City Mafia Game Thread

Re: City Mafia Game Thread

Pyrotechnician said:
Right now, I think I rather see flubb hang rather than FOE. I see it this way...if and by if I mean IF everyone was truthful about their roleclaims then that means we have a SK and a roleblocker/jailkeeper unaccounted for (assuming TC was actually blocked). Only two people have yet to claim, Gwaihir and Flubb. Flubb has been inconsistent throughout the game and it seems he only voted for Asriin when he was pushed into it. Gwaihir hasn't really given us anything to suspect of as of yet except for not wanting to claim. FOE (or whoever actually was the Vig) if he is anti-town has obviously already used his one shot so we don't have to be worried about that now. I see the most likely scenario being:

Flubb - Roleblocker/Jailkeeper Mafia
Gwaihir - SK

(This scenario is still iffy because any of the other unconfirmed claims or vanilla claims could actually be interchanged into this)

I'm of course going to wait to see how FOE defends himself before making a vote because that could definately sway my thought process.
Click to expand...

the SK could easily be hiding behind any role they killed (I.E. say..the vigilante, lines up if someone tracked them last night too cause they got a kill as the SK)

I am fine with flub. Honestly I am not confident about FOE but the coincidences I do not like as its usually a lie. Plus it will prove a lot about you as well stealing Laarz' role possibly.

@FOE I understand RL got in the way, it gets in the way for everyone from time to time. It still doesn't change the fact that you voted for a townie death and didn't vote for a mafia death. People can lie, or even be telling the truth. Being busy in RL doesn't mean you are pro-town, or anyone else for that matter. I think you are anti-town based on what I have read and how the game has played out. Am I 100% sure? No, but it's a read I have and I would like others opinions on it.

Gwahir and Gambor have both been a little off as well, but I dont feel as strongly about it as I do FoE



 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

Last post before I go to bed, but I will be on in the morning..

Bad Ash said:
It still doesn't change the fact that you voted for a townie death and didn't vote for a mafia death.
Click to expand...

But I had no oppurtunity to vote for the mafia death. That's the whole point. And it's fair game you have a scum read on my, I would just appreciate that my RL business (which was warned and afterwards explained) will no longer be used an argument against me.

@me lying: also didn't everyon (including) jump up about people wanting to pick ninja in the beginning of the game? And now you don't believe me when I tell you the ninja was mafia. I get that Pyro already told it in the thread and that's quite unfortunate for me. But the game days start/end at 3. am my time, so I can never be around for day end/start. Not much to do about that.

@SK: wouldn't it be more beneficial to aim for lynching the SK than mafia? This would stop one NK right away. If not, anybody care to explain why?

I'm now going to sleep. Looking forward to reading up tomorrow.


 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

At Fred ab sk: i've always thought this too, but now think that "they"hope the sk will aim after Mafia, as there are fewer numbers. I reckon.
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

coju said:
At Fred ab sk: i've always thought this too, but now think that "they"hope the sk will aim after Mafia, as there are fewer numbers. I reckon.
Click to expand...

After most of the town is eliminated the SK would have to go after mafia because if two mafia and the SK remain the mafia will win since they can secure a lynch on the SK. But yes you are correct, if we can identify the SK then we should go for it, but determining who it is is fairly difficult in my opinion. Do you have any opinions on who it might be? Who do you think seems scummy/supicious coju?


 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

So Asrrin was mafia.

Noodle was mafia.

If all things are to be believe, Laarz was Mafia

Its possible TC was mafia

And you are questioning why we are going after the SK?

How many mafia do you expect this game to have? If TC was town and Laarz is mafia with a SK in play I believe we have 1 mafia left. If as some people suggest, TC was mafia, we most likely are done with them no?

I think the latest post by FoE gives us more reasons to lynch him than less.

for this mainly
@me lying: also didn't everyon (including) jump up about people wanting to pick ninja in the beginning of the game? And now you don't believe me when I tell you the ninja was mafia
Click to expand...

So you hoped people would believe you because people talked about picking the ninja role earlier in the game? We said it would be beneficial for the mafia to have it, no one knew one way or the other if they actually did
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

18 players. There is a 1% chance there are 5 mafia. if Laarz was mafia we have 1 left (if that, but most likely 1 left) and possibly the SK.

Vote stands for now.

Ryleh do you believe FoE that Laarz was mafia? Gwahir do you?
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

Pyrotechnician said:
After most of the town is eliminated the SK would have to go after mafia because if two mafia and the SK remain the mafia will win since they can secure a lynch on the SK. But yes you are correct, if we can identify the SK then we should go for it, but determining who it is is fairly difficult in my opinion. Do you have any opinions on who it might be? Who do you think seems scummy/supicious coju?
Click to expand...

I personally don't think outing the sk is the best idea. if we do, the "one"Mafia knows who to kill tonight. If that Mafia is well embedded as "town"then imo we could be on trouble.

If we keep the sk, accidently lynch a townie, we (if sk is siding with town) have an extra chance of killing a Mafia tonight.

Then, there is always yet possibility that the sk is Mafia. If that's the case, then we're doubly screwed. So, my concensious, would be to lynch the sk... But Idk..

As for who seems scummy, im always suspicious of bad ash. Just because mainly. But because of his help,I don't think he is scum


 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

In all actuality it is completely possible that BA did NOT steal my role, and it was in fact one of his mafia buddies that did and he just used the information to his advantage. But the likely hood of that is pretty slim since he pushed hard on the Asriin lynch. Nothing is ever certain.

