, hang on Sath. iirc, last game y'all lynched me because i was the only one who had the most votes and "a lynch was better than no lynch!" it sucked a lot because i was at work and was unable to post. if you think what TC is doing is unfair, how do you feel about my lynch last game?
ONE "S", Sath. ONE "S" and two "R"s.
really now? in your next post you can or cannot reply, but do you feel you will live to see tomorrow?
"when Bruce Willis was dead at the end of Sixth Sense...."
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
TC and Asrrin are at the top of my list now as a result of that utterly bizarre logic.
However, I'm going with Asrrin because of the piling on to already weak reasoning.
Vote: Assrin
I am not one of those that feels the town must lynch someone when absolutely nothing is known and there is nothing to be learned from the lynch. Especially, when I have a strong suspicion that Mara is a power town role based on his comments.
TC and Asrrin are at the top of my list now as a result of that utterly bizarre logic.
However, I'm going with Asrrin because of the piling on to already weak reasoning.
Vote: Assrin
I am not one of those that feels the town must lynch someone when absolutely nothing is known and there is nothing to be learned from the lynch. Especially, when I have a strong suspicion that Mara is a power town role based on his comments.
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
guys, Asrrin's name has one S in it!
guys, Asrrin's name has one S in it!
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
i know it doesn't matter much now with the new vote format, but... eh, nvm.
i don't feel anything scummy from anyone except Lozhinge. and now i don't know whether to believe his bat signal to Gorny or not...
i know it doesn't matter much now with the new vote format, but... eh, nvm.
i don't feel anything scummy from anyone except Lozhinge. and now i don't know whether to believe his bat signal to Gorny or not...
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
Actually that was you being voted by Asrrin; you're currently voting Noodle.
Actually that was you being voted by Asrrin; you're currently voting Noodle.
Re: Ravenwood Retreat Mafia Game.
It's been proven over and over that lynching everyday, even if it's completely random, benefits the town. I am, and always have been an advocate of lynching. If you want to vote me because of that fine. I'm not unvoting Mara because of the current rules of today, I can't unvote without first voting someone. The only other person that I have suspicions on are Sathoris. Everyone else hasn't said much and there isn't enough information to lynch. Once I find another viable lynch candidate, I'll unvote Mara because of his claim. Though I still doubt the veracity of his claim, I'm hestant to lynch a claimed power role.
It's been proven over and over that lynching everyday, even if it's completely random, benefits the town. I am, and always have been an advocate of lynching. If you want to vote me because of that fine. I'm not unvoting Mara because of the current rules of today, I can't unvote without first voting someone. The only other person that I have suspicions on are Sathoris. Everyone else hasn't said much and there isn't enough information to lynch. Once I find another viable lynch candidate, I'll unvote Mara because of his claim. Though I still doubt the veracity of his claim, I'm hestant to lynch a claimed power role.
