ThunderCat
Active member
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
What's all this talk about fingering?
What's all this talk about fingering?
Zombie invasion Mafia game.
- Thread starter ThunderCat
- Start date
- Status
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
here is another giveaway for both Val and Ankeli. The post immediately after this one is TC asking where he ever voted for Ankeli. He saw a lynch train starting on ankeli and didn't want to be responsible for his scumbuddie's death, so in a fit of panic unvoted him. Jokes on him though, he never actually voted for Ankeli.
here is another giveaway for both Val and Ankeli. The post immediately after this one is TC asking where he ever voted for Ankeli. He saw a lynch train starting on ankeli and didn't want to be responsible for his scumbuddie's death, so in a fit of panic unvoted him. Jokes on him though, he never actually voted for Ankeli.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
short for "pointing the finger" at someone. I'd use FOS: target, but most people may not know the mafiascum lingo.
What's all this talk about fingering?
short for "pointing the finger" at someone. I'd use FOS: target, but most people may not know the mafiascum lingo.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
So we have Asrrin (post 7) and crazyivan (289) outside town. Wow what
has that scout been doing? Let's hope it wasn't gory or Uraj.
Oh go on then, what are you claiming?
Amusing OT; last time I saw "X could be framing Y" the person who
posted it was doing the framing. (Not that I'm suggesting you are, I
just thought it was funny.)
Just so you know Techno, some people in this game will NK you just
for posting wall of texts.
As for yesterday - well I still think Ankeli is mafia and the fake
doc claim left him free to do something nasty last night.
I have no real idea if Noodle is mafia or not. Mainly because I have
a hard time taking monkey-boy seriously anyway.
I can't comment on how others usually play as I rarely join these
things.
Sigh. Another role claim?
As for Val's post in 308. Oh good grief, the only saving grace is
that it didn't contain algebra. How did you work out everyone's roles
on day one? Seance with Uraj?
What is it with % crap - is it code between Valhauros, Asrrin, Krazeyivan, Bad Ash, Sathoris and Z_Y.
Ankeli explicitly calls Doc role. Yawn.
That's "deduce". "Deduct" means reduce.
You're not posting much Z_Y but you've made a couple of sensible posts.
Pfft. If you're going to take not reading the rules as a mafia tell then lynch me now because I've said at least twice I haven't really read them. So did someone else.
I'm still bemused why I thought more people voted Ank then switched. I'll go see if I can find all the unvotes.
So we have Asrrin (post 7) and crazyivan (289) outside town. Wow what
has that scout been doing? Let's hope it wasn't gory or Uraj.
Oh go on then, what are you claiming?
Amusing OT; last time I saw "X could be framing Y" the person who
posted it was doing the framing. (Not that I'm suggesting you are, I
just thought it was funny.)
Just so you know Techno, some people in this game will NK you just
for posting wall of texts.
As for yesterday - well I still think Ankeli is mafia and the fake
doc claim left him free to do something nasty last night.
I have no real idea if Noodle is mafia or not. Mainly because I have
a hard time taking monkey-boy seriously anyway.
I can't comment on how others usually play as I rarely join these
things.
Sigh. Another role claim?
As for Val's post in 308. Oh good grief, the only saving grace is
that it didn't contain algebra. How did you work out everyone's roles
on day one? Seance with Uraj?
What is it with % crap - is it code between Valhauros, Asrrin, Krazeyivan, Bad Ash, Sathoris and Z_Y.
Ankeli explicitly calls Doc role. Yawn.
That's "deduce". "Deduct" means reduce.
You're not posting much Z_Y but you've made a couple of sensible posts.
Pfft. If you're going to take not reading the rules as a mafia tell then lynch me now because I've said at least twice I haven't really read them. So did someone else.
I'm still bemused why I thought more people voted Ank then switched. I'll go see if I can find all the unvotes.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
Same post as above: better formatting:
So we have Asrrin (post 7) and crazyivan (289) outside town. Wow what has that scout been doing? Let's hope it wasn't gory or Uraj.
