OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
- Thread starter muzzz
- Start date
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
Vote Naz
As far as I'm concerned you can't post "I'll leave it open for a variable amount of time and then say "end of voting NOW". You should take votes up until 18 hours, give a better warning or take votes from when it finished yesterday.
And you posted that an hour ago.
Vote Naz
As far as I'm concerned you can't post "I'll leave it open for a variable amount of time and then say "end of voting NOW". You should take votes up until 18 hours, give a better warning or take votes from when it finished yesterday.
And you posted that an hour ago.
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
Things were a little hectic when I approached. Goltar and Naz stood in front of a small crowd, looking a little sheepish. Which wasn't surprising, as the rest of the town was fighting over which one of them would die. Naz was the first to spot me.
"I thought we agreed Goltar had to go", he said immediately. "But now they're talking about lynching me!"
At that, Merlin turned his head.
"Actually, we can't decide."
"But Goltar was your first choice?"
Merlin nodded.
"Then he goes."
A minute later, the town had gathered around Goltar. I was waiting for the family to calm down a bit, but he spoke before I could.
"You know I'm the last of them, right?"
"I guessed as much."
"Feel good?"
"Not particularly."
"There'll be others someday."
I shrugged, and looked at the faces around us.
"Your little play for power has taught them a good lesson, I'd wager."
When I asked for a weapon, someone immediately tapped on my shoulder. I turned around and was offered a mug. After blinking a few times, it was still there. So I shrugged, and accepted the mug, and went to bring an end to this ordeal.
Goltar has been lynched. He was a member of the rival mafia. With his death, the game ends in a victory for the family.
Yes, that's you townies. Congratulations! :grin:
I was going to post a whole deal of reflection here, but my connection is a bit flaky at the moment. And I'm sensing a little impatience here. So I'll leave that stuff for another time.
All in all, I quite enjoyed this. There were very few unpleasantries, and a fair amount of behind-the-scenes highlights. Liquid deserves special mention for making me spill the most espresso. :thumbsup:
Thank you all for playing. It's been a privilige to be your host. :wave:
Things were a little hectic when I approached. Goltar and Naz stood in front of a small crowd, looking a little sheepish. Which wasn't surprising, as the rest of the town was fighting over which one of them would die. Naz was the first to spot me.
"I thought we agreed Goltar had to go", he said immediately. "But now they're talking about lynching me!"
At that, Merlin turned his head.
"Actually, we can't decide."
"But Goltar was your first choice?"
Merlin nodded.
"Then he goes."
A minute later, the town had gathered around Goltar. I was waiting for the family to calm down a bit, but he spoke before I could.
"You know I'm the last of them, right?"
"I guessed as much."
"Feel good?"
"Not particularly."
"There'll be others someday."
I shrugged, and looked at the faces around us.
"Your little play for power has taught them a good lesson, I'd wager."
When I asked for a weapon, someone immediately tapped on my shoulder. I turned around and was offered a mug. After blinking a few times, it was still there. So I shrugged, and accepted the mug, and went to bring an end to this ordeal.
Code:
Vote # Voter Prev votee votee
1 FriedBananaz Bob
2 Maatiarna Bob
3 Bob Naz
4 Maatiarna Bob
5 Serdash Thyiad
6 Jason Thyiad
7 Thyiad Thyiad
8 Merlin Thyiad
9 Merlin Thyiad Goltar
10 Jason Thyiad Goltar
11 Thyiad Thyiad Goltar
12 FriedBananaz Bob Goltar
13 Naz Goltar
14 PureSummon Goltar
15 Jason Goltar
16 Thyiad Goltar PureSummon
17 Maatiarna Naz
18 FriedBananaz Goltar Naz
19 Maatiarna Naz Goltar
20 Thyiad PureSummon
21 Thyiad Goltar
22 Bob Naz Goltar
23 Goltar Naz
24 Jason Naz
25 Thyiad Goltar Naz
26 PureSummon Goltar Naz
27 Thyiad Naz
Goltar 4 (first to reach this amount of votes)
Naz 4
Thyiad 1
Not voting:
ThyiadGoltar has been lynched. He was a member of the rival mafia. With his death, the game ends in a victory for the family.
Yes, that's you townies. Congratulations! :grin:
Code:
Lister Rival mafia
Magicboy Rival mafia
NacRuno Rival mafia
Goltar Rival mafia
Lukin Cops
SiTro Cops
Aman Cops
Bob Doc
Merlin Snoop
Ray GoonI was going to post a whole deal of reflection here, but my connection is a bit flaky at the moment. And I'm sensing a little impatience here. So I'll leave that stuff for another time.
All in all, I quite enjoyed this. There were very few unpleasantries, and a fair amount of behind-the-scenes highlights. Liquid deserves special mention for making me spill the most espresso. :thumbsup:
Thank you all for playing. It's been a privilige to be your host. :wave:
Merlin The Wizzard
New member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
It was fun, Muzzz! :grin:
Actually, I can't believe the other townies didn't figure it out yesterday... I was almost completely convinced that Goltar was the last baddie when you said that you couldn't wrap the day up yesterday and extended it for a longer time.
