Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Am I supposed to answer your questions or be quiet? Make up your mind!

Look at the voting records, scum have voted for each other, shocking I know. Either way, I've already said that I don't think you are part of the main Mafia faction.

I did plenty of scum hunting until I needed to step out of the spotlight after flip's claim. My abilities become much more valuable in the late game and I didn't want to squander them early on.

I don't know why I would want to jump on boogey when you look so obvious already. You keep saying I'm confirmed scum by "facts" that only you can "prove".

In one sentence you say asrrin is the last Mafia, then you say he was not the hitman? How can he be the last Mafia and not be the hitman?
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Last response because I have this crazy need to point out the obvious.

kestegs said:
Am I supposed to answer your questions or be quiet? Make up your mind!
Click to expand...

Rhetoric questions are rhetoric

kestegs said:
Look at the voting records, scum have voted for each other, shocking I know. Either way, I've already said that I don't think you are part of the main Mafia faction.
Click to expand...

Yes let's look at voting records. The only scum you voted for is Zemaj. You didn't vote for: Noodle, Goryani or Gullik. You however did vote for Gwaihir when I came forward with my claim. Gwaihir had a defense, I didn't believe it but there was doubt in the rest. You must've trusted me more than him because you voted for him. But then when Corax had a guilty on Gullik, undeniable proof, you suddenly don't want to risk it anymore? Why was my case on Gwaihir a better place for your vote but a cop guilty isn't? And I do want an answer on this one.

Now it's very possible that town won't vote for every scum. I didn't vote for Zemaj for example, but not voting for three?


kestegs said:
I did plenty of scum hunting until I needed to step out of the spotlight after flip's claim. My abilities become much more valuable in the late game and I didn't want to squander them early on.
Click to expand...

Yet your ability has still been of no help whatsoever to the town. And why did you need to 'step out the spotlight' (you weren't under any spotlight so that's laughable)? There was a claimed doc, cop, tracker. Yet you were afraid the mafia would instantly kill the roleblocker? The same roleblocker that flip just told us was anti-town and the same that we might get lynched? You may answer this one aswell.

kestegs said:
I don't know why I would want to jump on boogey when you look so obvious already. You keep saying I'm confirmed scum by "facts" that only you can "prove".
Click to expand...

Yet those "facts" were good enough for the rest to get Val lynched, and they were rewarded with a scum flip. You really think you're going to sway them to lynch me over you? You don't even have "facts"

And there is no mole, stop spreading mistrust.

kestegs said:
In one sentence you say asrrin is the last Mafia, then you say he was not the hitman? How can he be the last Mafia and not be the hitman?
Click to expand...

Because Gorny gave me some of my "facts" after I made that post. Can't deny those.


 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

vote: kestegs


my bad. I simply have nothing to go on bar my investigation being blocked. So i have decided to put my trust in my fellow mason partner.
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

don't forget gorny said we were now on a 24 hour day/night cycle peeps
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

corax said:
don't forget gorny said we were now on a 24 hour day/night cycle peeps
Click to expand...

True, only two votes so far for a total of 5 needed.

Even if you belive Kestegs over me, we can't ever be in a lylo situation with so many scum dead so even lynching Kestegs to prove I'm scum would be worth it. If you don't vote, you're scum. Simple as that.

Though I find a 24 hour day on Halloween very harsh, why can't we have 48 hours Gorny?


 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Sathoris claims he tracked kestegs on N6 and that kestegs went nowhere, while kestegs claims he blocked a not yet lynched Goryani.

Kestegs claims he blocked Sathoris on N7, while Sathoris claims he tracked Val visiting RlyehExiled.

Who to trust? I see more reason currently to trust Sathoris than kestegs.

Sathoris certainly seems to have the tracking ability as evidenced by knowing who Noammr and Gwaihir visited. The only possibility I see where he can have that information otherwise is if a different member of the mafia team had that ability but that he was the one to claim that information.
Sathoris has been on the last three mafia lynches while kestegs has been on none of them.

On the mass role claim day kestegs delayed for 12+hours before claiming. I can understand him being unable to give an accurate accounting of who he blocked each night, but he should have been able to immediately give his role name and power. Then when he did claim one of the reasons for who he targeted proved false. I also have trouble believing that the leader of Mossad would be pro-town, while a CIA agent in the same game ended up neutral. I also find his claimed targeting of Flip last night at the very least a bad choice, if not a lie. Since Flip should have been believed to be pro-town not just because he gave up the info about the roleblocker and his name but from the fact that Abby showed up in the Day 3 in the story. That same day Flip claimed to be attacked and no one counter-claimed.

