You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
City Mafia Game Thread
- Thread starter Caluin Graye
- Start date
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Hm, very interesting....
I'm not so sure the doctor claim would have worked as we would have still questioned why you protected who you did, or didn't protect for that matter. I think the main thing that really gave it away for me and made me push from then on was your reluctancy to claim and state your selected targets, and then your reasoning for choosing your targets was based on a coin toss rather then trying to save someone. Both roles would have required trying to protect someone so it probably would have fell through.
I think they did it like that to kind of reach a consenus and try to figure out who was the largest threat to them at the time based on information/pushing/roles. Not a bad idea if you think about it, but apparently still didn't work :alright:. Score one for the town.
I'm still suspect of a couple different people, but I'm sure we all are.
Also on a side note, remind me to listen to Val, he had him pegged from day 2, pretty good I must say.
Hm, very interesting....
I'm not so sure the doctor claim would have worked as we would have still questioned why you protected who you did, or didn't protect for that matter. I think the main thing that really gave it away for me and made me push from then on was your reluctancy to claim and state your selected targets, and then your reasoning for choosing your targets was based on a coin toss rather then trying to save someone. Both roles would have required trying to protect someone so it probably would have fell through.
I think they did it like that to kind of reach a consenus and try to figure out who was the largest threat to them at the time based on information/pushing/roles. Not a bad idea if you think about it, but apparently still didn't work :alright:. Score one for the town.
I'm still suspect of a couple different people, but I'm sure we all are.
Also on a side note, remind me to listen to Val, he had him pegged from day 2, pretty good I must say.
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Well, considering the trend for killing off info roles, here are my thoughts if I don't last the night:
SK: Pyro, BA, and FoE can not be it just based on claims I believe. coju and Val both claimed early, which would be a gutsy move for a SK, leaving Gambor or RE as safer bets for the SK.
mafia: Assuming we can trust flubbs claim here (somewhat doubtful, I know) there were 3 mafia last night to discuss with. If this was Laarz and Noodle, he is the last, which would be awesome. If not, it gets harder, but in either case I believe BA and pyro are town. FoE I think is also likely town, and assuming that is true:
RE: voted Laarz (on a day 1 mislynch) and Asrrin early, flubb late. Voted Ankeli
gambor: last vote on Asrrin, no other votes
coju: voted both Asrrin and flubb. Voted Ankeli and I.
Val: voted flubb 2 days. Voted Ankeli
For comparison I: voted Asrrin and flubb. Voted Ankeli and BA.
Using this I would say RE and Val are less likely to be mafia, whereas coju and Gambor are more likely.
Well, considering the trend for killing off info roles, here are my thoughts if I don't last the night:
SK: Pyro, BA, and FoE can not be it just based on claims I believe. coju and Val both claimed early, which would be a gutsy move for a SK, leaving Gambor or RE as safer bets for the SK.
mafia: Assuming we can trust flubbs claim here (somewhat doubtful, I know) there were 3 mafia last night to discuss with. If this was Laarz and Noodle, he is the last, which would be awesome. If not, it gets harder, but in either case I believe BA and pyro are town. FoE I think is also likely town, and assuming that is true:
RE: voted Laarz (on a day 1 mislynch) and Asrrin early, flubb late. Voted Ankeli
gambor: last vote on Asrrin, no other votes
coju: voted both Asrrin and flubb. Voted Ankeli and I.
Val: voted flubb 2 days. Voted Ankeli
For comparison I: voted Asrrin and flubb. Voted Ankeli and BA.
Using this I would say RE and Val are less likely to be mafia, whereas coju and Gambor are more likely.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Last thoughts, if only the SK is left, then they really don't have any reason not to follow the town on votes, most likely peg is on RE for claiming late and having a high pick, and gambor because even though he had a low pick his claim was a role that was previously confirmed (essentially).
Last thoughts, if only the SK is left, then they really don't have any reason not to follow the town on votes, most likely peg is on RE for claiming late and having a high pick, and gambor because even though he had a low pick his claim was a role that was previously confirmed (essentially).
Caluin Graye
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
View attachment 1205
(Off camera) Hey... you okay?
"Psshht.... off coursh I'm. O. KAY. Noth... nothing my good fernd Jack can't sholve. HAHA. I shaid 'fernd'."
(Off camera) You really need to lay off the bottle man. It's not professional.
