Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

[Kestegs]

Note quite the same defense - there are significant differences.

Malevolent suggested a number of things which happened to include a bus driver defense amongst them. He also suggested that someone else switched him, and as such, did not provide an alternate target. He flailed for an answer to keep from getting lynched.

CDM, on the other hand, gives a specific defense and a specific alternate target for that defense. He does not flail, but cites a single scenario that is very plausible. Additionally, because he himself is the bus driver, we know that if Flubbucket does not flip with some kind of gas canister, then CDM will just be lynched the next day. A scum trading one for one with a townie is not a good move for scum.

I'm inclined to believe CDM.

Unvote: crawlingdeadman
Vote: flubbucket

But that claim works in scum favor if cdm is scum. He knows he's going to die either today or tomorrow, and this way a townie goes first at least. You could be right though, more thought is required.

Eh, idk. Maybe he was further bussed, who knows? Couse if he had been he'd have come at my claim differently all I know is that whatever dj targeted me with hit flubb as far as I know.

Damn, sorry I mentioned this then. He's a great character, you should read some of his own series if he interests you at all.

Probably not since I'd bet he's town aligned. Azrael was a pretty good character in the comics. He started out as an assasin, became Batman for a while, then when he started to be an a-hole Bruce took him down. Then he redeemed himself a bit. Now he's dead with no body which in the comic book world means, he's not really dead. Pyro's either done his research well or is as much a Batman nerd as I am. I can't wait to see the whole character list and their powers when we're done.

I didn't know anything about that character, interesting.

 

[djmbbandie]

@ cdm, can we get a name for your character?

@ Bad Ash, I was going to investigate you tonight. You haven't posted like you did last game... Any reasoning?

 

[Jason Maher]

Unvote: cdm

(that stings)
Vote: glibbucket

(not so much)

Hope I'm not being gullible.

 

[Jason Maher]

@ cdm, can we get a name for your character?

@ Bad Ash, I was going to investigate you tonight. You haven't posted like you did last game... Any reasoning?

You may want to read the thread.

 

[djmbbandie]

I've read it, he says he has a bus driver ability, what sort of character in Batman has that?

But

Unvote: crawlingdeadman
Vote: flubbucket

For now.

 

[omgwtfbbqpwned]

Guess I will come out with it. I am Azrael. Some dude named Jean Valley. Never heard of him before, but I had the ability to forgo my vote and lynchability for something else.

I will give some advice if I can from the sidelines, and have some extra firepower i'll try to wait to dish out when the time is right. Basically a unlynchable, unvotable vigilante, I was out of town previous night so I had no intention of trying to use it uneducated. I would assume we are up against some pretty heavy roles if I have this, but half the fun is not being called out on it. I always expected whoever figured it out would be scum for having a reason to look at the player list, but I am not sure if this is the case. If I was able to vote, I would be going after CDM today for information.

This is the most interesting post I've read all game long, excluding the ones about how much DJM enjoys swallowing. A treestump vigilante? I almost want to just commit suicide to see the complete roles list[STRIKE] and to see how much BS is being spewed[/STRIKE].

How many bullets are in your gun, Azzy-poo? Because I'd love for you to shoot me first thing tomorrow, right between my eyes, if you have bullets to spare. Just to see how things play out.

 

[Jason Maher]

You're one crazy lass, Joanna.

@djm: I was talking about the fact Bad Ash outed himself, which you evidently missed.

 

[djmbbandie]

I've also read that, and it strikes me as odd because he hasn't posted a lot of contributions this round, besides his ongoing feud with Noodle.

 

[Laarz]

Wow. Been reading starting with the beginning of Day 1, sorry I missed so much. Very sorry I missed out on the voting, but I definitely didn't want to vote w/o reading everything.

Gas, canister, eh? That means Flubb is probably Scarecrow since I used my bus-like ability on myself and him.