Oh go on then, what are you claiming?
Amusing OT; last time I saw "X could be framing Y" the person who posted it was doing the framing. (Not that I'm suggesting you are, I just thought it was funny.)
Just so you know Techno, some people in this game will NK you just for posting wall of texts.
As for yesterday - well I still think Ankeli is mafia and the fake doc claim left him free to do something nasty last night.
I have no real idea if Noodle is mafia or not. Mainly because I have a hard time taking monkey-boy seriously anyway.
I can't comment on how others usually play as I rarely join these things.
Sigh. Another role claim?
As for Val's post in 308. Oh good grief, the only saving grace is that it didn't contain algebra. How did you work out everyone's roles on day one? Seance with Uraj?
What is it with % crap - is it code between Valhauros, Asrrin, Krazeyivan, Bad Ash, Sathoris and Z_Y.
Ankeli explicitly calls Doc role. Yawn.
That's "deduce". "Deduct" means reduce.
You're not posting much Z_Y but you've made a couple of sensible posts.
Pfft. If you're going to take not reading the rules as a mafia tell then lynch me now because I've said at least twice I haven't really read them. So did someone else.
I'm still bemused why I thought more people voted Ank then switched. I'll go see if I can find all the unvotes.
Same post as above: better formatting:
So we have Asrrin (post 7) and crazyivan (289) outside town. Wow what has that scout been doing? Let's hope it wasn't gory or Uraj.
Oh go on then, what are you claiming?
Amusing OT; last time I saw "X could be framing Y" the person who posted it was doing the framing. (Not that I'm suggesting you are, I just thought it was funny.)
Just so you know Techno, some people in this game will NK you just for posting wall of texts.
As for yesterday - well I still think Ankeli is mafia and the fake doc claim left him free to do something nasty last night.
I have no real idea if Noodle is mafia or not. Mainly because I have a hard time taking monkey-boy seriously anyway.
I can't comment on how others usually play as I rarely join these things.
Sigh. Another role claim?
As for Val's post in 308. Oh good grief, the only saving grace is that it didn't contain algebra. How did you work out everyone's roles on day one? Seance with Uraj?
What is it with % crap - is it code between Valhauros, Asrrin, Krazeyivan, Bad Ash, Sathoris and Z_Y.
Ankeli explicitly calls Doc role. Yawn.
That's "deduce". "Deduct" means reduce.
You're not posting much Z_Y but you've made a couple of sensible posts.
Pfft. If you're going to take not reading the rules as a mafia tell then lynch me now because I've said at least twice I haven't really read them. So did someone else.
I'm still bemused why I thought more people voted Ank then switched. I'll go see if I can find all the unvotes.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
If there are 3 players of each basic role, then there are 15, add up the 4 mafia, a special role, plus 5-6 civilians, it's 25 or 26 individuals... but you forgot the game started with only 22 players.
I'm pretty sure I caught his role claim before you did, as a matter of fact, he made the claims more than once, and I know for a fact his role literally changed between day one and two. I had taken those into account when making my role list and coming to the conclusion Sathoris is a Mafia goon, as well as Nurman, Zhao and Trionth.
I read the entire thread several times, used a table of possible distribution (how many players per role), tried to find every claim in the thread, both by direct statement and by the content of particular comments, and started ruling out which players didn't seem to fit into one or another role. If it seems I'll get lynched, I'll post my findings.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
Just as an FYI, I sat here for the past hour and watched who was viewing the community forums. Laarz, Noodle, and Val were all here for most of an hour (and Laarz and val are still here) and haven't posted anything here. You'd figure Val would have something to say in his defense, unless he knows that he's scum and opening his mouth will just incriminate his scumbuddies more. And Laarz hasn't posted since yesterday, and is (still) suspiciously quiet.
