Well It is still a zealot guide,this way people can see that they can even pvp with this build (not mine,fanatic zealots in general).
Anyway the case with your setup is obviously the weapon If you ask me. Very nice damage but the lack of ias limits you very much. Ber ber coa and 15/40 verdungos that usually take care of the damage reduction part is not an option here if you want to keep angelics on. The offensive skiller way on the other hand means you 'll have to sacrifice ar/life charms as you already know. But I bet you want to use that beauty for weapon, so to keep the discussion going,I can think of this:
20ias gloves (something like magnus yes)
30/ed Coa 15% dr
25%dr/cham levi
ber Hoz/ber Alma negra, depends whether you want damage/ar or resists.
Nosferatu belt. Ok it has slow,some leagues rule it out but it allows you to hit max speed once more,have cbf and keep your damage reduction at 48%.
In the same fashion,you can use: 30/ed coa + stormshield for max damage reduction, 20 ias gloves+nosferatu for max speed and something like Chamed eth Steel Carapace for armor. Or cham the stormshield and use a glitched prudence with high defense ,or eth zod valor, or fortitude etc. You'll make up for the loss of defense from non eth shield by getting massive defense from armor.
What do you think?