Meh, why would I want to do the same thing twice? I really, really didn't think he was mafia and didnt want him lynched so quickly (and put some pressure on later to try and get him to really claim). I do think it was cool he fingered you as scum for it. And sorry for calling you names in the dead thread, heh. Every time I read your posts after you helped lynch me, it sounded like you were Jafar from Aladdin when you had turned into a snake. I hated Jafar.
The Most Extreme Elimination Challenge Mafia Edition
- Thread starter BipolarChemist
- Start date
Meh, why would I want to do the same thing twice? I really, really didn't think he was mafia and didnt want him lynched so quickly (and put some pressure on later to try and get him to really claim). I do think it was cool he fingered you as scum for it. And sorry for calling you names in the dead thread, heh. Every time I read your posts after you helped lynch me, it sounded like you were Jafar from Aladdin when you had turned into a snake. I hated Jafar.
Same diff (from my point of view). I needed 1 mislynch and it didn't matter to me when it occurred.
edit:
Though due to the mystery lynch rule, I guess it did matter.
I stand corrected: 1-1
That was a fun case to make.
Oh right that was you
Boo!
I'm glad town didn't listen to Zokar's idea of a mass name claim. Mafia didn't have fake claims, couldn't talk yet, and didn't have any NK example to emulate. That could have been really, really, really bad.
Not sure anyone cares, but here's my QT:
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/RrYB99F4tAWW
I had a 1 shot role cop and I used it on Zokar the night before he came forward with his name claim *blows smoke out of a finger pistol*
Also some drunk sleuthing (shocking I know).
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/RrYB99F4tAWW
I had a 1 shot role cop and I used it on Zokar the night before he came forward with his name claim *blows smoke out of a finger pistol*
Also some drunk sleuthing (shocking I know).
You were right on with Zokar almost immediately. I was impressed.
I'm a little disappointed that 2/4 vig kills this game were wasted. One was NKed (pyro) and the other was used to double kill Drixx. Gory, did it feel any better to kill him twice since you were forced to kill him once, anyway?
Also too bad Goldtru didn't listen to Gory when he suggested she fake her name claim. Mafia could have won pretty easily from that point I think.
We also didn't anticipate lightning rod + party host until the day we realized what the reward was and what the conditions for that reward was. We immediately realized that Drixx was 95+% sure to get the award. I felt so bad reading the mafia's night actions.
party host + amnesia = worst combo ever, right?Lightning Rod + Party Host = Best Combo Ever
All players can link to their QT if they're interested. Some had some cool thoughts/questions and others didn't use it at all.
- Dec 6, 2010
- 5,584
- 309
- 83
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/GqHKf5S2MKzK
that's my QT, only thing of real substance is a dream I had.
Goryani: sucks that lightning rod was used on two of your abilities!
that's my QT, only thing of real substance is a dream I had.
Goryani: sucks that lightning rod was used on two of your abilities!
Just read through all the roles...bravo on the vanilla ones. All of them were hilarious. I think "E" listener is my favorite.
No, I expected mafia to have at least 2 night actions (one being a replay), and that they would be preformed by different people. I thought the replayer was an every night deal, although I was wrong on it. So we have 2 scenarios:
1) There was a normal mafia goon - replayer would not submit kill and therefore a second mafia would target Drixx
2) All mafia were power roles - I found it unlikely that if the rest of the mafia were power roles, none had active powers they would submit, and therefore at least 2 mafia would be targeting Drixx
I did too. I was even amused by having the role power of tasting like vanilla.
Yeah, that early of a claim can either hose the mafia or the town, depending on how the game is set up.
Not much in mine:
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/hQHbywrGLGg
I didn't expect the mass name claim to work. I figured most people wouldn't actually go for it because it's kinda taboo in a way. W/o anything to fake, mafia are screwed in a lot of games, so mass claims (even just names) takes at least 3 days imo.
edit: I forgot to mention that I absolutely LOVED the fake claim gory came up with
edit: I forgot to mention that I absolutely LOVED the fake claim gory came up with
Valiantly so.
I was obnoxiously against this for selfish purposes obviously, but it would have been killer to the mafia for sure.
I think the Gory saving grace was his sink or swim ability. It just sounded so real (because it was) and fit with the genre...without Drixx bonus and lightning this is a LANDSLIDE mafia win.
I also have some candy and nuts for sale.
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/vcJBexHgPQ8Z - my QT. not much here, just pointing out my post restrictions mostly
Is this what the "Pick a number between 1-4" was all about?
We didn't know the rewards. We didn't know the penalties. We didn't know how either were handed out. We didn't know if we could receive either.
Feedback: It's really really really really hard for such a mysterious mechanic to benefit mafia. It reminds of the DreamingGod-like mechanic from RylehExiled's Roles of Madness game. I daresay the lack of information makes this mechanic town favored rather than mafia favored.
Feedback#2: I think it's really really really really fun for mafia to know the details of the rewards/penalties/eligibility/etc and try to put them to good use.
I liked the genericness of the role name flips. I don't think details such as 1x or triple decker or odd/even or whatever should be disclosed upon either lynch or rolecop. The ability to lie and fudge makes the game more interesting - for town and mafia.
I guess I misunderstood your original post then. I thought you were saying mafia wouldn't "risk" exposing a mafia power role as long as a plain goon could submit the NK. To me, it looked like you were saying: "well, Laarz wasn't the hitman since he flipped replay so that means a mafia goon faking a power role also targeted Drixx." I just disagree with that supposition in it's entirety and will do so each and every game it comes up.
Oh, and mafia had 0 repeatable night actions. We had 1 repeatable day action and a collection of X shot abilities.
Google