Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

Bah, not enough time left! I probably won't be online the rest of the day phase.

flubb's response to cdm's claim looks super super scummy.

cdm's response to djm's claim only looks scummy. kestegs (I think it was him) was right when he said it benefits mafia to last one more day and take out one townie while doing so. cdm gave a partial claim but not a full claim. The character name in particular is missing. However, cdm did the same thing his first game so there is precedent.

Unvote: crawlingdeadman
Vote: flubbucket


@cdm - who is on your scummy list that is getting attention?
 
Wow. Been reading starting with the beginning of Day 1, sorry I missed so much. Very sorry I missed out on the voting, but I definitely didn't want to vote w/o reading everything.

Gas, canister, eh? That means Flubb is probably Scarecrow since I used my bus-like ability on myself and him.

Vote: Flubbucket

Pretty weak defense, I know, but it's all good if I get lynched at the end of the day since I only had one shot anyway. Just do me a favor and lynch flubb tomorrow.

Any reason you did not do a full claim?

1) yes
2) yes
3) not in particular, but perhaps.
Who's eyes is batman 'town'? Only through the 4th wall is batman good. The "Town" thinks of batman as bad; along the same crook lines as all the other villains. (at least that's what i've obtained from the films)

I differ on the opinion on Batman. As far as I can tell, normal "town" consider him good. He does have issues with authority, and gets persecuted by the police at points, but it seems doubtful to me that he would not be town.

Unvote: crawlingdeadman

Interesting. So do you believe cdm? Do you think flubb is scum?

Guess I will come out with it. I am Azrael. Some dude named Jean Valley. Never heard of him before, but I had the ability to forgo my vote and lynchability for something else.

I will give some advice if I can from the sidelines, and have some extra firepower i'll try to wait to dish out when the time is right. Basically a unlynchable, unvotable vigilante, I was out of town previous night so I had no intention of trying to use it uneducated. I would assume we are up against some pretty heavy roles if I have this, but half the fun is not being called out on it. I always expected whoever figured it out would be scum for having a reason to look at the player list, but I am not sure if this is the case. If I was able to vote, I would be going after CDM today for information.

That actually seems like a very fun role. I would be very surprised if an anti-town role could "leave" the game like that. And apparently it fit with lore.

This is the most interesting post I've read all game long, excluding the ones about how much DJM enjoys swallowing. A treestump vigilante? I almost want to just commit suicide to see the complete roles list[STRIKE] and to see how much BS is being spewed[/STRIKE].

How many bullets are in your gun, Azzy-poo? Because I'd love for you to shoot me first thing tomorrow, right between my eyes, if you have bullets to spare. Just to see how things play out.

A wee bit suicidal? I had you pegged as scum or VI. Asking to get shot is not VI play though. Thinking you have to be scum.

I call bs on you winning with the town. I think you have a very specific wincon with a very specific role to go with it, in the spirit of G-Man. :)

So you think he is a non-voting/non counting anti-town? That seems like it would be really hard to deal with.

Hoping to have time today to look at both cdm and flubb before casting my vote.

I know this will be like pulling teeth, but flubb, any chance you would claim?
 
So does CDM have another poison shot or whatever and scum are trying to switch the votes to flub? I see you kegs, cg. Wouldn't a convincing bus driver claim come with targets for the first night and ahem maybe a character name?

And I am getting the feeling of scum day talk here...

You ignored me. Again. Yay!

Bah, not enough time left! I probably won't be online the rest of the day phase.

flubb's response to cdm's claim looks super super scummy.

cdm's response to djm's claim only looks scummy. kestegs (I think it was him) was right when he said it benefits mafia to last one more day and take out one townie while doing so. cdm gave a partial claim but not a full claim. The character name in particular is missing. However, cdm did the same thing his first game so there is precedent.

Unvote: crawlingdeadman
Vote: flubbucket


@cdm - who is on your scummy list that is getting attention?

Yes, that was me that said that. Although I drew the opposite conclusion you did.

vote: crawlingdeadman

I'm fine to switch to flubb, we can't not lynch one of them today. My feelings only slightly lean toward cdm being scum over flubb. The biggest reason are cdm's targets and timing of his role use. And a one shot bus driver is also an uncommon role.
 
Kegs: I answered your question that I could answer, I have no idea if they are tied together. I threw that in their to see if anyone would react to it, if there is a connection I was hoping a guilty party would help me out.