You professed lack of time to make a decent post before, but always managed to make a vote tally and final lynch anyways
But men, we were lucky. That drinking ability could seriously backfire, if they spotted me earlier instead of the bad guys... There was no way I could have defended myself when people like liquid and Sint had me pegged as suspicious
So goltar... WERE you turned on day 3?
It was fun, Muzzz! :grin:
Actually, I can't believe the other townies didn't figure it out yesterday... I was almost completely convinced that Goltar was the last baddie when you said that you couldn't wrap the day up yesterday and extended it for a longer time.
You professed lack of time to make a decent post before, but always managed to make a vote tally and final lynch anyways
But men, we were lucky. That drinking ability could seriously backfire, if they spotted me earlier instead of the bad guys... There was no way I could have defended myself when people like liquid and Sint had me pegged as suspicious
So goltar... WERE you turned on day 3?
Sint Nikolaas
New member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
hehe agressive posting ftw.. *high fives LE*
gg guys, we were lucky indeed as merlin said about the drinking procedures, however I also think we had an edge. With all the claiming and stuff it would be easier to figure stuff out later in the game (like what happened to pure).
Thy, no offence, I just attacked you for information. heh.. I really wasn't sure who to lynch and I made up a scheme that involved you being mafia. I really couldn't find anyone else to go for and luckily (for you) others lynched nac. The plan was really easy though: push really hard for one person and the next day look who followed me too easily if I was wrong.
Question 1: was I attacked on night 2 when I stayed cautious?
I couldn't believe people really thought I was a bad guy btw, which bad guy would claim doc on day 1?
Anyone got the hosting list to see who's next?
muzz, nicely done hosting, I liked the setup. Gave a nice bit of twist. I think you might've given the anti-towners a bit of a one-pick though because greed and falsify were clearly the best options.
hehe agressive posting ftw.. *high fives LE*
gg guys, we were lucky indeed as merlin said about the drinking procedures, however I also think we had an edge. With all the claiming and stuff it would be easier to figure stuff out later in the game (like what happened to pure).
Thy, no offence, I just attacked you for information. heh.. I really wasn't sure who to lynch and I made up a scheme that involved you being mafia. I really couldn't find anyone else to go for and luckily (for you) others lynched nac. The plan was really easy though: push really hard for one person and the next day look who followed me too easily if I was wrong.
Question 1: was I attacked on night 2 when I stayed cautious?
I couldn't believe people really thought I was a bad guy btw, which bad guy would claim doc on day 1?
Anyone got the hosting list to see who's next?
muzz, nicely done hosting, I liked the setup. Gave a nice bit of twist. I think you might've given the anti-towners a bit of a one-pick though because greed and falsify were clearly the best options.
Ray Patean
New member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
Nice going everyone, I was surprised to see so many scum roles get taken out so quickly.
Would've been nice if I could've actually blocked someone though :wink3:
Nice going everyone, I was surprised to see so many scum roles get taken out so quickly.
Would've been nice if I could've actually blocked someone though :wink3:
Merlin The Wizzard
New member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
You blocked lukin Ray
There was only 1 NK that night, with 2 baddies out... and you and I went after the same guy
You blocked lukin Ray
There was only 1 NK that night, with 2 baddies out... and you and I went after the same guy
Nazdakka
Well-known member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
Fun game. We were lucky though, having the EotF dropping like flies at the start meant the Family was on top for the whole game.
I think nerfing the cop was a really good idea - in regular games that role is really, really powerful and can easily be the difference between winning and losing. However, I think that the drinking abilty was, in retrospect, a little too powerful - even you didn't take it to an extreme like my plan did, it still gave the town a VERY powerful trick.
@Sint: Mostly I don't think we worried too much about when falsify was used because it very quickly didn't really matter - all we really cared about was whether the Agents were definitely eiliminated.
Fun game. We were lucky though, having the EotF dropping like flies at the start meant the Family was on top for the whole game.
I think nerfing the cop was a really good idea - in regular games that role is really, really powerful and can easily be the difference between winning and losing. However, I think that the drinking abilty was, in retrospect, a little too powerful - even you didn't take it to an extreme like my plan did, it still gave the town a VERY powerful trick.
@Sint: Mostly I don't think we worried too much about when falsify was used because it very quickly didn't really matter - all we really cared about was whether the Agents were definitely eiliminated.
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
Stupid, stupid, STUPID squid. I might have been able to defend myself a bit last night and last another day, but I couldn't get on. Either way, I would have very likely died the next day.
Very good game (I FINALLY got something other than a plain townie!) and I'm probably going to take a few ideas for myself.
I was converted on night 2, that's why I was trying to defend NacRuno and Magicboy (didn't work very well though).
Crud, and I had changed my mind that night, but it was a little too late.
Well, I'm going to try posting my round later today, assuming I can actually get back on to the forums. After 15 minutes, the emoticons are STILL loading here.