The only thing that can kill the SK is lynching (or the bomb? Not sure on this) because the SK is bulletproof so even if the sk is outed and we don't lynch them they can't be killed over night. The SK sides with the SK and will pretty much kill in their best interest, if it means targeting town, or if it means targeting mafia it will do both.

If the SK was originally mafia, their alignment is replaced with the new "SK" alignment (their own team).
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

Coju...you are barking up the wrong tree here.

If Laarz or TC were mafia we have 1 mafia left (almost guarunteed there would not be 5 mafia and the potential for a SK in a game as previously stated..I can not believe that).

1 mafia
1 SK
7 townies

The SK doesnt know who the mafia is.

1 mafia embedded in the town is absolutely no different than 1 sk embedded in the town. both are on personal agendas, both are on their own team at this point, and both have the same reasons to kill the town.

Always lynch the scummiest person you have. Do the SK and mafia need eachother gone to win? yes, but to think they would be laser focused with 6-7 townies still alive would not be correct line of thinking, especially when the town is capable of helping them through lynches.

Coju, why did you pick Bomb as your ability?
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

plus you got bomb with the 17th pick? And you are trying to steer a lynch away from FoE as if he is the SK.

Mighta just skyrocketed to the top of my list. I'd even place the last vote on him if it came to it.

I am all over the place which isnt helping any credibility I am sure, but a lot of defenders debating SK vs Mafia. Vote still stands for now on FoE.
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

I was just throwing out opinions there to think about not trying to derail a lynch i"m all for lynching

The reason i chose bomb is: i figured those who wanted it would figure someone else got it| Try and choose a role they"ve always wanted/good at
so i chose to choose bomb <keyboard issues here sorry for the punctuation> | did this because i normally get lynched/nkd towards the beginning of the game
i figured since this happens i could take someone else out with me or be able to survive because of that possibility that they might get killed when trying to kill me
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

Bad Ash, did you have to much caffine tonight? You need to focus a bit.

I still feel strongly about flubb until he proves otherwise. If it comes down to it though and you still believe FoE is our best bet I'll support that lynch. There still hasn't been enough activity from some of the other players to gather enough information.
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

Nah just mafia. Same reason you and coju are suspicious of me. Everything makes people suspicious. Defintely not enough activity.

Did flub roleclaim? We can start throwing some votes to see if he comes out of hiding
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

Bad Ash said:
Its possible TC was mafia

And you are questioning why we are going after the SK?

How many mafia do you expect this game to have? If TC was town and Laarz is mafia with a SK in play I believe we have 1 mafia left. If as some people suggest, TC was mafia, we most likely are done with them no?
Click to expand...

No I was suggesting that we should go after the SK, as I think we have two very nice candidates in Gwaihir and RE. RE being my favorite.

I'm far from sure TC was mafia. One of the things I've been wondering about is Gwaihir's role. I can see him waiting for everybody to claim before he would come out if he is the coroner. If that's the case he could probably shine some light on it.

Bad Ash said:
I think the latest post by FoE gives us more reasons to lynch him than less.

for this mainly

So you hoped people would believe you because people talked about picking the ninja role earlier in the game? We said it would be beneficial for the mafia to have it, no one knew one way or the other if they actually did
Click to expand...

We were all pretty much (or I was in any case after pyro and coju for saying they wanted it) up in their business for choosing a role that would not be beneficial to town. Now you're not believing that said role wasn't town. Merely pointing it out. I don't see how the above quote is an argument.

coju said:
Then, there is always yet possibility that the sk is Mafia. If that's the case, then we're doubly screwed. So, my concensious, would be to lynch the sk... But Idk..
Click to expand...

Pretty sure the SK loses his original allignment.

Flubb is at L-2. I'll happily be a part of such a lynch, but I think it's too early to put him at L-1 and make it possible for somebody to lock him. I'll be around for another couple of hours and then later this afternoon. If he hasn't come forward there I'll vote for him as that will be my last time online for this day phase.

How is everybody's feelings about RE?

-he's been lurking almost the entire game
-if we were to take the theory that SK had a high/mid pick, he and Gwaihir are the only options
-he made one post this day phase - no mention of suspects, and a vague claim that can only be tested by lynching him

I'm feeling more and more confident, that he is the SK. If not, I still wouldn't rule out the possibility of him being mafia.

Rlyeh: who do you want to lynch and why?


 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

Role: bus driver, however I could just as easily have said VT and it would have proven what? Role reveal is foolish and now gives the mafia more information.
 
Re: City Mafia Game Thread

@Flub: Some targets to back that up?

@FoE: As of when I was last here, Flubb, for his refusual to role claim. I also made 2 posts so far this day phase not 1. And how is my claim vague, I gave my city and said "I am the party host", not much more to the point than that. Now flubbs roleclaimed, I'm unsure, until he answers the question put forward now, I'll hold my vote.

If you're all convinced that me or Gwahir is the SK then I'd rather have Gwahir lynched, or lynch me, my abilities useless now and when I flip PH and town you can go after the real SK, ethier way you eventually remove a killer.

At the moment I beleive BA to be town and possibly Pyro.

Ryleh do you believe FoE that Laarz was mafia? Gwahir do you?
Click to expand...

Right now yes, but maybe just for being optimistic in that we're in a good position, still don't see why anyone would use nightkill when they have day kill power myself though.

Anyway:

Vote: Gwaihir

Will be in and out all day to change if need be, just don't want Flubb quickhammered.
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top