Kind of like I haven't questioned cdm on why he wouldn't use his bus to keep bandie alive. Of course he only (sketchily, I might add) claimed a "bus drive like" ability, leaving him room to change that if required. How anyone could switch to flub based on that is beyond me. An unvote, sure but to actually lynch? Really guys?
 
Interesting. So do you believe cdm? Do you think flubb is scum?

The only thing I've seen scummy about flub is cdm's quote unquote one shot bus. Where did y'all get this except from kestegs? He said, "My only shot is ________________ (what I did)." He still has tickets to ride.

I'll have to check them two out, like you are, to see who to vote for. CDM didn't seem desperate and actually seemed defeated in that post, which other's have put together a/b the differences b/w cdm and mal's posts claiming the same thing.
 
The only thing I've seen scummy about flub is cdm's quote unquote one shot bus. Where did y'all get this except from kestegs? He said, "My only shot is ________________ (what I did)." He still has tickets to ride.

Pretty weak defense, I know, but it's all good if I get lynched at the end of the day since I only had one shot anyway. Just do me a favor and lynch flubb tomorrow.

Though, I had to go back to notice that he had even said it. Interesting that kestegs and Laarz both honed in on that particular part of his claim.


PS: "maybe he was further bussed...". Sure.

Who said that? Source, please?
 
The only thing I've seen scummy about flub is cdm's quote unquote one shot bus. Where did y'all get this except from kestegs? He said, "My only shot is ________________ (what I did)." He still has tickets to ride.

I'll have to check them two out, like you are, to see who to vote for. CDM didn't seem desperate and actually seemed defeated in that post, which other's have put together a/b the differences b/w cdm and mal's posts claiming the same thing.

Hmm. This is actually the read I have. It feels like cdm is telling the truth - it seems like he is sad that he won't be believed, not annoyed he got found out.

I do find it weird he did not do a full claim though, especially giving a name.

A normal townie in flubbs spot I expect to claim as well, but it is flubb. On the other hand I would expect a townie to call out cdm as a liar and push more on him, which flubb really did not do. So of the two, I am going with flubb today, unless my votes are needed for a lynch.

Which leads to my claim so we don't get people confused on a day where one of these two need to go:

I am Mayor Anthony Garcia, politician. My power is slightly different from the one we have seen previously:
I choose a target at night. Once I vote during the day, my target must follow my vote, forced by the mod. If I switch unvote, and/or revote, they must follow my vote to the new target.

N1: I chose coju. He did not vote, and so I did not force the lock on Mal with mine and his. Once Mal was locked, I saw no reason to give away my power.
N2: I chose omg. He has not given me a reason to believe he town, and so far today has not convinced me he will use his vote wisely, so I have no problem using it for him.

Vote: flubbucket
 
Gwaihir: why did you feel it necessary to tell us your role now?

Because as soon as Pyro sees my vote, Pyro will have omg vote flubb. What would your reaction to seeing a mod switched vote with claim? I don't remember the game, but it has happened before, when Moar was politician. She voted someone using the (slightly different) politician role, and it immediately caused people to unvote the person. I remember it at least caused unvotes, not sure if it was a mislynch. I think flubb should be lynched, and not claiming would be more likely cause the opposite to happen.
 
What does Moar have to do with djm's claim of receiving scummy sounding results and cdm's claim of switching himself with you?

I also notice lack of a claim. If you don't have gas canisters, you should be providing evidence that cdm is lying rather than focus on multiple third parties.

I also notice you are naming a single name, Scarecrow. Kinda like how Mal knew exactly what character an investigation of him would return.



It's how a busdriver works. Any switch by any player involving yourself and cdm would mean anyone targeting cdm would instead target you and anyone targeting you would instead target cdm. If djm sent in an action naming cdm, then djm would have received results about you.
I never said Moar had anything to do with djm's claim or cdm, as you can read in my post. My statements regarding Moar were specific to Caluin Graye and you know this. I also only mention the scarecrow because crawlingdeadman mentions it specifically. You know this as well. Any more stupid questions you already know the answers to?? Oh no wait a minute...
Bah, not enough time left! I probably won't be online the rest of the day phase.

flubb's response to cdm's claim looks super super scummy.

cdm's response to djm's claim only looks scummy. kestegs (I think it was him) was right when he said it benefits mafia to last one more day and take out one townie while doing so. cdm gave a partial claim but not a full claim. The character name in particular is missing. However, cdm did the same thing his first game so there is precedent.