Just as an FYI, I sat here for the past hour and watched who was viewing the community forums. Laarz, Noodle, and Val were all here for most of an hour (and Laarz and val are still here) and haven't posted anything here. You'd figure Val would have something to say in his defense, unless he knows that he's scum and opening his mouth will just incriminate his scumbuddies more. And Laarz hasn't posted since yesterday, and is (still) suspiciously quiet.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
Asrrin, I log on when I get to work, and keep it up pretty much all day. Much of the time it's minimized while I'm doing actual work. When it's up, I'm not necessarily viewing this thread. There are constantly spambots to research and ban, the newcomer forum to keep an eye on, etc.
Asrrin, I log on when I get to work, and keep it up pretty much all day. Much of the time it's minimized while I'm doing actual work. When it's up, I'm not necessarily viewing this thread. There are constantly spambots to research and ban, the newcomer forum to keep an eye on, etc.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
I was re-reading the entire thread, to correct my super noobish role list and as you can see I made a post, to which I'll add I also know (or believe) what your role is and whether you are stranded in the city or residing as a citizen in the house. I also thought Laarz might be from the Mafia, but I don't have enough evidence to be sure... he could be a stranded civilian too.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
I figured as much, which is why I only mentioned you were on, not asking for a reason you didn't post.
Val posted right before I did, but unless he has an extremely convincing roleclaim I still see absolutely no way he's not scum. Please Val, enlighten me.
I figured as much, which is why I only mentioned you were on, not asking for a reason you didn't post.
Val posted right before I did, but unless he has an extremely convincing roleclaim I still see absolutely no way he's not scum. Please Val, enlighten me.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
It's over boys. Val has fingered us and found out everybody's role.
I'm just coming back here because I love this post and I want to follow your train of thought. You start by throwing out a wild guess on which you base your 68% (lol) accurasy of everybody's role, including through deduction that I'm left as a mafia goon.
It's not too hard to figure out who's stranded and who could already be in the town. Yet you are special and can even find out the players assigned to six of those roles. Yet you found out my allignement by ruling out the other citizens and civilians, so you know who they are too? Since I'm not one of them you say.
Then you decide to claim your town role (still waiting on that role btw) because you just learned the fundamental basics of the mafiagame?
It's over boys. Val has fingered us and found out everybody's role.
I'm just coming back here because I love this post and I want to follow your train of thought. You start by throwing out a wild guess on which you base your 68% (lol) accurasy of everybody's role, including through deduction that I'm left as a mafia goon.
It's not too hard to figure out who's stranded and who could already be in the town. Yet you are special and can even find out the players assigned to six of those roles. Yet you found out my allignement by ruling out the other citizens and civilians, so you know who they are too? Since I'm not one of them you say.
Then you decide to claim your town role (still waiting on that role btw) because you just learned the fundamental basics of the mafiagame?
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
I agree, Valhauros is claiming knowledge that he either can't realistically have, or if he has is outing himself as an absurdly overpowered pro-town role. Much as I would like the latter to be true, I can't believe TC would include such a role in his game.
Vote: Valhauros
I agree, Valhauros is claiming knowledge that he either can't realistically have, or if he has is outing himself as an absurdly overpowered pro-town role. Much as I would like the latter to be true, I can't believe TC would include such a role in his game.
Vote: Valhauros
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
Night action would suggest he's either mafia or he's a townie inside the fort. Unless he's the mafia hitman, wouldn't a more experienced mafia member be sending in the night actions to avoid gaming faux pas? But that would be assumming the mafia don't have additional power roles.
Val mentioning that he knows a couple of roles, I was thinking that it's possible that the townies inside the fort may form a type of mason group? Or would that be too unbalanced for the town?
Night action would suggest he's either mafia or he's a townie inside the fort. Unless he's the mafia hitman, wouldn't a more experienced mafia member be sending in the night actions to avoid gaming faux pas? But that would be assumming the mafia don't have additional power roles.