"What does you know about... about... about being professhional, HUH? Who? Cares? I losht everything important to me. She's gone, and I can't ever have her back. Never!"
(Off camera) Lighten up man. She's just some two-timing floosey. You'll find someone better than you wife eventually.
"Wife? WIFE?! I ain't talkin' about her! BINKY. BINKY ISH DEAD. <hic> I miss her sho much. She was the wor... world to me. Never even got to tell her how I felt.
"AND YOU JERKS TOOK HER AWAY FROM ME."
<Jeremy throws a half empty bottle at the camera. It shatters and nothing but static remains.>
--------------
flubbucket has been lynched. He was Memphis, Tennessee. Mafia. Bus Driver.
It is now night time. You know the drill. 24 hours, please have night actions submitted by 5:00pm Pacific.
View attachment 1205
(Off camera) Hey... you okay?
"Psshht.... off coursh I'm. O. KAY. Noth... nothing my good fernd Jack can't sholve. HAHA. I shaid 'fernd'."
(Off camera) You really need to lay off the bottle man. It's not professional.
"What does you know about... about... about being professhional, HUH? Who? Cares? I losht everything important to me. She's gone, and I can't ever have her back. Never!"
(Off camera) Lighten up man. She's just some two-timing floosey. You'll find someone better than you wife eventually.
"Wife? WIFE?! I ain't talkin' about her! BINKY. BINKY ISH DEAD. <hic> I miss her sho much. She was the wor... world to me. Never even got to tell her how I felt.
"AND YOU JERKS TOOK HER AWAY FROM ME."
<Jeremy throws a half empty bottle at the camera. It shatters and nothing but static remains.>
--------------
flubbucket has been lynched. He was Memphis, Tennessee. Mafia. Bus Driver.
It is now night time. You know the drill. 24 hours, please have night actions submitted by 5:00pm Pacific.
Caluin Graye
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
View attachment 1208 View attachment 1209
<Jeremy has his on the desk and is singing softly to himself. He is obviously quite hung over and not feeling well at all. Next to him is a new face, someone far too chipper and cheery>
Betty:
"Hi! My name is Betty Lisa-Ida-Swarn Samuels. Jeremy isn't feeling too well, the poor thing, so I'm filling in for him today! The poor thing!"
Jeremy:
"I could have been a baseball star, but I wound up here... just have to look good, don't need to be clear..."
Betty:
I'm not very good at this, but I'm going to give it my best. Let's see... top news today, Boston has been destroyed. Oh dear! I visited there once. It was very noisy, but the beer was great! Isn't that where the Cheers bar is? Gee, I don't remember!
Jeremy:
"Bubble-headed bleach blonde who comes on at five... she'll tell you about city bombings with a gleam in her eye...."
Betty:
"Silly goose! We're on at six!"
Jeremy:
"Six doesn't rhyme. And stop yelling. Nobody should be this loud at six in the evening. Anybody have a drink?"
Betty:
"We'll be back soon. In the mean time, I'm going to see about getting Jeremy sober and happy again! Stay tuned everyone!"
Jeremy:
"We all know crap is king... give us dirty laundry..."
-----------------
It is now 'day time'.
Bad Ash has been killed! He was Boston, Massachusetts.
Day is scheduled to end on Monday at 6:00pm. With 7 alive, it's 4 votes to lynch.
View attachment 1208 View attachment 1209
<Jeremy has his on the desk and is singing softly to himself. He is obviously quite hung over and not feeling well at all. Next to him is a new face, someone far too chipper and cheery>
Betty:
"Hi! My name is Betty Lisa-Ida-Swarn Samuels. Jeremy isn't feeling too well, the poor thing, so I'm filling in for him today! The poor thing!"
Jeremy:
"I could have been a baseball star, but I wound up here... just have to look good, don't need to be clear..."
Betty:
I'm not very good at this, but I'm going to give it my best. Let's see... top news today, Boston has been destroyed. Oh dear! I visited there once. It was very noisy, but the beer was great! Isn't that where the Cheers bar is? Gee, I don't remember!
Jeremy:
"Bubble-headed bleach blonde who comes on at five... she'll tell you about city bombings with a gleam in her eye...."
Betty:
"Silly goose! We're on at six!"
Jeremy:
"Six doesn't rhyme. And stop yelling. Nobody should be this loud at six in the evening. Anybody have a drink?"
