Mafia Game: Cheers/Frasier Theme

[pharphis]

@Gwaihir
I know you're not asking me but I thought I would mention that with respect to your "3) LOUD NOISES. But did you forget that he should now be out of saves, so how is he saving us all?
I took what Flubb said as sarcasm, as I do appear a little scummy only because I saved myself so that I can continue to save in the future (sarcasm on saving in the future). Anyway, I might have read that wrong.

Anyway. . .
although I've been felt fishy about you a bit for your suspicion of me and your claim (a tiny bit), I have to agree with Jcakes getting the vote. Him being saved BECAUSE he's a role blocker makes even more sense.
Like I think I've said before, the only other reason for unvoting Jcakes would be to cause distraction or perhaps a waste of a V1 today. Doesn't quite sound worth it, and even if that WAS the plan, well. . .

Unvote 1: Laarz
Unvote 2: coju
Vote 1: coju
Vote 2: Jcakes

 

[pharphis]

You being alive of course.
I checked my pm. I'm apparently a 'barfly. Protown' as well. Just claiming a vt protown barfly would be the easiest thing for me to do if I were hiding something. It says my name before that. So, I know my name now

I don't think this makes sense. . .
It would be more overpowered as a general game mechanic. If that were the case, then the game would be MUCH harder for mafia, and we ALREADY have had so many power roles. Do you think TC would allow this to be the game mechanic? Maybe because of Lore? I'm not really seeing it. . .

 

[Moar]

I must admit, I am confused why people keep claiming that my role is overpowered. We know the roles of everyone who has died, that can not be disputed. But what is more powerful - me being alive as the cause of the role reveals, or it just being a game mechanic?

The OP part is that it takes away claiming possibilities from the scum. They can't claim a role we know is dead.

 

[pharphis]

I want to admit that DO think his role is OP, but to answer his question I think it makes more sense then it just being how the game works on its own.

 

[Moar]

I think we need a list of who claimed what. I am getting confused. I'll start with what I remember off my head which is about to explode.

Moar: Gertrude Moon. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night.
Loz: Don't remember the name. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night.
flubb: Carla. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night.
pharphis: Daphne. 4shot doc.
Jcakes: Lillith. Psycatrist. Roleblocker.
coju: Won't tell. Barfly Percentage(?? Lawyer
Gwaihir: Barry (?). Reveals roles on NK as long as alive.
Laarz: Bebe. ?. Percentage bodyguard.
Pyro: Don't remember. Barfly. Can choose a drink for spiking every night.
nulio: Coach. Bartender. Can't vote.

Please fill inn what I am missing and correct what I got wrong.

 

[Gwaihir]

I checked my pm. I'm apparently a 'barfly. Protown' as well. Just claiming a vt protown barfly would be the easiest thing for me to do if I were hiding something. It says my name before that. So, I know my name now

So how does this fit with the lawyer thing? Still refusing to claim the name I see.

@Gwaihir
I know you're not asking me but I thought I would mention that with respect to your "3) LOUD NOISES. But did you forget that he should now be out of saves, so how is he saving us all?
I took what Flubb said as sarcasm, as I do appear a little scummy only because I saved myself so that I can continue to save in the future (sarcasm on saving in the future). Anyway, I might have read that wrong.

Anyway. . .
although I've been felt fishy about you a bit for your suspicion of me and your claim (a tiny bit), I have to agree with Jcakes getting the vote.

I always have trouble understanding what flubb is trying to get at, so I just try to answer everything. Also, I couldn't help myself with the Steve Carrel joke.

As for suspicion, that is fair, its everyone's job to be suspicious. I do agree on vote targets though. I am not sure who should get vote one and who should get vote 2 though. coju is acting so weird is is not even funny, so I think he gets my vote 2. Willing to switch that around if someone has a good idea on how we should vote1/vote2.

The OP part is that it takes away claiming possibilities from the scum. They can't claim a role we know is dead.

I see, and fair. I see my role as tempering that power by the fact I could be killed. Guaranteed reveals the whole game long seems much, much more powerful than it being controlled by a person.

I think we need a list of who claimed what. I am getting confused. I'll start with what I remember off my head which is about to explode.

Moar: Gertrude Moon. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night.
Loz: Don't remember the name. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night.
flubb: Carla. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night.
pharphis: Daphne. 4shot doc.
Jcakes: Lillith. Psycatrist. Roleblocker.
coju: Won't tell. Barfly Percentage(?? Lawyer
Gwaihir: Barry (?). Reveals roles on NK as long as alive.
Laarz: Bebe. ?. Percentage bodyguard.
Pyro: Don't remember. Barfly. Can choose a drink for spiking every night.
nulio: Coach. Bartender. Can't vote.

Please fill inn what I am missing and correct what I got wrong.

Mine is right, but details are, Father Barry, Priest.

Vote 2: coju

 

[flubbucket1]

Don't feel left out. Most people look at me sideways!!

...I always have trouble understanding what flubb is trying to get at, so I just try to answer everything. Also, I couldn't help myself with the Steve Carrel joke...

Here is what I was referencing

I just read through all of his posts. . .
I apologize for not protecting him, but I had completely forgotten about his role (which is what my surprise is referring to when I said "another cop!?!?").

Why I went for myself instead of anyone else? Well, I'm the only live person that I know that hasn't been recruited, and my vote can be very valuable. I thought they would have gone for me (because I had forgotten about the cop) simply because I have helped a lot with setting the ground for some cases;

Gory,
frozzzen (I helped convince everyone to vote2)
Mal (mostly pcm, but again I helped to convince people to vote2)
CG (I was the one who questioned his role claim, AND even way back when Gory 'saved' him from OMG)

So I would say I've proven myself to be a threat to them. Otherwise I would have gone for Gwaihir or someone if I didn't fear them being recruited.


