Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

[Asrrin]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

So is it just me, or is it awfully convenient that Sathoris is the last member alive from the NCIS mason group?

With kestegs dead and the game still continuing, the mole theory sounds entirely plausible. Another anti-town faction can easily hide among the mason group members seeking out the scum (the mafia and the serial killer) and ride himself to victory.

Vote: Sathoris

 

[coju]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I had an apifany while in the shower: Feysal isn't in the mafia group, right? So my accusation about him being a mole is frugal.

I'll have to look though the days here, but yes, Sath is the only one who defended so greatly about not being the mole.
Clicky!

 

[Uraj]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Cinco de Mayo? (Mexican day of the Dead, I believe that is the holiday's meaning.)
And there goes our Cop... Does this mean Sath is the only one who can investigate now or w/e?
7 known mafia killed by going over Feysal's post. How many are normally in a game with 26 players?

Usually the amount of anti-towns is close to 1/4 of players but this one seems to be at 1/3.

So is it just me, or is it awfully convenient that Sathoris is the last member alive from the NCIS mason group?

With kestegs dead and the game still continuing, the mole theory sounds entirely plausible. Another anti-town faction can easily hide among the mason group members seeking out the scum (the mafia and the serial killer) and ride himself to victory.

Vote: Sathoris

Just you, two of the players were modkilled for inactivity, the other was one of the story confirmed players and unsurprisingly the one with a power role. Maybe if Sathoris hadn't posted for an entire day phase and lived there would be reason to doubt.

We've already found two moles(Malevolent and kestegs) this game, do you really expect there to be a third? So you say this other anti-town faction would know precisely when the last mafia player was gone so they could start killing? But if we're going to look for another mole, this one is probably untrackable since the last two cop immune. Personally, I think the last anti-town is another mafia member.

I'll wait again to see if our last investigative role has any guilty results.

 

[coju]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Usually the amount of anti-towns is close to 1/4 of players but this one seems to be at 1/3.

That'd be between 6 and 9 (6 for 1/4th, 9 for 1/3'd).

We've already found two moles(Malevolent and kestegs) this game, do you really expect there to be a third? So you say this other anti-town faction would know precisely when the last mafia player was gone so they could start killing? But if we're going to look for another mole, this one is probably untrackable since the last two cop immune. Personally, I think the last anti-town is another mafia member.

I'll wait again to see if our last investigative role has any guilty results.

I'd like to point to post 682

At NCIS, a lone figure made his way past security and down a hallway, prepared to strike at his intended victim, she had been working late, well past the time that most others would normally leave for the day. He drew his gun and prepared to fire...

This would make me think that someone IN the NCIS was trying to kill Abby (who we believe the woman is). He made his way past security, they didn't stop him. He knew Abby would be down there and be a perfect victim. He knew where a mode of quick escape was should he need it. Not necessarily a mole, but an obvious anti-town player.

Spoiler

(I was going somewhere with this, but forgot...almost)N1 we know that BA is killed. Don't know anything else about him.
N2 we find out Ankeli is dead and he was the true Mike Franks and Pro-Town. He was killed with the scapel D1 ended with Zemaj's lynch, claiming Mike Franks, but lied and is a mafia goon.
I could go on, but y'all get the point. Nomarr was killed next, with a shot in the head, corax, the day before, cut his way out of a lynch.
(Yeah, I completely forgot where I was going...)

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

[highlight]Leopold Stotch has been modkilled for inactivity.[/highlight]

......:unimpressed:

Boogyman 19946 has been modkilled for not posting

......:unimpressed:

I had an apifany while in the shower: Feysal isn't in the mafia group, right? So my accusation about him being a mole is frugal.

Your thoughts regarding Feysal might hold water. He/she could have some ability to slip past guards at the facility (visiting son). However we have far too many folks currently who have gone uninvestigated (yourself included). So I'm not sure we can go with your epiphany just yet.


Keep showering tho....

 

[Asrrin]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Usually the amount of anti-towns is close to 1/4 of players but this one seems to be at 1/3.



Just you, two of the players were modkilled for inactivity, the other was one of the story confirmed players and unsurprisingly the one with a power role. Maybe if Sathoris hadn't posted for an entire day phase and lived there would be reason to doubt.

We've already found two moles(Malevolent and kestegs) this game, do you really expect there to be a third? So you say this other anti-town faction would know precisely when the last mafia player was gone so they could start killing? But if we're going to look for another mole, this one is probably untrackable since the last two cop immune. Personally, I think the last anti-town is another mafia member.

