Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

Apologies for not posting yet today, I've been dealing with moving to another city, fairly unexpectedly.

As for thoughts thus far, I am fairly certain the FoE lynch today is the best course of action, but it's not like that opinion matters at this point. If the game is still going tomorrow, my lynch order would have to be: CG then Moar. I should have enough time tomorrow to go through and make a more informed decision, I've just been slammed today.

As for my scumminess, my best argument against that is that we've seen a day vig, plus whatever bad Ash is. I don't think that it is much of a stretch to say that there could be a night vig, which I have claimed. I had only 1-shot and it got wasted, so I'm VT at this point. I didn't trust Laarz's claim at the time, but I obviously do now, and I apologize for that but luckily it all came out nicely.

Frankly, I doubt there is much scum left in the game, considering we have 5 confirmed scum down, and who knows how many more were just killed randomly.
 
Well, that looks like the end of one of the worst mafia games I've played it looks (and that says quite a bit :badteeth:).

But indeed something fishy is going on. I didn't target CG last night, no. But I didn't target frankin either. WIFOM!
 
Caluin Graye said:
You sound like Laarz's results surprise you. Like you had expected him to say that he targeted Franklin too.



Doubtful a cult is in play. Doesn't match the lore very well.
Click to expand...

It did until you said that. Then I realized that obviously he couldn't have targeted Franklin because I didn't see him. Doh.

So foe lied about his target but Franklin didn't die for whatever reason. It just doesn't add up.
 
Pyrotechnician said:
Notice to all players: I have slightly changed the role reveals of some of the players as there seems to be some general confusion so please see the second post regarding this information.

I'm very sorry if this causes any issues.
Click to expand...

So male and goryani were both poisoners. Interesting. So we maybe do actually have 2 scum factions?
 
Day 6 End:

"I should have known it was you." - Says Batman

"I'm surprised at you Bats, you didn't even recognize me, you must be going crazy in your old age." - Says the Joker

"You're the only one that's crazy." - Says Batman

"Don't talk like one of them, you're not! Even if you'd like to be. To them, you're just a freak, like me. They need you right now. But when they don't, they'll cast you out, like a leper." - Says the Joker

"We'll just see about that." - Says Batman

*Batman and the Joker fight, but the Joker proves to be no match for Batman*

“I get the feeling that you and I are destined to do this forever” – Says the Joker

“You’ll be in a padded jail forever” – Says Batman.

Final Vote Count:
FredOfErik(5): Moar, kestegs, Caluin Graye, Laarz, thefranklin
Caluin Graye(1): FredOfErik

FredOfErik was lynched, he was:
The Joker – Mafia – The Last Laugh/Poisoner/Hitman

Elsewhere in Gotham…

Thefranklin, however strong he may have been, was not able to prevent his own demise. He too had fallen victim to a shooting pain, which unfortunately lead to his downfall.

thefranklin has died.

It is now Night 7. Night will last 24 hours.

Please submit Night Actions to me as soon as possible.

Please keep in mind that the deadline for submitting night actions is no later than one hour before the start of the Day Phase.
 
Last edited:
Day 7:
“Another quiet night. The Joker is now behind bars though, one of the most dangerous of them. If he wasn’t involved I would have been surprised.” – Says Gordon

“Leave it to criminals to be unsurprising.” – Says Batman

“They are quite predictable aren’t they, however there is more work to do, you better get back out there and try to find another lead. Somehow I feel this isn’t quite over yet.” – Says Gordon

“It never is.” – Says Batman

No one has died.

It is now Day 7 for the next 48 Hours. With 5 players alive, it takes 3 votes to lynch and 4 to lock the lynch.
 
Last edited:
Even was the last time we had a NK? Like 3 nights ago? Jeez!

So either mafia chose someone who was protected or we still have a poisoner out there.

So left we have:
BPC
Moar
CG
Laarz
Kestegs

(BA)

Those are also listed in order of my suspicion.

We are likely in mylo or lylo today, so let's choose carefully.

What do you have to say cg?
 
I'm about to go to bed and won't be online again before about 20 hours from now. Starting new job tomorrow.

