ultimabeam
New member
- Aug 5, 2005
- 324
- 0
- 0
Re: The Don S. Davis memorial Stargate mafia game.
Ok finally got caught up, though I will need to reread in greater detail and also do some serious research on the Stargate universe itself (I am coming from a place of ignorance re: the show).
The Goa'uld symbiote scenario seems plausible with Falcon, which would suggest two anti-town factions (Wraiths being the other).
I think Feysal's idea of a mass role reveal is bad, and definitely not in town's best interest. Whether that's a reason to peg him as anti-town or not is unclear, though, as Feysal is one to concoct some pretty outlandish schemes despite being pro-town.
Thyiad's wall of text is a pretty well-thought out parse of the first page and a half. I don't necessarily agree with him lumping Ankeli & Marahumm together, but I think his analysis of the Falcon situation is quite good.
I think boogy is the front-runner for best lynch target. He's jumpy, is making mistakes with names, has suggested that we pick lynch targets based on inactivity, and has offered a theory that seems fairly ridiculous to me (2 mafia factions + 1 cult). It's not strong evidence to go on by any means, but it's day one and we'll have to pick someone.
Vote: boogyman19946
Obviously I'm not dead-set on this, and if a better target presents itself I'm all for it. But early on in the game he seems like the best choice.
Ok finally got caught up, though I will need to reread in greater detail and also do some serious research on the Stargate universe itself (I am coming from a place of ignorance re: the show).
The Goa'uld symbiote scenario seems plausible with Falcon, which would suggest two anti-town factions (Wraiths being the other).
I think Feysal's idea of a mass role reveal is bad, and definitely not in town's best interest. Whether that's a reason to peg him as anti-town or not is unclear, though, as Feysal is one to concoct some pretty outlandish schemes despite being pro-town.
Thyiad's wall of text is a pretty well-thought out parse of the first page and a half. I don't necessarily agree with him lumping Ankeli & Marahumm together, but I think his analysis of the Falcon situation is quite good.
I think boogy is the front-runner for best lynch target. He's jumpy, is making mistakes with names, has suggested that we pick lynch targets based on inactivity, and has offered a theory that seems fairly ridiculous to me (2 mafia factions + 1 cult). It's not strong evidence to go on by any means, but it's day one and we'll have to pick someone.
Vote: boogyman19946
Obviously I'm not dead-set on this, and if a better target presents itself I'm all for it. But early on in the game he seems like the best choice.