IWantToUseNumbersInMyName
New member
information>no information. With that said, BPC's question was reasonable, BA's words were a bit less reasonable, but I don't smell massive scummy vibes coming off either of them.
Final Fantasy Forum Mafia Game Thread
- Thread starter pharphis
- Start date
IWantToUseNumbersInMyName
New member
I'd also like to say that sometimes I'm just bad and wrong, and this was proven in recent memory when I thought neither of our D1 and D2 scum lynches were scummy at all. So...just saying I wouldn't value my input too much when I have so little to go off of.
BipolarChemist
New member
All input is valued! Just when you want to put in your two cents, sometimes it's really just worth 2 cents
BPC asked his question. I said I didn't like it. Zokar answered the question. People asked what I didn't like about it and it generated quite a bit of conversation. How is any of that stifling the conversation? And how was I trying to shut it down?
since when is disagreeing with something stifling conversation and an auto scum move?
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk
logoutzero
Active member
\/0T3: Drixx
For never coming through with his article highlight
For never coming through with his article highlight
coju
Well-known member
Thank you, Gwaihir, for the reply.
When are d1 and d2 lynches ever on someone scummy? There is always some post that someone finds that builds a case on it that a majority of people vote for, for whatever reason they may be voting: information, knows the person is town, loves bandwagons, etc.
There is extremely limited information on d1/2s. The given meta is town needs information. A mislynch on d1 isn't very bad, but not voting for someone: they should, in your (the voters') eyes appear such town that losing them would threating our victory; OR you know they are scum and obv won't vote for your m8 d1. Unless you just <3 towncred so much, "Pharphis couldn't be scum, he locked every scum all game!"
(After writing this out, I reread your comment and actually understood what you were saying... So, don't take this as an attack towards you.)
When are d1 and d2 lynches ever on someone scummy? There is always some post that someone finds that builds a case on it that a majority of people vote for, for whatever reason they may be voting: information, knows the person is town, loves bandwagons, etc.
There is extremely limited information on d1/2s. The given meta is town needs information. A mislynch on d1 isn't very bad, but not voting for someone: they should, in your (the voters') eyes appear such town that losing them would threating our victory; OR you know they are scum and obv won't vote for your m8 d1. Unless you just <3 towncred so much, "Pharphis couldn't be scum, he locked every scum all game!"
Technomancer
New member
That's my point. For me though, it just seems too perfect and doesn't set well with me, especially just out of the blue like that. Why don't we all just claim vanilla townie out of the gate every game then? I don't like it.
---
I used to not be as in favor of questionable lynch > no lynch, but I've warmed up to it quite a bit since I've been playing. I would like to see someone lynched today, otherwise is just gives mafia/vigi(s?) a free day and we get nothing. I'd like to know who Zokar really is and we won't get that if we let someone NK him. My vote stands (his tone makes me think we'd be doing him a favor anyway), although I've thought about switching to Gory or BA.
I'm afraid I won't be around for day close, I'm off to DM some D&D for the next 5-6 hours. I may be able to chime in again real soon, but after that, I'll just have to see you guys tomorrow. If I survive the night, which I probably won't. I tend to get kiled pretty early for some reason.
It did end up generating a lot of conversation, but to me it seemed like you wanted it not to. Like you wanted to give Zokar a free pass, which to me is a scum move.
I am suspicious of someone who is being cagey like Zokar is, and to me it seems like you are trying to assist him in being cagey.
OT: what type you playing?
Technomancer
New member
It's 4E tonight. They are gonna have to diffuse an elemental power construct that has been running out of control for the last century+, but has been contained until recently.
I have a 2nd Edition game going too, but that's been on the back burner for the last couple months.
It seemed like I wanted to give Zokar a free pass? If it "seemed" that way you are implying you aren't sure my actual motives and yet you voted for me without engaging me about the matter whatsoever about it. Interesting.
For the record the last thing I was doing was giving Zokar a free pass. The entire conversation had absolutely nothing to do with that.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk
logoutzero
Active member
[highlight]Attention Players:[/highlight]
Due to some bad IRL circumstances, Laarz has been forced to withdraw from the game.
Everyone please send your thoughts, prayers, well wishes, and general good juju towards him and his extended family, as they are going through a terrible trial right now. Our hearts go out to you and your family, Laarz. <3<3<3
FredOfErik volunteers as tribute, and will take over for Laarz for the remainder of the game. Thank you to both parties for their support of this game!
Day 1 will be ending in approximately 2 hours, at 5PM EST.
Due to some bad IRL circumstances, Laarz has been forced to withdraw from the game.
Everyone please send your thoughts, prayers, well wishes, and general good juju towards him and his extended family, as they are going through a terrible trial right now. Our hearts go out to you and your family, Laarz. <3<3<3
FredOfErik volunteers as tribute, and will take over for Laarz for the remainder of the game. Thank you to both parties for their support of this game!
Day 1 will be ending in approximately 2 hours, at 5PM EST.
Last edited:
logoutzero
Active member
Pharphis will be along later in the afternoon/evening to edit the player list.
IWantToUseNumbersInMyName
New member
Scum drawing so much attention to themselves D1 always seems super unlikely to me, so it looks to me like worst case is zokar(worst likely case) is that zokar is VI I guess? Which isnt really *bad* for town, other than the fact that lynching someone who isnt town is wasteful. If he flips VI what do we learn though?
Squirt me!
thank you, Mrs. Tru.
Usually pro-town because sometimes the switching does NK a scummy. But there have been mafia drivers before.
Which is why my answer was zero. I wanted to be sarcastic.,
Guys, got class in 15 minutes. Won't be around for the end of the day. Sorry.
too much to catch up on and so I can't cast a vote. 
IWantToUseNumbersInMyName
New member
On second thought, I dont even know what wed really learn from lynching any of the other primary speakers for today...so, I guess Vote: Zokar
BipolarChemist
New member
I doubt there will be a lynch but most others seem to be in favour of Day 1 lynch. Only person I'm willing to vote for is Bad Ash.
?Vote: Bad Ash
?Vote: Bad Ash
Nice. Have played that for a while, currently in a Pathfinder campaign (modified 3.5)
Sorry to hear that Laarz. I hope for the best possible outcome for you, whatever it is.
