Given we are fairly certain that Gwai is a Neuter
Lol. I am not Varys, sorry (Game of thrones reference for those who didn't catch it).
I'm putting all my faith into Gwaihir to be telling the truth, but I don't really feel safe in doing so. If he is telling the truth, and is pro-town, then I'll apologize later. Otherwise, (told you so!)
Interesting. So going for both sides here? You are putting your faith in me, but if that faith is misplaced, you are saying I told you so?
Day turn wasn't posted yesterday middayish, I was promoted yesterday and went out drinking. (which I intend to do again tonight).
Congrats!
This is a good point, but at this point we have three confirmed non-town to kill:
BA, Gwaihir, and Gory.
I don't know of any reason why we should kill anyone before those three.
Really? So if BA dies today, you think that the best idea is to lynch me? Even if it takes 3 days to do?
Pharphis:
Morder (or whatever his name is) is red. If Gwaihir is a neutral that wins with town, how can part of his wincondition be that he loses if a member of the red is alive? That makes no sense.
Beyond that, neutrals are bad for town, because a neutral win means a town loss. Based on that, I'd say we have to kill the neutral.
I am not sure everyone follows my definition, but here they are:
Town: Wins when anti-town is eliminated
anti-town: wins when other factions can not prevent them from winning
nuetral: can win with either town or anti-town factions.
From this I consider SK and cult to be anti-town, although others seem to think otherwise.
I on the other hand am neutral, with 2 conditions:
1) Mordred is dead
2) I am alive when game ends
As for why I have that win condition - probably to make my role more interesting than a normal survivor, to match book flavor (Walter dies trying to kill him in the books), and to balance the rest of the powers I have been given.
Me winning in no way prevents the town from winning. It also does not prevent a mafia win. I can win alongside either faction.