Vote: kestegs
 
Sathoris said:
Last response because I have this crazy need to point out the obvious.



Rhetoric questions are rhetoric



Yes let's look at voting records. The only scum you voted for is Zemaj. You didn't vote for: Noodle, Goryani or Gullik. You however did vote for Gwaihir when I came forward with my claim. Gwaihir had a defense, I didn't believe it but there was doubt in the rest. You must've trusted me more than him because you voted for him. But then when Corax had a guilty on Gullik, undeniable proof, you suddenly don't want to risk it anymore? Why was my case on Gwaihir a better place for your vote but a cop guilty isn't? And I do want an answer on this one.

Now it's very possible that town won't vote for every scum. I didn't vote for Zemaj for example, but not voting for three?




Yet your ability has still been of no help whatsoever to the town. And why did you need to 'step out the spotlight' (you weren't under any spotlight so that's laughable)? There was a claimed doc, cop, tracker. Yet you were afraid the mafia would instantly kill the roleblocker? The same roleblocker that flip just told us was anti-town and the same that we might get lynched? You may answer this one aswell.



Yet those "facts" were good enough for the rest to get Val lynched, and they were rewarded with a scum flip. You really think you're going to sway them to lynch me over you? You don't even have "facts"

And there is no mole, stop spreading mistrust.



Because Gorny gave me some of my "facts" after I made that post. Can't deny those.
Click to expand...

The reason I haven't voted for more scum is because my vote was never needed. Those trains were obviously going to reach their destination with or without me, lately I've been more focused on defending myself.

Gwahir and gullik, I have a hard time keeping them straight, tbh. Its not like I didn't used to trust you, things just changed when you lied about me not blocking anyone. I don't have time to dig through my history as I'm on my phone.

I never thought I was in danger of getting nk'ed, no. Why would they nk someone who has claimed what I have?
I was just worried that this would happen, that I would end up not able to use my final ability.

Why am I the one who is spreading mistrust about a mole. First off, I wasn't the first person to mention it. Second, this is ncis, a mole is extremely reasonable within the confines of the story.


My "facts" are no less proven than yours. You just roleclaimed early so people are giving you more town cred. Can't say I blame them for giving you town cred, you've played very well, I would still be believing you as well if I didn't have proof that you lied.

vote: sathoris [\b]

This may be my last post of the day, but I'll try to check back in later.


 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

vote: kestegs
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Hope that counts. On phone and might not make eod
 
I see how it is....


With 5 votes I might as well spill the beans, since my fate is sealed.

I am the roleblocker just as I stated. I have the option to do an individual block on one person or I have an option to do a one time global roleblock. I was saving it for when I thought we might be in lylo trouble. Its moot now either way, I guess last night would have been a better option.

Happy Halloween everyone, and thanks for the game :)
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

This is why we only have 24/24. No need to push days longer when we're going to lynch someone anyhow. I have more to say, but it's useless right now.

Vote: kestegs

I'm going to have to go over the previous days. I'm just glad they're not 122 posts long as they were in the beginning.
 
Re: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

DAY LINKS

Day 1 - no deaths, unknown player and Caluin Graye attacked
Day 2 - Bad Ash killed, Sathoris knocked out
Day 3 - Ankeli killed by Jonas Cobb, Abby Sciuto attacked
Day 4 - Noammr killed
Day 5 - Laarz killed, Gwaihir attacked
Day 6 - Caluin Graye killed
Day 7 - no deaths, unknown player saved
Day 8 - RlyehExiled killed
Day 9 - korialstraz killed

ALIVE

Feysal
Claimed Mrs Mallard, town survivor (#993).
kestegs
Claimed Eli David, role blocker (#1151).
Sathoris
Claimed Tim McGee, watcher/tracker (#963). Knocked out and role blocked night 1, recruited into masonry night 2. Targeted Noammr night 0, boogyman19946 night 2, Gwaihir night 3. Targeted unknown night 4, learned nothing of importance (#1095).
Asrrin
Claimed Jackson Gibbs, vanilla town (#1126).
Flip10thMtn
Claimed Abby Sciuto (#702) and that there was a mafia role blocker (#660, #952, #1142).
coju
Claimed EJ Barrett (#1125).
flubbucket
Claimed Kate Todd, vanilla town (#1123).
boogyman19946
Claimed Ziva David, post-restricted vanilla town (#1124).
corax
Indirectly claimed Tony DiNozzo, cop. Survived lynch attempt (#885), claimed it was one shot (#907). Caught Noodle (#924). Claimed investigation results (#1132).
Uraj
Claimed Jenny Shepard, seeking Rene Benoit (#1139).

