If it's possible, can someone with some time on their hands provide a vote tally? I'm too swamped at work to do it myself. I can't even tell, from all the chaos, if there's a trend developing.
@Rash: I never, ever said I needed to send a PM. Lister just assumed I meant sending, instead of reading, and you jumped on that bandwagon. If you want to believe I had to send something, fine. But please don't post that I said so.
I don't have time to cross-check votes or inconsistencies at the moment. I want to vote, but I don't really have a sensible target. The only thing I can think of is my old suspect.
GoHabsGo seems a bit odd, especially since he called for no lynching early in the first day, but I'm not sure if he just offered that idea up out of frustration or not.
But as I learned the mecanics of this game during the last week, I quickly realised there is no strategy involved. It's chaos and random accusations thrown left and right.
I'm quite tired of being accused when there is nothing I could be accused for. I don't get where I should have slipped. To me it looks like there are a few people that jumped on me right from the start without much reasoning.
I haven't had much time to follow the thread, but what I read confuses me. There are some good thoughts out there and I have changed my opinion of some people a bit. I don't think Goltar is mafia now.
What stands out to me is that Lord Nikon and Jaago jumped on me without good reasons and try to get a bandwagon started. Looks like they will succed this time as well. Make of it what you will. :smiley:
Vote: Lord Nikon
Returning a vote on a person who just voted you is either suspicious or lame.
I'm quite tired of being accused when there is nothing I could be accused for. I don't get where I should have slipped. To me it looks like there are a few people that jumped on me right from the start without much reasoning.
Returning a vote on a person who just voted you is either suspicious or lame.
Considering this was my first time playing, I originally tho it was more strategic for the town to do a no-lynch on day 1, especially with the mafia inactivity. But as I learned the mecanics of this game during the last week, I quickly realised there is no strategy involved. It's chaos and random accusations thrown left and right.
Sint Nikolaas. His posts all seem very well reasonable, and he did not make many suspicious moves, but yet, his posts are in such a way different from the posts in the previous two games (admittedly few due to his early deaths) that I think he's mafia. Further more, it looks to me as if Sint is the evil genius, and Rashiminos the mouthpiece of the mafia, ...
vote: Sint Nikolaas
Sint made posts in the previous games? Really Lister this is quite a stretch. It's very apparent that the loud people will either get murdered or lynched fairly quickly. Basically if they don't get murdered by mid-game start to worry, but early on does it really matter? All the mafia have to do is jump on whatever bandwagon is forming, there's no need to start a lynchfest. Whether they be talkative or quiet, the mafia can pretty much do anything early game.
Well, nice tactic. First voting for someone, and then by this making sure that they don't return the favour. I agree though that voting on someone purely because that other person voted for you is lame, but there are times when the reason for that voting lies in reasoning such as for example that that person started to try and get you lynched without any solid reasoning, and just out of the blue gave some "mumble jumble" as an argument.
I do suspect Moar, but since it looks already likely she's going to be lynched, and she's not on my list of most suspicious people anymore, I'm going to vote on the one I suspect of being the mastermind in the mafia, Sint Nikolaas. His posts all seem very well reasonable, and he did not make many suspicious moves, but yet, his posts are in such a way different from the posts in the previous two games (admittedly few due to his early deaths) that I think he's mafia. Further more, it looks to me as if Sint is the evil genius, and Rashiminos the mouthpiece of the mafia, who the third one is I don't know, it could have been Jaedhan, but Jaago, RevenantsKnight, and Thyiad are all likely contenders. In light of Rashiminos late vote on Moar I don't think Moar is mafia. Note that the ones I named are the ones I found most likely to be mafia. Unfortunately that means they're also likely contenders for the title of village idiot. Also, I want to emphasize that all of you are suspicious, even if I did not name you here.
vote: Sint Nikolaas
Sint made posts in the previous games? Really Lister this is quite a stretch. It's very apparent that the loud people will either get murdered or lynched fairly quickly. Basically if they don't get murdered by mid-game start to worry, but early on does it really matter? All the mafia have to do is jump on whatever bandwagon is forming, there's no need to start a lynchfest. Whether they be talkative or quiet, the mafia can pretty much do anything early game.
Moar, it's nothing personal, I assure you. It's not you who slipped, but Neksja. I realise it's not something you can do much about, and again, none of us are absolutely sure you are mafia, just that you have a night-time role.
Now isn't that a kick in the head. My posts are different? Please tell me how. Seriously I am trying to make some logic of this game and think things trough before I post and because I ''didn't make any suspicious moves'' I'm suspicious? Great reasoning there... Oh and Rash and me have been on the same team the whole game ofcourse, mainly because we haven't had contact. Oh no wait that must be another reason that we're in it together, because we're not doing anything together. Funny how the 3rd person can be one of 4(!), while I'm pretty much already picked.lister said:His posts all seem very well reasonable, and he did not make many suspicious moves, but yet, his posts are in such a way different from the posts in the previous two games (admittedly few due to his early deaths) that I think he's mafia. Further more, it looks to me as if Sint is the evil genius, and Rashiminos the mouthpiece of the mafia, who the third one is I don't know, it could have been Jaedhan, but Jaago, RevenantsKnight, and Thyiad are all likely contenders.
After that, how can you give such a reason for me being mafia. Seriously get your act together......for example that that person started to try and get you lynched without any solid reasoning...
Or do you already have your act together.lister said:Nevertheless, I felt it was best to say those things, to put nearly all my cards on the table.