Stupid, stupid, STUPID squid. I might have been able to defend myself a bit last night and last another day, but I couldn't get on. Either way, I would have very likely died the next day.
Very good game (I FINALLY got something other than a plain townie!) and I'm probably going to take a few ideas for myself.
I was converted on night 2, that's why I was trying to defend NacRuno and Magicboy (didn't work very well though).
Crud, and I had changed my mind that night, but it was a little too late.
Well, I'm going to try posting my round later today, assuming I can actually get back on to the forums. After 15 minutes, the emoticons are STILL loading here.
Jason Maher
Active member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
Sweet! Well done especially to Liquid for starting the ball rolling and Merlin for ratting out goltar. Not so well done to me who got Jaedhann lynched and nearly railroaded goltar's lynching. Also seems that not very well understood first past the post in the case of a tie rule was rather crucial in the end.
Good game all. Look forward to the next round.
And Merlin: still think I'm such a good player after that effort?
Sweet! Well done especially to Liquid for starting the ball rolling and Merlin for ratting out goltar. Not so well done to me who got Jaedhann lynched and nearly railroaded goltar's lynching. Also seems that not very well understood first past the post in the case of a tie rule was rather crucial in the end.
Good game all. Look forward to the next round.
And Merlin: still think I'm such a good player after that effort?
Sint Nikolaas
New member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
Oh and wait, goltar, this means you killed w_m? :grin:
Oh and wait, goltar, this means you killed w_m? :grin:
NacRuno
Member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
It was a pleasure watching things move in the game. I wish i went on a bit longer though =P. Good job townies...
I also would like to congratulate Liq and Merlin, both did a great job in convincing others in what they had though to be right. Merlin is the one deserving the credit more imo since he was the one who dug up facts to convince others. Of course if liq was not so persistent at the beginning he may have not get the chance but that is something else
An explanation: We have killed Sitro just because we have though he might have an important role due to player change and even if he was a plain townie, his death would be the required confusion for the town. Sorry for not giving him a chance to play though :soapbox:
Our other possible target instead of Sitro was Merlin that day :scratch:. I tried to tell my worries about him having a power role in my final speech posted by muzzz but i was out of time and couldn't emphasize on it much. At that time i was thinking Thy to be the snoop and Merlin to be the doc...
Anyways, it was great fun. I hope i can join the next round...
It was a pleasure watching things move in the game. I wish i went on a bit longer though =P. Good job townies...
I also would like to congratulate Liq and Merlin, both did a great job in convincing others in what they had though to be right. Merlin is the one deserving the credit more imo since he was the one who dug up facts to convince others. Of course if liq was not so persistent at the beginning he may have not get the chance but that is something else
An explanation: We have killed Sitro just because we have though he might have an important role due to player change and even if he was a plain townie, his death would be the required confusion for the town. Sorry for not giving him a chance to play though :soapbox:
Our other possible target instead of Sitro was Merlin that day :scratch:. I tried to tell my worries about him having a power role in my final speech posted by muzzz but i was out of time and couldn't emphasize on it much. At that time i was thinking Thy to be the snoop and Merlin to be the doc...
Anyways, it was great fun. I hope i can join the next round...
water_moon
New member
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
I think it's fitting that he got killed by the squid hehe
Yes, yes he did. So he didn't have to hide from me. What's sad is that I almost stayed catious that night, but I was afraid that if I did and we only got one kill then we wouldn't know for sure how many bad guys were left. Fat lot of good that alturism did...
I think it's fitting that he got killed by the squid hehe
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem
Thanks for the compliments, guys.
I had my fair share of LOL moments during this game, and many nights showed interesting results. Night 1 was my favorite by far, for a large part due to Liquid's reaction when I told him about Lister. Night 4 was another interesting one, with Ray, Merlin and Lukin all targeting Sint. The following night had some rather bad luck in store for Lukin, as Ray prevented him from NKing Goltar, who was busy murdering his own wife.
Bob deserves special mention for not acting 4 out of 6 nights. Would've been 5 out of 6 if I hadn't been late myself one sunday. On the other end of the spectrum, Liquid and Merlin stood out to me as two very valuable players on the side of town. And of course kudos to both Lukin and Goltar, for hanging on even though their teammates died one after the other.
Thanks for the compliments, guys.
I had my fair share of LOL moments during this game, and many nights showed interesting results. Night 1 was my favorite by far, for a large part due to Liquid's reaction when I told him about Lister. Night 4 was another interesting one, with Ray, Merlin and Lukin all targeting Sint. The following night had some rather bad luck in store for Lukin, as Ray prevented him from NKing Goltar, who was busy murdering his own wife.
Bob deserves special mention for not acting 4 out of 6 nights. Would've been 5 out of 6 if I hadn't been late myself one sunday. On the other end of the spectrum, Liquid and Merlin stood out to me as two very valuable players on the side of town. And of course kudos to both Lukin and Goltar, for hanging on even though their teammates died one after the other.