Val mentioning that he knows a couple of roles, I was thinking that it's possible that the townies inside the fort may form a type of mason group? Or would that be too unbalanced for the town?
I_Told_You
New member
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
I think we are barking up the wrong tree with Val.
His theories over who is or is not mafia may not be correct, but the fact he let slip he had a role which required PMing TC on Day 1 makes it more than possible he has a town power role.
I think we are barking up the wrong tree with Val.
His theories over who is or is not mafia may not be correct, but the fact he let slip he had a role which required PMing TC on Day 1 makes it more than possible he has a town power role.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
Yes, based on his night action claim, he's either scum or in the safe zone. However I systematically debunked each role inside the fort that he could be. Therefore, he has a night action, and he's not inside the fort. ergo, scum!
I also had a suspicion about a possible mason group, but I kept it to myself to not let any mafia on to that fact, if true. Again, if there is a mason group, Val is certainly NOT in it because he botched the role abilities in the post I quoted when I outed him.
Yes, based on his night action claim, he's either scum or in the safe zone. However I systematically debunked each role inside the fort that he could be. Therefore, he has a night action, and he's not inside the fort. ergo, scum!
I also had a suspicion about a possible mason group, but I kept it to myself to not let any mafia on to that fact, if true. Again, if there is a mason group, Val is certainly NOT in it because he botched the role abilities in the post I quoted when I outed him.
I_Told_You
New member
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
This requires the mafia to have additional power roles above and beyond the night kill. So do you think this game has a very powerful mafia then. The town is after all facing NK's and game dynamics which penalize them aswell.
If his action was the night kill he would surely be fully aware that it had suceeded.
This requires the mafia to have additional power roles above and beyond the night kill. So do you think this game has a very powerful mafia then. The town is after all facing NK's and game dynamics which penalize them aswell.
If his action was the night kill he would surely be fully aware that it had suceeded.
Re: Zombie invasion Mafia game.
Ok, let me make it as clear as possible. This is one of Val's posts:
As of right now, there are only 4 town power roles that can be used, because only 4 roles are present inside the fort. No power role outside the town can use it's ability until they reach safety.
He can't be the engineer, he's dead.
He can't be the soldier, I've accounted for all the soldiers.
He can't be the scout, or the scavenger because he thinks that both of these roles could have a chance to find things other than people and food respectively.
I know that at least 3 town power roles know the correct actions for scouts and/or scavengers. I am taking a small leap of logic to conclude that the last power role that he could possibly be (the scientist) would have enough information in their PM to know the actions of one of the other power roles. He is able to research that boosts everyone's stats, so he should actually know more about other people's roles than anyone else in the game. For instance, I do NOT know what kind of role PM the engineers have, but for this current debate, that's a moot point.
So, he has a night action, and can't be inside the town. He's Scum! and if I have to make this any more clear than it already is, I might as well roleclaim /eyeroll.
Ok, let me make it as clear as possible. This is one of Val's posts:
As of right now, there are only 4 town power roles that can be used, because only 4 roles are present inside the fort. No power role outside the town can use it's ability until they reach safety.
He can't be the engineer, he's dead.
He can't be the soldier, I've accounted for all the soldiers.
He can't be the scout, or the scavenger because he thinks that both of these roles could have a chance to find things other than people and food respectively.
I know that at least 3 town power roles know the correct actions for scouts and/or scavengers. I am taking a small leap of logic to conclude that the last power role that he could possibly be (the scientist) would have enough information in their PM to know the actions of one of the other power roles. He is able to research that boosts everyone's stats, so he should actually know more about other people's roles than anyone else in the game. For instance, I do NOT know what kind of role PM the engineers have, but for this current debate, that's a moot point.
So, he has a night action, and can't be inside the town. He's Scum! and if I have to make this any more clear than it already is, I might as well roleclaim /eyeroll.
- Status