Betty:
"We'll be back soon. In the mean time, I'm going to see about getting Jeremy sober and happy again! Stay tuned everyone!"
Jeremy:
"We all know crap is king... give us dirty laundry..."
-----------------
It is now 'day time'.
Bad Ash has been killed! He was Boston, Massachusetts.
Day is scheduled to end on Monday at 6:00pm. With 7 alive, it's 4 votes to lynch.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
He said he was immune and I knew he was bluffing when he said it but didn't call him on it because obviously it would stop a night kill which is obviously a good thing. The only thing is if the SK was keeping track of the cycle it was an easy one to catch.
He said he was immune and I knew he was bluffing when he said it but didn't call him on it because obviously it would stop a night kill which is obviously a good thing. The only thing is if the SK was keeping track of the cycle it was an easy one to catch.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Also, my last post of the previous day phase was regarding gambor claiming to be vanilla after trying to get role cop, not that he claimed to have an already confirmed role. Obviously I was running out of time when I was typing that so was kind of in a rush. Either way hes still on my suspect list.
Also, my last post of the previous day phase was regarding gambor claiming to be vanilla after trying to get role cop, not that he claimed to have an already confirmed role. Obviously I was running out of time when I was typing that so was kind of in a rush. Either way hes still on my suspect list.
FredOfErik
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
First of all, I'm drunk posting. Sorry for that. :crazyeyes:
Well, speaking of WIFOA..
One kill indicates, that flubb was the last mafia member, or?
I was sure BA was the hider role tonight? Since he was killed, he apparently was lying (again, alternatives?).
If he was lying about that, I'll assume he was mafia. Gwaihir will clear this up by tomorrow.
What's really interesting IMO - the thing that confirmed Pyro's claim was BA. If BA was lying, where does this leave Pyro?
I'm not in condition to figure this out atm. I will check the thread asap tommorrow.
Gwaihir: Laarz was Ninja, mafia.
First of all, I'm drunk posting. Sorry for that. :crazyeyes:
Well, speaking of WIFOA..
One kill indicates, that flubb was the last mafia member, or?
I was sure BA was the hider role tonight? Since he was killed, he apparently was lying (again, alternatives?).
If he was lying about that, I'll assume he was mafia. Gwaihir will clear this up by tomorrow.
What's really interesting IMO - the thing that confirmed Pyro's claim was BA. If BA was lying, where does this leave Pyro?
I'm not in condition to figure this out atm. I will check the thread asap tommorrow.
Gwaihir: Laarz was Ninja, mafia.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Even though your drunk posting, I'll try to clear it up for you. Hider role was immune to all night actions every other night.
So
Night 1: I was immune
Night 2: I was not immune, BA stole my role
Night 3: BA was immune
Night 4: BA not immune. (Last night)
The SK most likely followed this timeline and took him out on the night he was vulnerable, and the first people to target would be solidly confirmed towns as they are very unlikely to be lynched and taking out someone uncertain would draw more attention to them during the day as there would be less people to suspect.
Other alternatives, BA was not the one that stole my role and therefore was never immune (possible but would mean that both TC and BA were lying which makes it near impossible, and wouldn't matter anyway due to the timeline above)
From flubbs last post it made it seem like he was the last mafia, and as far as we are aware, we have no one with an ability to avoid being night killed except the SK.
I will await further pushing on FoE until Gwaihir's post as that could prove or disprove a lot (maybe...).
Even though your drunk posting, I'll try to clear it up for you. Hider role was immune to all night actions every other night.
So
Night 1: I was immune
Night 2: I was not immune, BA stole my role
Night 3: BA was immune
Night 4: BA not immune. (Last night)
The SK most likely followed this timeline and took him out on the night he was vulnerable, and the first people to target would be solidly confirmed towns as they are very unlikely to be lynched and taking out someone uncertain would draw more attention to them during the day as there would be less people to suspect.
Other alternatives, BA was not the one that stole my role and therefore was never immune (possible but would mean that both TC and BA were lying which makes it near impossible, and wouldn't matter anyway due to the timeline above)
From flubbs last post it made it seem like he was the last mafia, and as far as we are aware, we have no one with an ability to avoid being night killed except the SK.
I will await further pushing on FoE until Gwaihir's post as that could prove or disprove a lot (maybe...).
