Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

Vote: Jason Maher

Best thing about some being already locked when I check in.:badteeth:

Alas, I haven't been able to read the thread properly, only skim. Pretty much my only initial thought was surprise at only 1 kill. There's so many villains that could potentially be in a Batman game, I was pretty much certain there'd be 2 scum groups. Perhaps we'll see tonight.

Now the question is, who to prosecute? I won't be around at 7 a.m. my time (when day ends), so I'll have to make a decision now. Joanna definitely appears to be trying to pass herself off as a VI, but it's Joanna - how would anyone ever tell the difference? Seems as good a place for my second vote as any.

Prosecute: omgwtfbbqpwned

aka Joanna, for those who didn't get the reference.
 
Caluin Graye said:
Why are you so interested in Moar's defense of herself? What is she to you? I haven't seen you call her town yet. If I attack someone else, would you jump to their defense too so long as it wasn't Goryani?
Click to expand...

Moar's alignment is unknown, she shared the same Gory is weird feeling and got us grouped together by you. I did not jump in her defense, you are throwing darts at BA, me, Moar and then stated you had two scum suspects.

Caluin Graye said:
You're projecting your own preconceived notions onto me, and your logic is flawed. I'm calling Moar scum because she's waffling on whether she should join in on the Goryani lynch train, and I'm calling Franklin scum for his adamant defense of her as well as his odd ball quote in post #286. If I think they're both scum, then by lynching Goryani tomorrow wouldn't I be letting them go another two days?
Click to expand...

Adamant defense of her? Ha, she had a good response to your nonsense and I gave it a thumbs up. Then you wallowed answering her questions. So if thinking she is more town than you, then sure call it whatever you want! I know you will!

While you are telling everyone what I am doing with my play, you forget to mention how much I have been trying to get everyone else to follow my lead in 286, I have revisited that topic so many times I can't believe you forgot it. /sarcasm

All in all, it looks like you are trying to distract everyone from using the prosecute. Is one of your buddies on it? Should I be voting for BA now that you have completely forgot about him?

Release: crawlingdeadman
Prosecute: Bad Ash
 
Goryani said:
I fell asleep last night before getting to new stuff. Unfortunately, I don't have much new stuff and less time to talk about said new stuff.

The BA vs Noodle thing has gone from weird to weird but not in a good way. Jokes are understandable but today the votes are real and the lynch is real. I'd think that if either is serious about the other, one would have made a case by now.

Noodle, BPC, cdm and omg all have playstyles that are likely to earn some votes on any day of any game. All are "easy" lynches in that one just has to give the usual reason and it's more than likely to be applicable this game.

Prosecute: BipolarChemist feels right this game. Not sure if I'll make it back before the end of the day.
Click to expand...

I agree with most of this. What strikes me as odd is that you then choose to Prosecute BPC, one of the 'easy' lynches. It seems like you're hinting that Bad Ash and Noodle are making a show of things. So why then Prosecute BPC?

Prosecute: Bad Ash
 
Ankeli said:
Kegs, this here.



The whole post reeks LAMIST to me, and I'm pretty certain that FOE is in team with Mal, trying to distance himself when he noticed things were going south. He was in the latter half of people voting for Mal, and then comes up with this post as his reasoning = I'm 99% certain that he's anti-town and in league with Mal.

The scumdar is online! :)

I'm also surprised there was only 1 kill. Yeah, they must have other powers besides killing, but only 1? Odd. Raises thoughts on Goryani, given that we can trust Mal blocking him and not just setting him up for a lynch.
Click to expand...

Why is this addressed to me?
 
pharphis said:
your count on bpc is wrong, or you included 2 names for some reason. I'm not sure.
Click to expand...

Count is correct as far as I'm aware, Moar released BPC in 329. If anyone else would like to check please feel free.

Count as of #405:

11 to lynch, 12 to lock

Vote:
Malevolent(12): djmbbandie, Valhauros, flubbucket, Solar Ice, Ankeli, Caluin Graye, FredofErik, kestegs, omgwtfbbqpwned, Moar, pharphis, Noodle
Djmbbandie(1): Malevolent
Jason Maher(1): Jason Maher

Malevolent has been locked, he will be lynched at the end of the day phase.

Prosecution:
Bad Ash(5): Noodle, coju, Valhauros, thefranklin, Caluin Graye
Omgwtfbbqpwned(4): FredofErik, flubbucket, BipolarChemist, Jason Maher
BipolarChemist(2): (Moar), Goryani, pharphis
Noodle(1): Bad Ash
Crawlingdeadman(0): (thefranklin), (coju), (Solar Ice)

Day ends in approximately 4 hours and 15 minutes.
 
