INT-ARESTING.
If someone else made a statement like this, would you give them town points, or scum points? Why?
Create Your Own Role Mafia game
- Thread starter Goryani
- Start date
INT-ARESTING.
If someone else made a statement like this, would you give them town points, or scum points? Why?
I don't like being called "idiot" and that I was. You do better without me then.
thefranklin
Well-known member
You are not going to let yourself forget that one. And Vendetta's are just the best. Did you happen to have one against Ankeli for some reason?
Good question. I would have chosen one of the people least likely to be lynched. If they appeared more town than scum, great.
If not, hope we are not close enough to the end of the game that mafia would try for a one for one trade. Pyro would most likely have been my choice.
thefranklin
Well-known member
I was feeling the exact same way last game, someone does something very scummy and acts like a freaking 12 year old girl when you call them out on it, then other people join their side and make it worse.
thefranklin
Well-known member
What do ya know, does "reply with quote" do something different now?
I certaily have the stomach to be called names (mafia) one game or the other, but you took it a bit further by saying whay you did. I won't play another game.
What I react to has actually nothing to do with this game. It was the comment by flubb about me being "frazzeled" which pretty much meant that I can't play the game, any game. He is absolutely entiteled to that opinion, but it did hurt me to read about it and I will take the consequence and make this my last mafia game.
This will make you feel better, why don't you join me?
Unvote: Moar
Vote: flubbucket
My reasoning is the Solar being the BFF comment. I don't like it, I don't trust it, and I think its a link to SI by flub who was paris and wanted to keep his scum buddy close.
Also, If Solar Ice would have been the BFF HE WOULD HAVE LOST HIS JOE BLACK ROLE AND ONLY BEEN THE BFF!
he kept it.
BOOM ROASTED FLUBBY BOY. (unless im wrong)
Tiny Print:
Your role rotates but the BFF stays the BFF until death.
You will be told the identity of the BFF, if one already exists, when receiving this role.
Your Hammer vote on the BFF will be identified as Paris.
You may not quote from any Paris night chat to any other thread but you may paraphrase information.
You may not share links to any Paris night chat with anyone.
So my post might have been a bit rash, but the BFF stays the BFF until death? Do we think that is why Solar Ice kept his Joe Black role?
How likely is it that the mafia would make another mafia his BFF? How likely is it that a mafia would have made a townie his BFF?
Some questions, the hammer has not been broughteth down, I got a wee bit excited. Vote stands until I get some answers though.
Your role rotates but the BFF stays the BFF until death.
You will be told the identity of the BFF, if one already exists, when receiving this role.
Your Hammer vote on the BFF will be identified as Paris.
You may not quote from any Paris night chat to any other thread but you may paraphrase information.
You may not share links to any Paris night chat with anyone.
So my post might have been a bit rash, but the BFF stays the BFF until death? Do we think that is why Solar Ice kept his Joe Black role?
How likely is it that the mafia would make another mafia his BFF? How likely is it that a mafia would have made a townie his BFF?
Some questions, the hammer has not been broughteth down, I got a wee bit excited. Vote stands until I get some answers though.
You are wrong. The BFF was additional to any other role. I would know since it was my creation. And as I said before, scum taking a scum BFF wouldn't make sense (because of the hammer vote). Couldhappen though if flubb didn't think it through.
What are you smoking?
The role was out of business before anything much could happen. Solar and flubb might have have had a cosy nightchat, but that's all. The voting things wouldn't have been in play before D2 an there the role was already removed (sadly).
Then my vote for flubb isnt changing this day phase I dont think unless something else comes through. The hammer vote is almost irrelevant in this case. If your mafia buddy is going down, he's going down and you look scummy if you arent on the bandwagon to begin with.
Secondly, having a mafia member be the BFF gives the mafia an advantage. The night talk can be used to gain credibility with non-mafia members and get them on their side.
Thirdly, If we want to just get to the basics of it, if flub was town, there is a 25%-ish chance that he would have picked a mafia member to be the BFF. Plausible odds, but 70% ish chance he chose a townie and he didnt (the remaining 5% is because flub is a town member in this scenario)
since Paris changes but still communicates with the BFF I think, if I was a mafia Paris, on day 1, I would make a mafia the BFF for the potential for gained credibilitiy by night talking other Paris' who arent in your group.