And finally, why the hell wouldn't I just say I bluffed having any saves left or 'saved' my last save if I was anti-town and wanted the cop dead? This makes no sense.

Hurrah for pharphis!! He will save us all with his...his...his...

I'll have to get back to you.

 

[pharphis]

I just realized something. . . My pm says I can target the same person several times in a row , not twice in a row, like I thought it did. So I could have saved ML 2-3 times depending on their determination on targeting him.
BEST DOC EVAR

At least now I see why it was 4-shot.

Anyway, I checked my pm to check my last name and to see if there was any more to it. It also says Daphne Moon. Barfly, Protown.

 

[LozHinge the Unhinged]

Hi, I'm Paul Krapence and I serve up whiskies :yes:

On balance, this is how I vote. I don't believe Cakes or coju are town.

Vote 1: Jcakes
Vote 2: coju

 

[pharphis]

Oh - I thought I'd admit to it now rather than forget and have someone dig it up post-game.

The night ML died was a night I didn't even send in a target (because I totally forgot to, thinking I couldn't save ML). iirc only one person died that night, so this may prove to be useful information. i'm going to go double check.

Also, I'm willing to swap V1/V2 as necessary, as well.

 

[pharphis]

Okay. . .

N4 - MartinLong is dead. He was Eddie. Pro Town. Cop
D5 - Malevolent is dead. He was Robin. Anti Town. 1 shot recruiter
D5 - Noodle is dead. He was Roz. Pro Town. Jailkeeper

Given my previous confession about not sending in a target N4, who wants to bet Noodle saved the other target from the anti-town?

 

[Moar]

I just realized something. . . My pm says I can target the same person several times in a row , not twice in a row, like I thought it did. So I could have saved ML 2-3 times depending on their determination on targeting him.
BEST DOC EVAR

At least now I see why it was 4-shot.

Anyway, I checked my pm to check my last name and to see if there was any more to it. It also says Daphne Moon. Barfly, Protown.

Do you "Barfliies" have a night chat? You seem to be a group as well.

 

[pharphis]

I don't have any chat. I get the feeling that would be WAY too OP if that was the case, though. 3 night chats? Insane

 

[Moar]

I think we need a list of who claimed what. I am getting confused. I'll start with what I remember off my head which is about to explode.

Moar: Gertrude Moon. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night with gin.
Loz: Paul Krapence. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night with whisky.
flubb: Carla. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night.
pharphis: Daphne Moon. Barfly. 4shot doc.
Jcakes: Lillith. Psycatrist. Roleblocker.
coju: Won't tell. Barfly Percentage(?) Lawyer
Gwaihir: Father Barry. Priest. Reveals roles on NK as long as alive.
Laarz: Bebe. ?. Percentage bodyguard.
Pyro: Don't remember. Barfly. Can choose a drink for spiking every night.
nulio: Coach. Bartender. Can't vote.

Please fill inn what I am missing and correct what I got wrong.

On balance, this is how I vote. I don't believe Cakes or coju are town.

I don't have any chat. I get the feeling that would be WAY too OP if that was the case, though. 3 night chats? Insane

The Barflies have a doc and a cop. So yes, that's way OP. But then this game is not normal.

 

[Moar]

I managed to not erase a sentence that I had from a quote to remember what Loz name was. I did not write "On balance, this is how I vote. I don't believe Cakes or coju are town."

But I do agree with him.

Vote 2: coju

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Name is Martin Crane. Father of Niles and Fraiser.

So you don't cakes or coju are town but you do agree with him? Who do you agree with?

 

[Moar]

Name is Martin Crane. Father of Niles and Fraiser.

So you don't cakes or coju are town but you do agree with him? Who do you agree with?

LoZ. It was his sentence.

I think we need a list of who claimed what. I am getting confused. I'll start with what I remember off my head which is about to explode.

Moar: Gertrude Moon. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night with gin.
Loz: Paul Krapence. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night with whisky.
flubb: Carla. Waiter. Can spike a drink every night.
pharphis: Daphne Moon. Barfly. 4shot doc.
Jcakes: Lillith. Psycatrist. Roleblocker.
coju: Won't tell. Barfly Percentage(?) Lawyer
Gwaihir: Father Barry. Priest. Reveals roles on NK as long as alive.
Laarz: Bebe. ?. Percentage bodyguard.
Pyro: Martin Crane. Barfly. Can choose a drink for spiking every night.
nulio: Coach. Bartender. Can't vote.

 

[Moar]

Remind me please since I can't seem to find the post. Didn't Uraj also revealed as Barfly? It is not in Thy's reveal on page 1.

 

[coju]

Hi, I'm Paul Krapence and I serve up whiskies :yes:

On balance, this is how I vote. I don't believe Cakes or coju are town.

Vote 1: Jcakes
Vote 2: coju

On balance, that would make Cakes anti-town and coju town.

@Gwa: Yes, I still refuse to give my name. By the looks of it, Pyro hasn't gave his name.
Pyro! Pm Thy and figure out what your name is! It is of crucial importance!

Sick him, Town! Another one who hasn't gave every bit of information! GHNA!!!

 

[Moar]

I'm Fraiser Crane, barfly, Pro-Town

Found it. So we have Fraiser, his father and his sister in law as claimed barflies. I bet Niles was one also. That looks like close family. Is there anyone else that fits there? I can't think about anyone though I know more about Cheers than Frasier.