Last edited:
Hey all, sorry for not being around. Hope it doesn't get me killed, but if it does, so be it. Should have posted after work yesterday, but I ran out of time to make an intelligent response so I didn't. Today, I'm too busy with real life. Here's my "contributive" post: Everyone's scum...or town.... except for the neutral character(s).


Have a good weekend, y'all! :wave:
 
I think the only person up for prosecute I could see myself voting for is bpc. The others just haven't given me anything to really make me think they're scum.

Not sure I'm even ready to vote him.
 
coju said:
Why that Franklin?
Click to expand...

I was wondering if CG would follow suit, balk at voting BA because of me, or actually question BA today. What do his actions tell me? Absolute nothing.

I also saw you had voted BA, and your original vote on BA was because of Noodle's waterboard comment. And you also jumped on voting for cdm when I prodded him earlier. So I have had suspicion on you, hence I don't want to vote with you right now.
 
I apologize for my absence, something more serious than mafia has come up this last week, I will try to do a decent read thru of the game and hope to contribute to the game as soon as possible.
 
omgwtfbbqpwned said:
What's with the CDM train? It started without any reason. That omg fella looks too awesome to hurt as well. Let's not get him.

Occam's Razor, just gonna take it that he does have a freeze gun. Although it's weird that the investigation read-out would reveal weapons, since quite a few Batman villains tend to not have a weapon.

Vote: Malevolent
Click to expand...

This is OMG's only constructive post so far this game. He made sure to get in on the Mal lynch, and he pointed out the cdm train that someone else already pointed out earlier.

Prosecute: omgwtfbbqpwned
 
Laarz said:
I apologize for my absence, something more serious than mafia has come up this last week, I will try to do a decent read thru of the game and hope to contribute to the game as soon as possible.
Click to expand...

Laarz contribute? Obvious scum is obvious.
 
Then again, cdm hasn't made a contributive post this day phase either.

Prosecute: crawlingdeadman

I'll change my vote to help us get a lynch at the end of the day if need be.
 
Malevolent said:
Unfortunately for me there are no other members in my mafia group, i beleive there are several 1-man groups of mafia floating around. In the batman comics and movies, when do you ever see 4+ villians team up? it doesnt happen.
Click to expand...

Well at least you made this easy for us. I would be surprised if this was the truth, bad guys seem to often work together, at least in movies I have seen and games I have played.

BipolarChemist said:
#conestogamall #shopping #movies
Click to expand...

So you are following in omg's footsteps now? Why did you post this?

5 chioces for prosecute:
Noodle and BA - taking thier cometition a bit farther this game
BPC and omg - more posts, but none have been particularly helpful
cdm - lurky

Of these I find omg the most suspicious, although BA is up there too.

Prosecute: Omgwtfbbpqpwned
 
Gwaihir said:
Well at least you made this easy for us. I would be surprised if this was the truth, bad guys seem to often work together, at least in movies I have seen and games I have played.



So you are following in omg's footsteps now? Why did you post this?

5 chioces for prosecute:
Noodle and BA - taking thier cometition a bit farther this game
BPC and omg - more posts, but none have been particularly helpful
cdm - lurky

Of these I find omg the most suspicious, although BA is up there too.

Prosecute: Omgwtfbbpqpwned
Click to expand...

I thought about mal's post and having the anti-town separated frmo one another turns this into a game that isn't a mafia game. if they're nto a s a team they may as well all be SKs. Even so, there isn't much in the favor of the town at that point because it's too hard to make connections between members of the mafia especially if there are no mafia. So I think he's lying.
 
Caluin Graye said:
I agree with most of this. What strikes me as odd is that you then choose to Prosecute BPC, one of the 'easy' lynches. It seems like you're hinting that Bad Ash and Noodle are making a show of things. So why then Prosecute BPC?
Click to expand...

A bit of the watcher/tracker idea and a bit of him not quite behaving as his easy lynch self. He got serious in his first post this day phase (after he had a prosecute vote already) but it seemed the goal was to avoid being lynched or find out more about djm's role than to find scum.
 
I wonder if Male's insistence on dj releasing BPC was only to keep the tie or if there is a connection between Male and BPC.
 
I'm out of town till tomorrow and busy so no clue what's happening in the game. Don't sink to Anarky! While I'm gone

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top