Unvote: crawlingdeadman
Vote: flubbucket


@cdm - who is on your scummy list that is getting attention?
How convenient....you won't be here. Now isn't that just super super......



Any reason you did not do a full claim?



I differ on the opinion on Batman. As far as I can tell, normal "town" consider him good. He does have issues with authority, and gets persecuted by the police at points, but it seems doubtful to me that he would not be town.



Interesting. So do you believe cdm? Do you think flubb is scum?



That actually seems like a very fun role. I would be very surprised if an anti-town role could "leave" the game like that. And apparently it fit with lore.



A wee bit suicidal? I had you pegged as scum or VI. Asking to get shot is not VI play though. Thinking you have to be scum.



So you think he is a non-voting/non counting anti-town? That seems like it would be really hard to deal with.

Hoping to have time today to look at both cdm and flubb before casting my vote.

I know this will be like pulling teeth, but flubb, any chance you would claim?
Nope. Surely you know I hate role claiming.

Though, I had to go back to notice that he had even said it. Interesting that kestegs and Laarz both honed in on that particular part of his claim.




Who said that? Source, please?
Here it is.

Eh, idk. Maybe he was further bussed, who knows? Couse if he had been he'd have come at my claim differently all I know is that whatever dj targeted me with hit flubb as far as I know.

Damn, sorry I mentioned this then. He's a great character, you should read some of his own series if he interests you at all.

Probably not since I'd bet he's town aligned. Azrael was a pretty good character in the comics. He started out as an assasin, became Batman for a while, then when he started to be an a-hole Bruce took him down. Then he redeemed himself a bit. Now he's dead with no body which in the comic book world means, he's not really dead. Pyro's either done his research well or is as much a Batman nerd as I am. I can't wait to see the whole character list and their powers when we're done.
 
Nope. Surely you know I hate role claiming.

So say you are town and in a situation where if you refuse to claim, town will most likely lynch you (a townie) instead of scum. You hate claiming so much, that you will hurt town's and thereby (assuming you're town) your own chances of winning so badly just to avoid it?
 
I've just read this thing in one go. Sorry for my lack of activity this day phase. Busy RL with lunches out and consuming beers in the sun, can't say I'm sober right now. ;)

So dj says cdm is scum. I believe dj is town. Cdm says he switched with flubb, so it's flubb that's scum. Looking at the posts from both of them, I think cdm is town and did what he said he did.

Vote: flubbucket
 
So say you are town and in a situation where if you refuse to claim, town will most likely lynch you (a townie) instead of scum. You hate claiming so much, that you will hurt town's and thereby (assuming you're town) your own chances of winning so badly just to avoid it?

+1. I for one do not believe the odds that cdm happened to use a one shot "bus like ability" (again, he didnt say he was a bus driver) randomnly on Flub and himself when if one was town they would 99% of the time use it on the (basically) confirmed rolecop or whatever djm is. He ex post facto chose one of the other people that seemed scummy and say he bus drove them.

If there is not day chat, I 100% bet cdm went to the list looking to choose Bad Ash as his "target" and that is when he noticed BA was not in the list.
 
I am undecided whether to keep my vote on CDM or change it to Glib but Glib's response to CDM's claim and his refusal to claim outright swings the deal for me.

Unvote: crawlingdeadman
Vote: flubbucket
 
Eh, idk. Maybe he was further bussed, who knows? Couse if he had been he'd have come at my claim differently all I know is that whatever dj targeted me with hit flubb as far as I know.

Damn, sorry I mentioned this then. He's a great character, you should read some of his own series if he interests you at all.

Probably not since I'd bet he's town aligned. Azrael was a pretty good character in the comics. He started out as an assasin, became Batman for a while, then when he started to be an a-hole Bruce took him down. Then he redeemed himself a bit. Now he's dead with no body which in the comic book world means, he's not really dead. Pyro's either done his research well or is as much a Batman nerd as I am. I can't wait to see the whole character list and their powers when we're done.

I guess this is a longshot, but did djm ever say anything about cdms claim? it would make it real easy if the bolded was not possible...
 
Back
Top