I will again say Coju that I never said the word want. Keep spinnin it that way if you'd like.
Vote: asrrin I agree with the things that have been said regarding him
If no one could use any abilities, how WOULD he have the knowledge? You think that he would out himself and a mafia compadre not five posts into the game?
Guess it gives us a chance to lynch a townie before the actions kick in. Random votes ahoy!
I will again say Coju that I never said the word want. Keep spinnin it that way if you'd like.
Vote: asrrin I agree with the things that have been said regarding him
LOL Ya - say anything: your scum - don't say anything: your scum - say too much: your scum - say too little: your scum! I can say CG that games on this site are the only ones you get hung for contributing - or not - or for any other random thing! The "Common Scum Tactic" is so overused by all here I find it too dam funny. OH - you countered me - "That's a common scum tactic" LOL!
Also, it's a common scum tactic for scum to point out the common scum tactics of townies.
@CG: What do you think of the specific details Flip referenced? Namely: multiple possible night actions. Cultafia can choose which mode to use. Cultafia is most likely to choose. Lastly, do you still think Flip "said nothing?"
Both yes and no. I don't like that we've jumped to the conclusion of a cult without any real proof, especially when the lore states that the baddies are intentionally not recruiting and are instead killing their victims. Secondly, Flip's statement is presented with authority, as if he knows this to be fact already. Note how he says - "The KC can either". There's no 'I think' in that statement, anywhere. He then subtly suggests that we'd need to be more interested in hunting recruits than the original scum team, which leads town down a losing road.
That's what went through my head when I read Flip's post. It could have been a legitimate slip, or just a "mind to keyboard" translation error. So I decided I wanted to prod him a bit, to see what his reaction might be. It was... interesting, to say the least.
The KC's tactic in Hong Kong was to turn all into an army - they tried to do the same in the "Safe Zone" where this story is set. Does it mean that's what will happen in this game? Of course not; I'm just speculating.
Fred - Again I'm speculating but I think if I were the "bad-guys" I'd rather turn players than kill. Not that I need to say it even to you as a self proclaimed "Somewhat MAfia nub"; trust no one. Even if they seem to be pro-town at one point - they may be turned after that.
I'll post my replies to that same question (Remember, these are all within the first 20-30 posts of a day started game......)Coju seems far more suspicious than Bad Ash to me, and my propensity for trying to kill Bad Ash is well documented. Particularly his early posts, Coju seems trying to deliberately confuse us. If we lynch him, the best case scenario is that we kill a mafia, worst case scenario is we get rid of a townie who hasn't been adding anything constructive to the conversation.
Nothing personal, Coju, just found your "Re: Black Blood Brothers Mafia Thread
I didn't want to say anything, but kestegs hasn't been at our monthly meetings lately... "
and "No. kestegs, I am quite disturbed by the blood on your vest. Forget to change? "
posts to be quite distracting.
Trying to start conversation. Looks like it'd be best to watch the series.
I was simply starting conversation, as I stated in post #10
...
Fingers going crazy, eh? I've pointed at two people. Kegs, just because, Ash, because he said from post 28.
I never said you said want. I asked why we would want to... (And I did read your reply to that.)I will again say Coju that I never said the word want. Keep spinnin it that way if you'd like.
Vote: asrrin I agree with the things that have been said regarding him
I'm glad someone else picked up on this besides me.Wait, seriously? Voting for me because I decide to random vote to get some conversation started, and then almost immediately change my vote to something with a little more substance than a RNG vote? I don't like it when people "psuedo-random" vote by declaring a vote on someone for a silly reason. It seems contrived and serves only to distract people from posts of real substance. Doing a mathematically pure random vote in the first couple of posts in the game because absolutely nothing has been said is much different than that.
They would have knowledge if they were in a group together. It's a flimsy pretense to be sure, but something I picked up on because nothing else of value had been said up to that point. Something is better than nothing.
This is a HUGE slip even more than the coju thing. Having had several games under my belt now as mafia, I can say that there have been many times when I would slip up while typing and say something like this when I meant to make it more general and "Townie-like." I had to studiously reread my posts before posting, and even then I felt like I said certain incriminating things that made me sweat. and you know the first thing I did? try to put the heat on someone else so my post slips into the background.
And look at that, Bad Ash's very next post is to hop on someone else's bandwagon, with no other evidence to back it up I might add.
Unvote: coju
Vote: Bad Ash
I tried watching the first chapter, but my eyes started bleeding. Also, naming a sanctuary "Special Zone" has to be one of the lamest things in the universe. Anyway, with fourteen players, I would assume that the ratio ought to be 3:4 (around 10 aligned with town or neutral and 4 opposing). So, onto my prime suspects, in descendant order...
Bad Ash: His post #28 was either a huge slip or a honest mistake. His defense was quite poor, too.
Coju: I think his initial statements (#6, #16, #18) were made to push for information, but who knows.
Kestegs: This particular post (#21, by Coju) revealed that he has something to hide, perhaps scum.
Flip: Rant (#26) was uncalled for and I don't get were it came from; maybe goon's remorse.
Vote: Bad Ash