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
You realize, of course, that if I wanted to lie about what role I went for, it would be impossible for anybody to counter-claim me. Since the way one would be caught there would be if someone lower in the order ended up with the claimed role. As such, a previously confirmed role wouldn't be of much value to me if I wanted to hide the role I went for. If we want to get all WIFOM about my claim I could point out that I claimed vanilla before it was established that there wasn't a watcher. I don't know what else to tell you, I asked for rolecop and it was taken.
One nk could be no scum left, or both sk and scum going after the same target.
Also, my last post of the previous day phase was regarding gambor claiming to be vanilla after trying to get role cop, not that he claimed to have an already confirmed role.
You realize, of course, that if I wanted to lie about what role I went for, it would be impossible for anybody to counter-claim me. Since the way one would be caught there would be if someone lower in the order ended up with the claimed role. As such, a previously confirmed role wouldn't be of much value to me if I wanted to hide the role I went for. If we want to get all WIFOM about my claim I could point out that I claimed vanilla before it was established that there wasn't a watcher. I don't know what else to tell you, I asked for rolecop and it was taken.
One nk could be no scum left, or both sk and scum going after the same target.
FredOfErik
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Oh.. I just remember BA saying that he would be immune yesterday. I get why he would say that, though - he fooled me, an could've possibly fooled the SK aswell (which he obviously didn't, but you get my point).
Even though your drunk posting, I'll try to clear it up for you. Hider role was immune to all night actions every other night.
So
Night 1: I was immune
Night 2: I was not immune, BA stole my role
Night 3: BA was immune
Night 4: BA not immune. (Last night)
The SK most likely followed this timeline and took him out on the night he was vulnerable, and the first people to target would be solidly confirmed towns as they are very unlikely to be lynched and taking out someone uncertain would draw more attention to them during the day as there would be less people to suspect.
Other alternatives, BA was not the one that stole my role and therefore was never immune (possible but would mean that both TC and BA were lying which makes it near impossible, and wouldn't matter anyway due to the timeline above)
From flubbs last post it made it seem like he was the last mafia, and as far as we are aware, we have no one with an ability to avoid being night killed except the SK.
I will await further pushing on FoE until Gwaihir's post as that could prove or disprove a lot (maybe...).
Oh.. I just remember BA saying that he would be immune yesterday. I get why he would say that, though - he fooled me, an could've possibly fooled the SK aswell (which he obviously didn't, but you get my point).
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Interesting. I got a slightly different result: role thief, mafia. I highly doubt Pyro and BA were lying, Pyro's explanation makes the most sense, that BA tried to bluff the killers. I also don't actually think you are lying - my bet is the difference comes from the fact you and Pyro acted at the same time and I acted a night later for roles.
I stand by my post from yesterday - Pyro and FoE can not be the SK based on claims I believe. coju and Val both claimed early, which would be a gutsy move for a SK, leaving Gambor or RE as the ones most likely to be a SK. Unfortunately voting history tells us nothing, it will be very hard to tell who the SK is.
I was sure BA was the hider role tonight? Since he was killed, he apparently was lying (again, alternatives?).
If he was lying about that, I'll assume he was mafia. Gwaihir will clear this up by tomorrow.
What's really interesting IMO - the thing that confirmed Pyro's claim was BA. If BA was lying, where does this leave Pyro?
I'm not in condition to figure this out atm. I will check the thread asap tommorrow.
Gwaihir: Laarz was Ninja, mafia.
Interesting. I got a slightly different result: role thief, mafia. I highly doubt Pyro and BA were lying, Pyro's explanation makes the most sense, that BA tried to bluff the killers. I also don't actually think you are lying - my bet is the difference comes from the fact you and Pyro acted at the same time and I acted a night later for roles.
I stand by my post from yesterday - Pyro and FoE can not be the SK based on claims I believe. coju and Val both claimed early, which would be a gutsy move for a SK, leaving Gambor or RE as the ones most likely to be a SK. Unfortunately voting history tells us nothing, it will be very hard to tell who the SK is.
Pyrotechnician1
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
It is impossible for anyone to counter-claim you which makes it all the more difficult, it was just one of those points of if its too convenient it probably is, all speculation of course.
I agree with the same target thing being possible but were up to 4 confirmed mafia with Gwaihir's confirmation, do you think its possible to have 5 and a SK? Seems like an awful lot.