I'll wait again to see if our last investigative role has any guilty results.

I never said that Sath didn't have investigatory powers. It's quite likely that he could either be a lone gunman or working/has worked for a third(fourth?!) faction and can easily give himself cover acting as both an investigator and mason. How else do you explain the game still continuing despite having lynched do many mafisa players?

And many of the people we have lynched have not shown up as "mafia," only as anti-town, which further makes me believe there is a third faction.

I think Sathoris is highly suspect, but coju makes some sense about Feysal as well.

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

... Feysal isn't in the mafia group, right?...

Why is this statement true? I went through all of corax’ investigations and rethought your supposition regarding Feysal being a mole. I then looked at Feysal’s voting record. This is where it starts to look suspicious.

Anyone else care to take a look and give an opinion? I have already been accused/ignored and would rather have someone smart corroborate such evidence.

 

[coju]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

And many of the people we have lynched have not shown up as ...

Anything. Many of the players have not shown any side of play. Whether mafia or town. Pro-town nor Anti-town.

Why is this statement true? I went through all of corax’ investigations and rethought your supposition regarding Feysal being a mole. I then looked at Feysal’s voting record. This is where it starts to look suspicious.

Anyone else care to take a look and give an opinion? I have already been accused/ignored and would rather have someone smart corroborate such evidence.

(Are you asking if the statement is true? I believe I was asking the same question?)
I will have to look at Feysal's voting records. Fey is one of the only ones who have posted such great information for the town-the ones showing who is who, day/night kill statuses, and so forth. Great help for town, and great help not looking at such a helpful player... I didn't think of Feysal being the one who slipped passed the guards, although, being Abby's Mother(? is that correct) would allow her to slip past undetected.

 

[coju]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

For some reason I was thinking that Feysal's character was Abby's Mother. Which is wrong. #546 states that she is "Ducky's" Mother. Ducky is her son. So, she easily could have went past security and the story be the way it is.

 

[Flip10thMtn]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Also - who says Fey's role claim is true? Has there been an investigation to confirm.
Sure - to start "in-character" from day 1 is a long shot but also a fairly safe character to pick since supposedly harmless? Would Gorny PUT a harmless character into his game?

OT- Got another "day from Hell" at work and I might not be here for EOD - I will try and check from my phone but may not have time.

 

[coju]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

vote: Feysal

(lol... I thought I spell checked my misspelled 'Epiphany') Yes, lots of people have yet to go uninvestigated, but I don't think we can wait for everyone to get that way. Unless y'all want to, it won't bother me none; just make the game last longer.
(bed time)

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Has there been an investigation to confirm

I found nothing on Feysal.

Would Gorny PUT a harmless character into his game?

This is what makes me quite itchy right now. The assumption all along has been you are harmless. That's why when I looked at the voting record I got a bit of a chill.

 

[Uraj]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I'd like to point to post 682 This would make me think that someone IN the NCIS was trying to kill Abby (who we believe the woman is). He made his way past security, they didn't stop him. He knew Abby would be down there and be a perfect victim. He knew where a mode of quick escape was should he need it. Not necessarily a mole, but an obvious anti-town player.

I think that was just Ari Haswari the mafia hitman at the time. Search down to "Ari attempted to kill Abby Sciuto in her lab." Though I'm not sure she was in costume that episode, possibly the stories were merged to indicate how Abby stopped the attacker instead of DiNozzo.

I never said that Sath didn't have investigatory powers. It's quite likely that he could either be a lone gunman or working/has worked for a third(fourth?!) faction and can easily give himself cover acting as both an investigator and mason. How else do you explain the game still continuing despite having lynched do many mafisa players?

And many of the people we have lynched have not shown up as "mafia," only as anti-town, which further makes me believe there is a third faction.

I think Sathoris is highly suspect, but coju makes some sense about Feysal as well.

Five mafia players down, a sixth member doesn't seem too high to me. Maybe if the SK(P2P Killer) was more effective at killing, but as it is he only killed one player. That player's role Mike Franks was one he did kill in the series. Quite possibly he could only kill or maim those he did in the series. Since the mafia players are listed as anti-town as well, I don't see the other two revealed anti-towns as part of a collective other faction. If you want to count each of the individuals as another faction go ahead, just seems to be semantics to me.

I'm surprised you're jumping at a new faction doing the killing instead of it just being the mafia again. Are you the last mafia player and now need to direct the town's attention elsewhere?

