Create Your Own Role Mafia game

[Kestegs]

I think Solar must have been scum since he didn't reveal that he was Joe again. But how the h*ll did he get killed then? Mafia won't attack one of their own, but I don't really see yet how the bus driver could have involuntarily done it.

Hadn't thought about the fact that he would get the role again, so he would know either way I guess. Probably reflected then.

 

[Caluin Graye]

No, I wouldn't think so.

Couple situations I see possible:

1. SI was the hitman and he reflected off of the reflector to hit himself.

2. SI was the target of the kill and he did not get told he was killed or that his mjb ability triggered. Not sure if gory would tell him or not, that's the issue.

3. Bus driver lied and mafia hit mafia. Seems unlikely, especially since we can confirm one of his switches.

Option #2 doesn't work since Solar specifically mentioned that he had a different role. Meet Joe Black forces you to keep the role for another day.

Option #3 doesn't work because that assumes Bad Ash submitted targets without consulting his team, nor even checking to see who they were going to kill. We all know Bad Ash is incompetent, but not that incompetent. (I kid. I kid.)

Yes, the reflector makes sense. You didn't get any PM back about your reflecting?

Negatory.

 

[Sathoris]

Hypothetical question: If Ankeli had convinced you that he was town, and the rest of the town still wanted him lynched, would you have moved the lynch? To whom would you have moved it to?

If he convinced me of his innocence, which he had no chance of doing, I would have moved the lynch to Moar. I thought about switching it to Moar anyway, but Ankeli made me too curious to find out his alignement.

 

[Sathoris]

I think Solar must have been scum since he didn't reveal that he was Joe again. But how the h*ll did he get killed then? Mafia won't attack one of their own, but I don't really see yet how the bus driver could have involuntarily done it.

People lie.

 

[Moar]

No, I wouldn't think so.

Couple situations I see possible:

1. SI was the hitman and he reflected off of the reflector to hit himself.

2. SI was the target of the kill and he did not get told he was killed or that his mjb ability triggered. Not sure if gory would tell him or not, that's the issue.

3. Bus driver lied and mafia hit mafia. Seems unlikely, especially since we can confirm one of his switches.

1. After the last messages, I do think this must have been the thing. SI going for CG is a good play as well. CG is one of the strongest players (while according to flubb i am just rubbish, you will be alone on your rug for a long time flubby...) so getting rid of him is a good mafia play if he's not on the team.

2. Waiting for Gory there. I asked if he would not be allowed to tell that he had the role twice.

3. That's why i asked if Paris was around last night.

 

[Moar]

People lie.

Yes, but how would a town Joe denying that he was Joe again the next day help the town? So lie = scum.
We would have looked for others if we knew that is role was the reason for no NK instead of me blocking Ankeli.

 

[Kestegs]

yes, I think it's safe to assume SI was scum then.

 

[Goryani]

@Gory
Was he stopped by you and had to lie?

All details of this nature are listed in post #3.

 

[Moar]

Then he didn't have to lie but elected to.

 

[thefranklin]

I was the king maker and without a night I didn't do anything with it. I would assume one is not randomly due to no night actions.

 

[Moar]

I guess all night actions just got wiped. I ddn't get to do anything with the bus driver.

 

[Moar]

I just reread the thread. Did it once before, but was in bad shape then. So apparetly I am "frazzled" an aint got a clue. Fine, you have your right to your opinion. Get me lynched then. My last mafia game this is.

 

[Moar]

Really annoyed. Sorry to the town , but then I am apparently a liability anyway.

Vote: Moar

 

[Caluin Graye]

I just reread the thread. Did it once before, but was in bad shape then. So apparetly I am "frazzled" an aint got a clue. Fine, you have your right to your opinion. Get me lynched then. My last mafia game this is.

I think you're taking things a bit too personally. In the end, it's still simply a game played amongst friends. Sometimes the game goes splendidly. Other times you get caught on the first day being scum for cases built against you while you were town.

The trick is to let it pass, not let people get under your skin, and never, ever hold a VENDETTA against someone.

 

[Kestegs]

Really annoyed. Sorry to the town , but then I am apparently a liability anyway.

Vote: Moar

That's really a bad idea. It only makes me feel you are even more scummy.

I think you're taking things a bit too personally. In the end, it's still simply a game played amongst friends. Sometimes the game goes splendidly. Other times you get caught on the first day being scum for cases built against you while you were town.

The trick is to let it pass, not let people get under your skin, and never, ever hold a VENDETTA against someone.

Agreed, except on the vendeta part. Vendetas are the best part of the game!

 

[Caluin Graye]

I was the king maker and without a night I didn't do anything with it. I would assume one is not randomly due to no night actions.

Hypothetically speaking; if there had been a night phase last night, who would you have made king?

 

[flubbucket1]

1. After the last messages, I do think this must have been the thing. SI going for CG is a good play as well. CG is one of the strongest players (while according to flubb i am just rubbish, you will be alone on your rug for a long time flubby...) so getting rid of him is a good mafia play if he's not on the team.

2. Waiting for Gory there. I asked if he would not be allowed to tell that he had the role twice.

3. That's why i asked if Paris was around last night.

So you want some pics of me on the rug maybe??

I just reread the thread. Did it once before, but was in bad shape then. So apparetly I am "frazzled" an aint got a clue. Fine, you have your right to your opinion. Get me lynched then. My last mafia game this is.

I quit for a short time to decide if I had the stomach for this abuse. Comments from players which I took personally, realized it wasn't aimed at me but was all part of the game.

Don't quit.

I think you're taking things a bit too personally. In the end, it's still simply a game played amongst friends. Sometimes the game goes splendidly. Other times you get caught on the first day being scum for cases built against you while you were town.

The trick is to let it pass, not let people get under your skin, and never, ever hold a VENDETTA against someone.

This. And what kestegs said....sorta

 

[flubbucket1]

Oh I almost forgot....


Since no one ever asked me....derp


Solar Ice was the BFF...was that is

 

[Kestegs]

Oh I almost forgot....

Since no one ever asked me....derp

Solar Ice was the BFF...was that is

Maybe nobody cared?

..

Jk.


What made you pick solar, and did you glean anything useful from your conversation?

Also what were you yesterday? Spammer?

 

[Bad Ash]

Well Moar, if you are doing that because of my post I wouldn't.

First, the post I where I voted for you for not reading the thread, was more of a judgement on others you have railed on me for it, I am just as guilty of it as you are. Skimming gets the best of us.

Secondly, I never mean anything offensive. I play with emotion, but I don't ever want to hurt anyone and if I did, I apologize.

Third, if you dislike me, PM Noodle, I think he has my rug size on file.

Fourthly, if this has nothing to do with me, then I would suggest applying these to whoever it is, because like others have said, it is just a game amongst friends.

Fifthly, I kinda want to vote for flub. Anyone else get this feeling?