Vote: Flubbucket

Pretty weak defense, I know, but it's all good if I get lynched at the end of the day since I only had one shot anyway. Just do me a favor and lynch flubb tomorrow.

So your a 1-shot busdriver?

Honestly, I randomly chose him. I made my list of the scummiest people, then picked three that looked the most likely that weren't getting any attention and rolled a six sided die to decide which I'd target. My choices were Laarz, flubb, and Moar. Again, not the scummiest, just the scummiest that weren't getting any attention.

Yep. Something that targeted me (dj's ability) instead targeted you. Seems to me that dj's ability doesn't give him much. He picks a target and gets to see what item(s) that person has. He picked me, but saw what you had. @dj on your results; do you get "crawlingdeadman has a gas canister" or do you get "gas canister"? I understand if you don't wanna tell, I just wanted to see if that was a possible response. Mal's was a weak claim because he didn't have any facts or targets to back it up. I do. I targeted you, flubb, with my ability. Implicate a scumbag? Okay. Lynch me now. When I flip as a character that doesn't use gas, you're toast.

The character that springs to my mind when "gas canister" is mentioned is Scarecrow. Joker could be another possibility, but the stories I've read where he was at his baddest, he usually stuck with guns, knives, crowbars, and explosives.

I dont quite get why you bussed yourself with someone you considered scummy, or bussed yourself at all. Dont busdrivers usually bus someone they think may be Nked, a townie, with someone that they think is scum in order to try to get the scum killed instead?

 

[Bad Ash]

This is the most interesting post I've read all game long, excluding the ones about how much DJM enjoys swallowing. A treestump vigilante? I almost want to just commit suicide to see the complete roles list[STRIKE] and to see how much BS is being spewed[/STRIKE].

How many bullets are in your gun, Azzy-poo? Because I'd love for you to shoot me first thing tomorrow, right between my eyes, if you have bullets to spare. Just to see how things play out.

Well, I'm torn on how much more info to give as there is a way to be removed from the game, but, I wont get into the nitty gritty. Definitely have someone I'd like to remove myself.

And go home DJM you're drunk

 

[BipolarChemist]

excluding the ones about how much DJM enjoys swallowing.

It's not the only thing he enjoys!

*wink wink* *nudge nudge*

 

[BipolarChemist]

I...I..I'm saying he's the bottom.

 

[djmbbandie]

I think I'm out after this game.

It's kinda getting ridiculous.

 

[Ankeli1]

Refresh us. Why do you think FoE is scum? I'm familiar with the post you quoted but I either don't understand it or don't agree with it. I don't see a LAMIST scenario with that one post of FoEs and LAMIST was the reason you gave for thinking FoE is scum.

It's just a feeling. The post he made after this one of yours reassures me.

yup, I win with the town. had a plan if that wasn't the case to finger noodle and just cause some damage, (hence the beginning of the day) when a re-read of my role revealed that I was in fact for the town

I call bs on you winning with the town. I think you have a very specific wincon with a very specific role to go with it, in the spirit of G-Man.

@ cdm, can we get a name for your character?

@ Bad Ash, I was going to investigate you tonight. You haven't posted like you did last game... Any reasoning?

The 1st is a valid question, the 2nd might not be a terrible idea all in all despite of his reveal.

 

[djmbbandie]

That's what I was thinking. It kind of scares me.

 

[BipolarChemist]

I think I'm out after this game.

It's kinda getting ridiculous.

Aww I'm sorry *hugz*

 

[flubbucket1]

What a night!! It's my Friday at work and they choose to install two new servers tonight...grief!! I'm telling these guys I don't have time for this because some guy in Kansas in accusing me of being a scarecrow. When I said it out loud it made me laugh. Scarecrow...Kansas...Oz....guess you had to be there. Anyway I read through and some stuff really stinks.

Honestly, I randomly chose him. I made my list of the scummiest people, then picked three that looked the most likely that weren't getting any attention and rolled a six sided die to decide which I'd target. My choices were Laarz, flubb, and Moar. Again, not the scummiest, just the scummiest that weren't getting any attention.

