Re: Halloween Saw themed Mafia game.
korial is taking a page from BA! "effing agressive" haha
Haha nah not really. I was tired of being called mafia for either trying to stay low, or do theorycrafting based on stories posted and roles that had been revealed, so I figured I'd try something different. Didn't work out so well either. Made me feel that no matter what you do, there's a chance people will accuse you of being mafia. Which sort of added this randomeness feel to the whole game, which I did not care for at all. >_>
That and I don't have the money to go visit my family and join a cool halloween party with my friends, so I'm stuck at home playing games. xD
anyways, korial, the problem with that is it outs our cop on day 1/2. I believe it can sometimes happen if they are 100% certain about getting a mafia and want to do the 1 for 1 approach.
Outing a cop to prove 2 people are townie is a big no no in my book
Ahh snap. I guess I didn't think that one through huh? Well I'm sure we can find a way to confirm this without lynching one of them.
But I'll try not to post some "good" solutions without thinking it through completely. I'll just shut up instead if I don't have time to view the outcome from all the angles.
No. Laarz more or less explained what I feel. Quoted below.
Mara you have the rolestealer role you need to use it, because if you dont the mafia will kill you to get rid of the role if it has a chance to expose them. I think you need to keep the person you target to yourself and confirm it the next day if you are both alive
What I mean was that we shouldn't have some overly complicated plan where the role-stealer announces his target before each night. He just chooses someone he feels might provide good intel for the town, and reveals it the next day. Unless there is something I'm forgetting, this means the mafia is kept in the dark, and we can still get info from the role-stealer while also keeping track of who has that role.
Okay, seems you guys don't want to lynch the mute. I prefer a lynch over a no lynch. So I'm putting on my inactivity police cap and vote for nurman. One post which to be fair wasn't very contributive.
Unvote: Gorny
Vote: nurman
Now see this is something I like seeing. Atm I feel like those who are inactive is staying low due to the activity going on. Me being poked and prodded, accused of being mafia, several people willing to lynch either Mara or Gorny etc. Basically staying low until day 1 is over and let the town go for a miss-lynch.
Vote: nurman
Any reasons for your inactivity nurman?
Mara you have the rolestealer role you need to use it, because if you dont the mafia will kill you to get rid of the role if it has a chance to expose them. I think you need to keep the person you target to yourself and confirm it the next day if you are both alive
The new rolestealer merely coming forth and saying the old rolestealer is pro-town or neutral or anti-town should be safe enough. Further details such as name, abilities, triggers, alternate win conditions (if safe for the town) should be kept private.
Isn't that exactly what was suggested? The role-stealer not announcing their target, and the day after simply saying that he/she was pro-town, and the person who had his/her role stolen simply saying they're the new role-stealer?