DEAD

Bad Ash - killed night 1. Flavor indicates James Korby.
zemaj - lynched day 2. Merton Bell, mafia goon, anti-town.
Ankeli - killed night 2. Mike Franks, pro-town, killed by Jonas Cobb.
Drixx - modkilled day 3. Jimmy Palmer, vanilla townie/backup doctor, pro-town.
Noammr - killed night 3. Flavor indicates watcher role, killed by unknown sniper.
Noodle - lynched day 4. Clayton Jarvis, SecNav, anti-town.
Laarz - killed night 4. Flavor indicates Jonas Cobb, killed by unknown sniper.
Gwaihir - lynched day 5. Trent Kort, CIA agent, neutral. Claimed neutral mason cop (#986). Partner with Noammr, who had separate investigation for finding mafia.
Malevolent - killed day 5. Michelle Lee, anti-town.
Caluin Graye - killed night 5. Flavor indicates protective role.
Goryani - lynched day 6. Michael Rivkin, mafia goon, anti-town.
Gullik - lynched day 7. Rene Benoit, anti-town.
RlyehExiled - killed night 7. Claimed Leon Vance, double voter (#1051).
Valhauros - lynched day 8. Ari Haswari, mafia hitman, anti-town.
PvtCaboose/Leopold Stotch - modkilled day 8. Leroy Jethro Gibbs, mason recruiter.
korialstraz - killed night 8. Claimed Ducky, doctor (#1155).

I think that is all of the claims and such. Now, kestegs seems to be one vote away from lock, and his claim contradicts Sathoris's. By this point, even if he is town, lynching him would be worth it to expose Sathoris, as he said himself.

Counting from this list, there have been six anti-town deaths we know of, possibly the serial killer too, though that is unconfirmed. There can't be more than one anti-town left, I think.
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

On second count, that's a lock. Six people have voted.

Vote: kestegs

For good measure.
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

About 15 minutes left and no boogery man...

We need to keep an eye on Gorny!

He seems to be doin' an awful lot of killin' his ownself!!!
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Kestegs shouted it takes six of you to lynch me and there's seven, I win!!!

However, as kestegs tried to calmly walk away from the lynchmob outside, he was grabbed by the arms and roped up and lynched without much of an actual fight. I'm chip! He shouted. I'm one of the good guys.

The rope went taught and kestegs yelled no more.

Kestegs was Charles "Chip" Sterling, Mafia Role blocker. Anti town.


[highlight]It is now nighttime, and you may not post for 24 hours. If you have reason to PM me, do so ASAP.[/highlight]
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Boogyman 19946 has been modkilled for not posting yesterday, he was Ziva David, pro town.
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

The day dawned rather quietly, no screams in the night, no car crashes or ambulance sirens. However the body of one Corax was found in an alley behind a building. At first glance, it seemed as if he had jumped. On closer inspection, he had a small wound from a needle in his neck. It seems that he was drugged then dumped off the top of a building, then fell to his death.

A Mexican Day of The Dead Doll was also found near him on the ground...

[highlight]Corax has been killed.[/highlight]


[highlight]It is now Daytime, and you may post freely for 24 hours, as there are 7 left alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch and 5 votes to lock.[/highlight]
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Cinco de Mayo? (Mexican day of the Dead, I believe that is the holiday's meaning.)
And there goes our Cop... Does this mean Sath is the only one who can investigate now or w/e?
7 known mafia killed by going over Feysal's post. How many are normally in a game with 26 players?
 
Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Survivor
A Survivor is a lone player whose goal is to live until any other faction achieves their Win Condition, be it Town or scum. If the Survivor dies, it loses.

Survivors are not known for getting any kind of compensation to help them achieve their Win Conditio
Click to expand...
So, you win no matter what? Is this the case now? That would be ultimate for the mole to have...
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top