That's two... I'm befuddled. What post(s) do you consider my defense for Mal?
Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game
- Thread starter Pyrotechnician1
- Start date
That's two... I'm befuddled. What post(s) do you consider my defense for Mal?
Oh no... they're on to me...
oops...
I mean...
Comedy. I posted that pic in response to someone calling me scummy while quoting me posting a pic. I chose that pic because of it's scummy nature since it makes the humor that much better.
I concur with the contradiction label but I don't quite understand your contradiction point. The third point seems to contradict the first two. Point one looks fairly certain. Point two is absolutely certain. Point three looks to be a friendly disclaimer. "Of course I'm not mafia because I'm not positive that Mal is scum."
Additionally, each response is fairly typical of mafia bussing a teammate. "A definite despair move." "Give it up, you were caught and not you must pay." "I'm not certain you are mafia.... "
Second person to assume djm was a watcher/tracker (Val was the first)....
I see no possible way someone can view djm's claim as that of a watcher/tracker unless they have inside knowledge about who Mal targeted with what ability.
This seems an appropriate place to share some thoughts...
I think Moar always labels someone(s) VI. She definitely does it often.
thefranklin always calls me scummy in the first couple of days. I'm his de facto target.
They each do those behavior patterns so often that I wouldn't use those patterns to judge their behavior in this game.
preview edit: how many in a row is this?
I didn't/don't think Mal targeted Drixx. You did. You thought djm watched/tracked the use of a Freeze Ray (I assumed it to be kill flavor for Mr. Freeze) on a target. That implied you thought djm tracked Mal targeting Drixx or you thought djm watched Drixx get targeted by Mal.
BipolarChemist
New member
I was talking about Mal in #290. Mal made a number of contradictions/slips and I was encouraging Mal (or teammates) to talk more about one of them.
Placing a vote on someone you consider townie is a contradiction. I wanted to know why it happened. Everything Mal said about rolecops being mafia is true enough to require consideration. djm is not guaranteed to be townie simply because he found scum N1/D1.
Do I ever avoid attention?
You read that wrong.... I thought your idea was one of the most townie moves I've seen in a while. If it hadn't been for djm's claim, I'd probably still be thinking you were townie.
I get what you meant now.
flubbucket1
New member
I would never underestimate you. I'm just too pretty to do such a thing.
But...but...but...
I guess the $64,000 question is, are you two on the same team....
Would I claim to "role block" my scum bag team mate??Kegs, this here.
The whole post reeks LAMIST to me, and I'm pretty certain that FOE is in team with Mal, trying to distance himself when he noticed things were going south. He was in the latter half of people voting for Mal, and then comes up with this post as his reasoning = I'm 99% certain that he's anti-town and in league with Mal.
The scumdar is online!
I'm also surprised there was only 1 kill. Yeah, they must have other powers besides killing, but only 1? Odd. Raises thoughts on Goryani, given that we can trust Mal blocking him and not just setting him up for a lynch.
The whole post reeks LAMIST to me, and I'm pretty certain that FOE is in team with Mal, trying to distance himself when he noticed things were going south. He was in the latter half of people voting for Mal, and then comes up with this post as his reasoning = I'm 99% certain that he's anti-town and in league with Mal.
The scumdar is online!
I'm also surprised there was only 1 kill. Yeah, they must have other powers besides killing, but only 1? Odd. Raises thoughts on Goryani, given that we can trust Mal blocking him and not just setting him up for a lynch.
FredOfErik
New member
Kegs, this here.
The whole post reeks LAMIST to me, and I'm pretty certain that FOE is in team with Mal, trying to distance himself when he noticed things were going south. He was in the latter half of people voting for Mal, and then comes up with this post as his reasoning = I'm 99% certain that he's anti-town and in league with Mal.
The scumdar is online!
I'm also surprised there was only 1 kill. Yeah, they must have other powers besides killing, but only 1? Odd. Raises thoughts on Goryani, given that we can trust Mal blocking him and not just setting him up for a lynch.
Yeah, I was in the latter half of the votes, but DJ posted his result at midnight my time (I was out drinking) and I immediately voted for him when I woke up and read the thread the next day (at around noon). Didn't really have the option to be in the first half of the votes.
Whether or not it was a LAMIST post, I can't really comment on - I posted my thoughts, and those thoughts still stand (and I'm pretty sure nobody would disagree with them). You're scumdar is broken.
