@korial - I didn't see TC's post that the story actually meant something today before I was confused about the night's results. It makes a lot more sense now that he let us know the story is linked to what happened.
I honestly don't see the difference in me saying "I've found CG scummy, anyone else too?" or making a wall of quotes. In both instances I'm saying that I've caught a scum vibe off him ... one just takes a whole lot longer. I am pressed for time so if I'm going to do the whole wall of quotes thing, I'd rather not do it if the folks I view as town aren't getting the same vibe. CG is difficult to read, so I'm not particularly sure the vibe I'm catching is correct.
Also, there's something to be said for how people react to a question like that. Moar, for example, immediately tried to twist what I actually asked into something else and used that manipulation as a basis to paint me scummy. Now let's say I do the wall of quotes, people agree, and I'm right and CG flips scum. What does that say about Moar?
@Korial, @djmbbandie - thank you for your answers. I've had you both on my probable town list for awhile and since neither of you have a clear read it seems worthwhile to at least go back and re-asses what struck me as scummy and wall-o-quote as necessary.