Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Do you honestly believe "to stop mafia from taking it" is at all plausible for someone with the 2nd pick? How about 17th pick? How about any other pick?I agree with this completely, but as a townie that would have been my very first response. What I found odd was that neither coju nor pyro mentioned this reason over a total of what, 6 posts?
I vehemently disagree. "To stop mafia from taking it" is the worst reason for a townie picking ninja. It's worse than a townie picking ninja in the first place.why on earth would you give them that answer when neither had so much as mentioned it before? You on a team with one of them? Trying to tip them off to the answer that will let them off the hook?
Pyro said nothing about initial reason. Furthermore, his reason for townie taking ninja ISN'T to stop mafia from getting it. In Pyro's very next post (#57) he said a reason for townie picking ninja is so that mafia watcher/tracker won't find townie power roles that also target the townie ninja. While I agree with your later criticisms about that not being a great reason, I still think it's a better reason than "to stop mafia from getting it."Oh and look at that! Very next post Pyro now claims that was his initial reason. Maybe it was, or maybe you just listened to what your partner just recommended.