I used the one shot doc ability on Laarz last night.
 
How's CG not some prisoner kind of role? He needs a certain number of days before he reveals? Or maybe it's kestegs even hell I don't know.

I fully expected Pyro to post that the game was over and CG had won in a cult format

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
 
Bad Ash said:
How's CG not some prisoner kind of role? He needs a certain number of days before he reveals? Or maybe it's kestegs even hell I don't know. I fully expected Pyro to post that the game was over and CG had won in a cult format
Click to expand...

As awesome as that would have been, that's not the case. Prepare yourself for the undramatic.

I'm a Commuter. Half of the night phases I return to Bludhaven and am completely non-targetable by night actions.

My idea from yesterday was that the last mafia member was Franklin and he was with-holding kills due to the poisoning nature and kestegs getting multiple hits with his watcher ability. If I were mafia and last on the 'to-be lynched list', I'd have done the same; with-hold kills, avoid being seen by the watcher, and let the town whittle themselves to LYLO.

Obviously I was pretty darn wrong about that, so thanks for clearing that up Freddie. The fact that Gwaihir flipped Mafia and other people were tagged as poisoners in the dead list also proved me false, but I decided to just go with it for a bit to gauge reactions. Unfortunately, the two people who reacted most scummy are the two people who can't be scum: Ash and Franklin.
 
I just want people to consider options before voting that was my sole purpose and that's all I can do as a stump. Don't think it's scummy that I think people should take a step back at your game and then make a decision.

On this day as well as the others I've mentioned your actions I would be fine supporting a lynch of an also scummy person but we surprisingly seem to be running out of them.

Moar is highest candidate in my book I believe

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
 
Caluin Graye said:
As awesome as that would have been, that's not the case. Prepare yourself for the undramatic.

I'm a Commuter. Half of the night phases I return to Bludhaven and am completely non-targetable by night actions.

My idea from yesterday was that the last mafia member was Franklin and he was with-holding kills due to the poisoning nature and kestegs getting multiple hits with his watcher ability. If I were mafia and last on the 'to-be lynched list', I'd have done the same; with-hold kills, avoid being seen by the watcher, and let the town whittle themselves to LYLO.

Obviously I was pretty darn wrong about that, so thanks for clearing that up Freddie. The fact that Gwaihir flipped Mafia and other people were tagged as poisoners in the dead list also proved me false, but I decided to just go with it for a bit to gauge reactions. Unfortunately, the two people who reacted most scummy are the two people who can't be scum: Ash and Franklin.
Click to expand...

You're right about one thing...that was anti climactic! What nights do you commute? What was your role name?

So who do you think we need to lynch today? That question applies to everyone alive, and people should start voicing their ideas ASAP so we can work some stuff out.

As for me? BPC. He's played pretty scummy all game, and I'm skeptical of his NK ability claim.

I watched moar visit Laarz last night, just as she said. If she is a poisoner he will die at day end, but I expect she is probably telling the truth. And if she is the last scum poisoner then we will be able to lynch her tomorrow. To be perfectly clear: Nobody else visited Laarz last night.
 
kestegs said:
You're right about one thing...that was anti climactic! What nights do you commute? What was your role name?
Click to expand...

Role name is 'Commuter'. I specifically left out what nights I commute.

kestegs said:
So who do you think we need to lynch today?
Click to expand...

BPC. He tried to shoot the doc. Also, he's the least likely to be town.

I know I'm town.

Bad Ash is a non-vote-able stump, so is probably not scum.

For kestegs to be scum, it means Noodle, Jason Maher, and CDM all had to have been scum too. With six confirmed lynched scum, that means at least ten in total. Possible? Maybe. Likely? No.

Moar has been acting pretty town the past couple days, but still has a fishy role all together (Kettle? This is Pot. You're of a non-primary colour nature).

Laarz could be faking the doctor claim, but I find that unlikely. Also, Silver Platter stolen from him by Moar suggests he is indeed Alfred as claimed. Therefore, for Laarz to be mafia, Moar has to be as well. I find that highly unlikely.

That leaves BPC. He tried to shoot the doc.
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top