Yep. Something that targeted me (dj's ability) instead targeted you. Seems to me that dj's ability doesn't give him much. He picks a target and gets to see what item(s) that person has. He picked me, but saw what you had. @dj on your results; do you get "crawlingdeadman has a gas canister" or do you get "gas canister"? I understand if you don't wanna tell, I just wanted to see if that was a possible response. Mal's was a weak claim because he didn't have any facts or targets to back it up. I do. I targeted you, flubb, with my ability. Implicate a scumbag? Okay. Lynch me now. When I flip as a character that doesn't use gas, you're toast.

The character that springs to my mind when "gas canister" is mentioned is Scarecrow. Joker could be another possibility, but the stories I've read where he was at his baddest, he usually stuck with guns, knives, crowbars, and explosives.

I notice you mention both me and Moar (which meant nothing to me at first). Then when I see Caluin Graye just happens to switch his vote I remember his hounding of Moar from the previous day.

Note quite the same defense - there are significant differences.

Malevolent suggested a number of things which happened to include a bus driver defense amongst them. He also suggested that someone else switched him, and as such, did not provide an alternate target. He flailed for an answer to keep from getting lynched.

CDM, on the other hand, gives a specific defense and a specific alternate target for that defense. He does not flail, but cites a single scenario that is very plausible. Additionally, because he himself is the bus driver, we know that if Flubbucket does not flip with some kind of gas canister, then CDM will just be lynched the next day. A scum trading one for one with a townie is not a good move for scum.

I'm inclined to believe CDM.

Unvote: crawlingdeadman
Vote: flubbucket

You are really quick to believe crawlingdeadman. He just says he's a busdriver and you say ok. How convenient. I also notice you have had nothing to say to Moar. Why is that? It smells of a setup. I know I'm town and if I'm lynched, will the plan then be to go oopsey I guess it must be Moar?? All that silly bussing must have messed us up. Boy is my face red.

Cdm switches himself with you. Dj targets cdm. DJ receives the result on you, but assumes it was on cdm.

Of course that's all purely hypothetical. It's also the same defense male claimed.

I don't understand this at all.

 

[thefranklin]

So does CDM have another poison shot or whatever and scum are trying to switch the votes to flub? I see you kegs, cg. Wouldn't a convincing bus driver claim come with targets for the first night and ahem maybe a character name?

And I am getting the feeling of scum day talk here...

 

[thefranklin]

PS: "maybe he was further bussed...". Sure.

Vote: crawlingdeadman

 

[Goryani]

What a night!! It's my Friday at work and they choose to install two new servers tonight...grief!! I'm telling these guys I don't have time for this because some guy in Kansas in accusing me of being a scarecrow. When I said it out loud it made me laugh. Scarecrow...Kansas...Oz....guess you had to be there. Anyway I read through and some stuff really stinks.

I notice you mention both me and Moar (which meant nothing to me at first). Then when I see Caluin Graye just happens to switch his vote I remember his hounding of Moar from the previous day.

You are really quick to believe crawlingdeadman. He just says he's a busdriver and you say ok. How convenient. I also notice you have had nothing to say to Moar. Why is that? It smells of a setup. I know I'm town and if I'm lynched, will the plan then be to go oopsey I guess it must be Moar?? All that silly bussing must have messed us up. Boy is my face red.

What does Moar have to do with djm's claim of receiving scummy sounding results and cdm's claim of switching himself with you?

I also notice lack of a claim. If you don't have gas canisters, you should be providing evidence that cdm is lying rather than focus on multiple third parties.

I also notice you are naming a single name, Scarecrow. Kinda like how Mal knew exactly what character an investigation of him would return.

I don't understand this at all.

It's how a busdriver works. Any switch by any player involving yourself and cdm would mean anyone targeting cdm would instead target you and anyone targeting you would instead target cdm. If djm sent in an action naming cdm, then djm would have received results about you.