 

[Uraj]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Also - who says Fey's role claim is true? Has there been an investigation to confirm.
Sure - to start "in-character" from day 1 is a long shot but also a fairly safe character to pick since supposedly harmless? Would Gorny PUT a harmless character into his game?

Well Gorny did stick Micheal Larson in as a role in the PLY game. I'm not sure on Feysal but he did claim the survivor early, later in the game Flub claimed a wincon that seems similiar and Flub has a recieved a pro-town result from corax.

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Why did Asrrin not vote on the last three lynches???

Why didn't I notice that???

Why is my reputation for being stupid warranted???

 

[Gorny1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

*Eats popcorn*

 

[Sathoris]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Why is this statement true? I went through all of corax’ investigations and rethought your supposition regarding Feysal being a mole. I then looked at Feysal’s voting record. This is where it starts to look suspicious.

Anyone else care to take a look and give an opinion? I have already been accused/ignored and would rather have someone smart corroborate such evidence.

I tracked Feysal because (I know you don't like to hear it Feysal, but I'm gonna anyway) he's too quiet again. I've seen him being said about having to play to his mafiawincon in a game once, so I doubt his survivor status makes him truly neutral.

He didn't visit Corax though, but I found a confused flurry of acitivity. Feysal went back and forth from his house and his front yard. Not sure what to make of that. But seeing as we've likely got one anti-town left (the hitman) I doubt Feysal is anti-town.

So is it just me, or is it awfully convenient that Sathoris is the last member alive from the NCIS mason group?

With kestegs dead and the game still continuing, the mole theory sounds entirely plausible. Another anti-town faction can easily hide among the mason group members seeking out the scum (the mafia and the serial killer) and ride himself to victory.

Vote: Sathoris

Just cause the game is still going on doesn't make a mole more likely. Having 7 dead anti-town means there is one left to have two 4 man teams. We also had an SK in the game.

You really think it's more likely to have a 3 and 4 man mafia team. An SK and another SK type? No. We've got two 4 man teams and an SK.

I think Sathoris is highly suspect, but coju makes some sense about Feysal as well.

Only here can I be labelled 'highly suspect' after giving the town three mafia lynches in a row. Your theory being they were all from a rival faction?

Why did Asrrin not vote on the last three lynches???

Interesting, hadn't looked at that yet. Even if Asrrin truly believed I were a mole trying to get town cred by giving the town the rival mafia faction's members he should still have voted for the people I mentioned because he would be lynching scum.

---

Asrrin is our best lynch by far. He hasn't voted for five! mafia members, including one with a cop guilty and two tracking results. He desperatly clings on to the mole theory to get a PR player lynched. He may not have been the hitman on Korial, but Kestegs was still alive and could have carried out the kill.

Vote: Asrrin

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

After going to lunch and thinking, (something I'm not equipped to do BTW), I simply couldn't rectify Asrrin's poor showing at the polls.

Vote: Asrrin

 

[Uraj]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I tracked Feysal because (I know you don't like to hear it Feysal, but I'm gonna anyway) he's too quiet again. I've seen him being said about having to play to his mafiawincon in a game once, so I doubt his survivor status makes him truly neutral.

He didn't visit Corax though, but I found a confused flurry of acitivity. Feysal went back and forth from his house and his front yard. Not sure what to make of that. But seeing as we've likely got one anti-town left (the hitman) I doubt Feysal is anti-town.

I think the confused flurry of activity points to the dementia suffered by Mrs. Mallard.

Asrrin is our best lynch by far. He hasn't voted for five! mafia members, including one with a cop guilty and two tracking results. He desperatly clings on to the mole theory to get a PR player lynched. He may not have been the hitman on Korial, but Kestegs was still alive and could have carried out the kill.

Vote: Asrrin

Actually seems to be only four mafia members he didn't vote for; Goryani, Gullik, Valhauros and kestegs. He did vote very late on the wagon for zemaj.

That said he was my top suspect for today due to lack of voting for any of the last four mafia and otherwise just posting to avoid modkill. Additionally I find how he claimed to have received information from Gorny following Goryani's lynch suspect. Kestegs also claimed something similiar for his roleblock on Goryani. Since you didn't find anyone last night:

Vote: Asrrin

 

[Gorny1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Sathoris: [1] (Asrrin)
Feysal: [1] (coju)
Asrrin: [3]: (Sathoris, Flub, Uraj)