Yeah he did, and it was a nice try, however unfortunately it obviously didn't work.
Your find would make sense, after I used my role thief on Laarz, he would then become the role thief. The important find is that his alignment is in fact mafia which confirms FoE's claim, and unless you and him are working together for some reason (would make no sense in the scheme of things) I think that makes him in the clear for the time being.
You realize, of course, that if I wanted to lie about what role I went for, it would be impossible for anybody to counter-claim me. Since the way one would be caught there would be if someone lower in the order ended up with the claimed role. As such, a previously confirmed role wouldn't be of much value to me if I wanted to hide the role I went for. If we want to get all WIFOM about my claim I could point out that I claimed vanilla before it was established that there wasn't a watcher. I don't know what else to tell you, I asked for rolecop and it was taken.
One nk could be no scum left, or both sk and scum going after the same target.
It is impossible for anyone to counter-claim you which makes it all the more difficult, it was just one of those points of if its too convenient it probably is, all speculation of course.
I agree with the same target thing being possible but were up to 4 confirmed mafia with Gwaihir's confirmation, do you think its possible to have 5 and a SK? Seems like an awful lot.
Oh.. I just remember BA saying that he would be immune yesterday. I get why he would say that, though - he fooled me, an could've possibly fooled the SK aswell (which he obviously didn't, but you get my point).
Yeah he did, and it was a nice try, however unfortunately it obviously didn't work.
Interesting. I got a slightly different result: role thief, mafia. I highly doubt Pyro and BA were lying, Pyro's explanation makes the most sense, that BA tried to bluff the killers. I also don't actually think you are lying - my bet is the difference comes from the fact you and Pyro acted at the same time and I acted a night later for roles.
I stand by my post from yesterday - Pyro and FoE can not be the SK based on claims I believe. coju and Val both claimed early, which would be a gutsy move for a SK, leaving Gambor or RE as the ones most likely to be a SK. Unfortunately voting history tells us nothing, it will be very hard to tell who the SK is.
Your find would make sense, after I used my role thief on Laarz, he would then become the role thief. The important find is that his alignment is in fact mafia which confirms FoE's claim, and unless you and him are working together for some reason (would make no sense in the scheme of things) I think that makes him in the clear for the time being.
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Welp, if we are down to just the sk, we have 2 mislynches before lylo. I'm not thrilled about it, but there is the lynch one of us today the other tomorrow plan. The downside of that being that if there is a scum left then tomorrow is most likely town choosing which anti-town wins.
Welp, if we are down to just the sk, we have 2 mislynches before lylo. I'm not thrilled about it, but there is the lynch one of us today the other tomorrow plan. The downside of that being that if there is a scum left then tomorrow is most likely town choosing which anti-town wins.
FredOfErik
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
I totally missed this. Sorry, and this pretty much leaves my last post irrelevant.
I'm going to sleep now, see you in the morning1
He said he was immune and I knew he was bluffing when he said it but didn't call him on it because obviously it would stop a night kill which is obviously a good thing. The only thing is if the SK was keeping track of the cycle it was an easy one to catch.
I totally missed this. Sorry, and this pretty much leaves my last post irrelevant.
I'm going to sleep now, see you in the morning1
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Well, the point I was trying to make is that it isn't particularly convenient.
I had assumed 5 scum from the beginning, I even mentioned that briefly yesterday.
It is impossible for anyone to counter-claim you which makes it all the more difficult, it was just one of those points of if its too convenient it probably is, all speculation of course.
Well, the point I was trying to make is that it isn't particularly convenient.
I agree with the same target thing being possible but were up to 4 confirmed mafia with Gwaihir's confirmation, do you think its possible to have 5 and a SK? Seems like an awful lot.
I had assumed 5 scum from the beginning, I even mentioned that briefly yesterday.
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
I just realized I made an assumption here that I didn't put in the post. This is assuming I go first. I actually do think RE is most likely the SK.
The downside of that being that if there is a scum left then tomorrow is most likely town choosing which anti-town wins.
I just realized I made an assumption here that I didn't put in the post. This is assuming I go first. I actually do think RE is most likely the SK.
FredOfErik
New member
Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Oh, when reading my last post, I realize I actually didn't miss it.
And yes, I promise I'll go to sleep now :balloons:
Oh, when reading my last post, I realize I actually didn't miss it.
And yes, I promise I'll go to sleep now :balloons:
