The Most Extreme Elimination Challenge Mafia Edition

Gwaihir said:
So you claim to be a power role, which puts you in danger from a mafia kill, but don't give the town info about it? That is suspect to me. I also don't see a new player just coming out of the blue to post that he is a listener as mafia, it just seems too farfetched.

Vote: thefranklin
Click to expand...

In this post, in my response to Moar, I already stated that assuming I, as a new player, would have claimed listener as mafia, was beyond my reasoning, and by default, skill.
 
Pyrotechnician said:
I think I thunk maybe? My other thought was the bonus is completely unrelated to a lynch immunity, and that it was a convienent way for him to claim lynch immunity if that’s his actual role (easy opportunity made it an easy claim, and it would have truth). In short, I’m weary of his bonus claim.


Anyway, I don’t have a ton of time to sift and sift through all kinds of crap right now, but the short of it is I am suspicious of the people that keep flipping back and forth like it’s their job. It shows a lack of concern and thought put into their vote and I don’t like it. Also some of the votes being placed have terrible backing and are giving me a feeling of “do we have to bus him? I’m not sure? Can we save him? Maybe we can’t! Maybe we can!â€
Click to expand...

So basically this is all me. Trying to determine if I have the patience to develop a response.

For the second time, people are more than free to devote plenty of time into the bonus claim, but keep wasting your time. Not everything is a big glass a wine and spinning something that was done to actually help the town into something different is scum in my book without a doubt.

And the lack of concern is evident of confusion from the information that has come out. When both are even in votes, yes or no, can a train develop quickly if one gains an edge? Of course it can. I was not comfortable letting my vote sit while sifting through the crap and having it lead to a bad decision. On top of it, my opinion changed, frequently. I don't think listeners should be in any games so it could be a lie. I don't think names would be given if a listener did exist. I don't think the post that logout received even sounds like a QT post. I think he is adamant about his role and alignment. I think franklin is playing it too safe. I think franklin could be anti-town if logout is who he says he is. I think that if a cop came out and said he found scum, you don't lynch the cop to see if he's telling the truth this early in the game. I think logouts posts have been crazy. I think he's ignoring rules on page one and his suspicion of gory is peculiar.

There's crap on crap on crap. And I am clueless and flip flopped many times. If I was indeed scum because of this why would I try to make a right decision? I would know if one was town and one wasn't. I would know if both we town and would be much more comfortable sticking a vote and letting it sit.

Welcome to my scum list. I will enjoy watching you waste your time by trying to get me lynched and dedicating a large portion of your post about who else is scum and save your reasoning for your vote on a potential lynch target as the minority.
 
I kind of want to lynch Zokar today instead of either Franklin or Logout, though I recognize that as not a possibility. His posts strike me as avoiding the topic at hand, while pushing for topics about possible neutrals and bringing up the serial killer angle again.

I also really disliked his statement about being four teams, and then what appears to be backpedaling about neutrals or the mafia being the fourth team.
 
logoutzero said:
In this post, in my response to Moar, I already stated that assuming I, as a new player, would have claimed listener as mafia, was beyond my reasoning, and by default, skill.
Click to expand...

Seals it for me. My vote won't budge from you until you are strung up. You have a team and putting out the new player for a bold play to get long term town credibility is just the kind of move a savvy team of veteran mafioso might try. You pretending like you would not have any team advice is the last straw. You are absolutely unconvincing.
 
Caluin Graye said:
I kind of want to lynch Zokar today instead of either Franklin or Logout, though I recognize that as not a possibility. His posts strike me as avoiding the topic at hand, while pushing for topics about possible neutrals and bringing up the serial killer angle again.

I also really disliked his statement about being four teams, and then what appears to be backpedaling about neutrals or the mafia being the fourth team.
Click to expand...

you're free to lynch me if you like, but you'll die.

i'm talking about teams and names and neutrals and sk and all sorts of stuff because that's what interests me. this whole back and forth that's going on right now doesn't. I can't make heads or tails out of it and anybody that suggests that at this point it's anything other than a 50/50 toss up is trying to push an angle imo.

So, let the **** hit the fan with whoever dies, I don't really care.
 
thefranklin said:
So rather than risk the mafia killing me you lynch me? This is one heck of an opportunistic vote. If I claim to have role A or role B, does that change where your vote goes? How much more information do you need other than it didn't help the town or hurt the mafia last night? (to be clear, I am hinting that your questions are only something only scum wants to know)
Click to expand...

I don't think you are town, so I have no problem trying to lynch you. I don't see what benefit your partial claim gave the town. You looked to me like mafia trying not to get lynched without having to commit to a fake claim, especially if they didn't get anything they could use from last night's kill.



Also, I have noticed a couple of people saying they think there is a SK - Moar and Zokar I think? Could you guys say why you think there is a SK when we have not even had a night with 2 kills?
 
Zokar said:
you're free to lynch me if you like, but you'll die.

i'm talking about teams and names and neutrals and sk and all sorts of stuff because that's what interests me. this whole back and forth that's going on right now doesn't. I can't make heads or tails out of it and anybody that suggests that at this point it's anything other than a 50/50 toss up is trying to push an angle imo.

So, let the **** hit the fan with whoever dies, I don't really care.
Click to expand...

I am definitely confused by this post. What are you trying to say here?
 
*inflicts a surprise high pressure colon-ic on phar for vote obstruction of the keyboard impaired

unvote: iwanttousenumbers
vote: logoutzero
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk 2
 
Well that was a whole bunch of reading but I have come to an conclusion, i'm going to apply the *KISS* principle and

Vote: thefranklin
 
10 votes to lynch and 11 votes to lock the lynch
My count say each have 7
5 mins left?

I am willing to switch to log if we need to get a lynch here.
 
Zokar said:
you're free to lynch me if you like, but you'll die.

i'm talking about teams and names and neutrals and sk and all sorts of stuff because that's what interests me. this whole back and forth that's going on right now doesn't. I can't make heads or tails out of it and anybody that suggests that at this point it's anything other than a 50/50 toss up is trying to push an angle imo.

So, let the **** hit the fan with whoever dies, I don't really care.
Click to expand...

Wow, it's been awhile since I've gotten that kind of reaction just by calling someone scum without providing a real case.
 
Another no lynch. One of these dudes is scum. I can't think of another reason for people not switching their votes. This is a train wreck of a day, myself included.
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top