OT: today is my birthday, so I probably won't be around much before next day phase.
flubbucket1
New member
Just got back from doing some work and had some thoughts. Yes I nearly had a stroke but I pushed through. The possibility of multiple mafia factions raised by others and Ankeli's curiosity why only one NK got me wondering. Since we didn't get any kind of information on Drixx, is it possible he could have been scum? Since I've never hosted a game, I'm not at all sure how the "math" works on night actions. If Drixx had a NK action would Malevolent's alleged roleblock have stopped it? Or if Malevolent had actually killed him would that have stopped Drixx' NK action?
wut ?
I fell asleep last night before getting to new stuff. Unfortunately, I don't have much new stuff and less time to talk about said new stuff.
The BA vs Noodle thing has gone from weird to weird but not in a good way. Jokes are understandable but today the votes are real and the lynch is real. I'd think that if either is serious about the other, one would have made a case by now.
Noodle, BPC, cdm and omg all have playstyles that are likely to earn some votes on any day of any game. All are "easy" lynches in that one just has to give the usual reason and it's more than likely to be applicable this game.
Prosecute: BipolarChemist feels right this game. Not sure if I'll make it back before the end of the day.
The BA vs Noodle thing has gone from weird to weird but not in a good way. Jokes are understandable but today the votes are real and the lynch is real. I'd think that if either is serious about the other, one would have made a case by now.
Noodle, BPC, cdm and omg all have playstyles that are likely to earn some votes on any day of any game. All are "easy" lynches in that one just has to give the usual reason and it's more than likely to be applicable this game.
Prosecute: BipolarChemist feels right this game. Not sure if I'll make it back before the end of the day.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Oh Gory, so close for longest string of posts, maybe next time.
Count as of #396:
11 to lynch, 12 to lock
Vote:
Malevolent(12): djmbbandie, Valhauros, flubbucket, Solar Ice, Ankeli, Caluin Graye, FredofErik, kestegs, omgwtfbbqpwned, Moar, pharphis, Noodle
Djmbbandie(1): Malevolent
Malevolent has been locked, he will be lynched at the end of the day phase.
Prosecution:
Bad Ash(3): Noodle, coju, Valhauros
Omgwtfbbqpwned(3): FredofErik, flubbucket, BipolarChemist
Crawlingdeadman(1): thefranklin, (coju), (Solar Ice)
Noodle(1): Bad Ash
BipolarChemist(1): (Moar), Goryani
Count as of #396:
11 to lynch, 12 to lock
Vote:
Malevolent(12): djmbbandie, Valhauros, flubbucket, Solar Ice, Ankeli, Caluin Graye, FredofErik, kestegs, omgwtfbbqpwned, Moar, pharphis, Noodle
Djmbbandie(1): Malevolent
Malevolent has been locked, he will be lynched at the end of the day phase.
Prosecution:
Bad Ash(3): Noodle, coju, Valhauros
Omgwtfbbqpwned(3): FredofErik, flubbucket, BipolarChemist
Crawlingdeadman(1): thefranklin, (coju), (Solar Ice)
Noodle(1): Bad Ash
BipolarChemist(1): (Moar), Goryani
Last edited:
Caluin Graye
New member
Just because you and a few others are so gung-ho to lynch someone does not mean I need to be. I decided to pursue other people acting scummy to me. I find them to be more likely to flip mafia than Goryani. It's not hesitation, it's pragmatism.
You're projecting your own preconceived notions onto me, and your logic is flawed. I'm calling Moar scum because she's waffling on whether she should join in on the Goryani lynch train, and I'm calling Franklin scum for his adamant defense of her as well as his odd ball quote in post #286. If I think they're both scum, then by lynching Goryani tomorrow wouldn't I be letting them go another two days?
Why should Goryani scum be more important to lynch than thefranklin scum? Or Moar scum?
Caluin Graye
New member
This is so out of left field that I snorted air through my nose heavily. How does me calling you scum at all relate to me asking if you are town power role? Hint: it doesn't. You know why? Because you're scum.
Why are you so interested in Moar's defense of herself? What is she to you? I haven't seen you call her town yet. If I attack someone else, would you jump to their defense too so long as it wasn't Goryani?
your count on bpc is wrong, or you included 2 names for some reason. I'm not sure.
However,
Prosecute: BipolarChemist