Counter Arguement against what I just posted?
This was a post by Solar Ice, during day 1. He wasn't the BFF at this point though, so there is that to take into consideration, and if flub was his teammate, wouldnt have known flub was Paris due to no night 1, but day 1.
Caluin Graye
New member
Yes. You should read Asrrin's Half-Life themed game. It's actually a good game to read, and the ending is spectacular in how I self-destruct and cost the town the win.
Another counter to my flub being mafia arguement:
"Your BFF will enter a period of mourning should you ever die (silenced + voteless for a day)."
This might be the most important piece of the puzzle that could clear flub. Still IDK.
A voteless and silenced player "most likely" wouldnt be voted off?
Lets roleplay: If you were mafia Paris on Day 1 would you BFF your teammate or no? Lots of pros and cons. This could be a big waste of time, and not trying for it to be, just looking for direction on where to go this day phase, if we need to move on, we can, but still wondering what peoples answer to this question is.
"Your BFF will enter a period of mourning should you ever die (silenced + voteless for a day)."
This might be the most important piece of the puzzle that could clear flub. Still IDK.
A voteless and silenced player "most likely" wouldnt be voted off?
Lets roleplay: If you were mafia Paris on Day 1 would you BFF your teammate or no? Lots of pros and cons. This could be a big waste of time, and not trying for it to be, just looking for direction on where to go this day phase, if we need to move on, we can, but still wondering what peoples answer to this question is.
MartinLong
New member
I may be picking at straws, but to me it looks like you're just going along with where the pressure is at and applying more.
Which advantage is this?
Flubb said SI was BFF.
SI is now dead.
If flubb is lying, then either another living townie is a BFF and not telling us (stupid) or mafia is the BFF.
Now, lets see what happens here.
Next day Paris gets a thread for her and her BFF ... Hmmm, there shouldn't be one since SI was the 'claimed' BFF. That means that flubb was lying and he is scum. Next day, easy lynch.
This doesn't make sense. In no way would this plan ever make sense. There is no advantage here as Paris will find out whose lying at night.
If there is a mafia BFF still alive, it's an easy lynch for us.
A coin flip has 50/50 odds of showing heads. I could flip the coin 100 times in a row and get heads every time.
What is the relevance? The odds mean nothing. Especially at D1 where reads are quite hard.
And here is where I really think you are going with the flow, making flawed points to try to get attention on to flub.
We have a BFF that is dead. If there is a BFF still in the game, which Paris will find out about at night, flub gets lynched. In this case as well, the mafia BFF wouldn't want to even talk in that thread, as they will uncover their identity, then get lynched as well.
For now, I suspect you are scum.
Vote: Bad Ash
Caluin Graye
New member
Sort of rereading a couple things. Another question for franklin.
I know you said this two days ago, but could you elaborate a bit? The way I'm reading this is that you state the politician role is more useful to scum than to town. I don't argue that. Next, you say "it is really good for them, though." Who is them? Are you still referring to the scum? If so, why the redundant phrasing? Maybe it's the 'though' word throwing me off, making me think you've referenced the town. Hence, why I'm asking for elaboration.
Also, the last sentence just seems out of place to me. How does everyone having a power role effect the politician's roleblock target?
I realize it seems like I'm picking on you. There's a reason for that. Solar Ice never engaged you directly. Granted, Solar wasn't around for very long, but he asked questions, quoted, and responded to just about everyone at least once. But not you, not that I can find. Connections can be suspicious, but some times the lack of connections are just as suspicious. I'm interested in what you think about that.
I know you said this two days ago, but could you elaborate a bit? The way I'm reading this is that you state the politician role is more useful to scum than to town. I don't argue that. Next, you say "it is really good for them, though." Who is them? Are you still referring to the scum? If so, why the redundant phrasing? Maybe it's the 'though' word throwing me off, making me think you've referenced the town. Hence, why I'm asking for elaboration.
Also, the last sentence just seems out of place to me. How does everyone having a power role effect the politician's roleblock target?
I realize it seems like I'm picking on you. There's a reason for that. Solar Ice never engaged you directly. Granted, Solar wasn't around for very long, but he asked questions, quoted, and responded to just about everyone at least once. But not you, not that I can find. Connections can be suspicious, but some times the lack of connections are just as suspicious. I'm interested in what you think about that.
