Mafia Game: Cheers/Frasier Theme
- Thread starter Thyiad1
- Start date
ThunderCat
Active member
I'm not sure if I should take that as a compliment or not.
However, all I did for this game was make sure that everything that Thyiad put together is suitable and balanced. One can never anticipate all the moves before the game actually begins.
Carry on.
All I have figured out that scum came from both cheers and fraisier by using the wiki (Robin and Kelly seem to be from Cheers and Donny from Fraisier). Beyond that I have no idea, but I really know nothing of either show. Does that mean someone else has not figured it out? Not at all. This is a themed game and names can be very useful to find scum. You holding it back makes me think that you might have a reason to think your name is scummy, which may be because it is.
As for claiming last, no it does not mean that you are scum. But if you claim first and make something up, you have a much higher chance of getting caught in a lie. Therefore, the later someone claims, the less likely they can be caught in a lie, and the more likely they are to be scum. You could be telling the truth, but you could also just be using something we don't know the cause of to make your story sound legit.
As for your targets (actual and claimed that you would have tried) : I see saving ML, and pancakeman as well. Why omg?
Well they just revealed today, although I have suspected flubbs was a mason for a long time because of the roleplaying. Although I thought that the last one was nulio for a similar reason. As a question for the both flubb and nulio: were you required to RP?
I was actually quite sad I got this style of coroner, as I feel it is less powerful. It seems better to get the death reveals as a PM from the mod. That way when it comes to claim time, you can spot mafia really easily if they start using fake claims they think are safe. In the current way, they know exactly what they can't claim, so you can't find them that way.
coju
Well-known member
True on the corner. Never thought of that
to answer your question about why omg: I never wanted him to go in the first place. I believed his claim about being a survivor. Yeah, he lied about it, got lynched, and won. Yeah, he would have went for either team in the end. I just couldn't believe that nobody could just drop it. I wanted to lynch a lurker. Not someone who was willing to participate. (yes, he did lurk some the day lynched)
to answer your question about why omg: I never wanted him to go in the first place. I believed his claim about being a survivor. Yeah, he lied about it, got lynched, and won. Yeah, he would have went for either team in the end. I just couldn't believe that nobody could just drop it. I wanted to lynch a lurker. Not someone who was willing to participate. (yes, he did lurk some the day lynched)
I see your point. I think the traditional coroner has a higher potential upside, with a lower average (I.E the ability to find scum from a false claim, vs. having to claim to provide information to the rest of the town). Whereas what you have probably has a higher average (in that you don't have to do anything except survive for the information to be provided to town). I was looking at it based on the average case, whereas you were looking at it from the best upside. Does that make sense?
I believe the name Caluin provided is true but for the rest of the claim I'm not as inclined to believe it as true.
Angry Ex-wife of Niles - this seems a little long for a faction name.
I agree with pharphis that bomb might have been claimed just to explain why he's still alive as the days go by.
He's also been a bit vague for some of his reasons in voting. Often saying this person is the scummiest but not elaborating on why.
Vote 1: Caluin Graye
Angry Ex-wife of Niles - this seems a little long for a faction name.
I agree with pharphis that bomb might have been claimed just to explain why he's still alive as the days go by.
He's also been a bit vague for some of his reasons in voting. Often saying this person is the scummiest but not elaborating on why.
Vote 1: Caluin Graye
flubbucket1
New member
I don't trust this person at all.
And nobody tells me to roleplay .....except in the bedroom :wink2:
Yeah, actually that makes sense. Basically this role is more consistent, while the other method is swingy (for better or worse).
Anyways, where did everyone go? Please tell me people are not just giving up for the day.
I was thinking a recruiter would be easier to balance in a one mafia setting than in a two mafia setting. And I was thinking he was mostly guessing on the masons being mafia but I guess it was two mafia regardless of the masons.
I'm happy with my votes (CG and Jcakes - not so much because CG wants him lynched) and I don't have much else to say for now.
Though I was going to add this but forgot earlier; I additionally think that CG claimed his bomb effect was night only so that it would come across as "oh - he's not trying to hide behind a lynch bomb threat. . . he must be town!"
@All,
Question: Who thinks CG is being honest?
I don't remember reading him being locked, so. . .
Yeah, I'll take of the cakes vote.
Unvote 2: Jcakes
Caluin Graye
New member
flubbucket1
New member
I wonder if the hotcakes man could have gotten the mason/pyro drink spiking as some sort of activity and interpreted it as dual mafia.
Malevolent was a recruiter so could there be others??
I don't see definitive evidence of two mafia factions. However I do see evidence of a no lynch day!!
We don't want a no lynch, do we?
Pharphis seems to be confident about CG. He is not my first target, but that bomb claiming seems off. A bomb should claim some other power role and try to get the mafia to target them for a NK. Even more so with so many "savers" out off the game.
Vote 1: Caluin Graye
Caluin Graye
New member
nulio
Well-known member
I'm really sorry that I'm not participating much. I'm having trouble trying to read the players and add something to the discussion.
But I do think CG has to go, this looked weird to me at the time and was what "started the kill" on Noodle. The way he jumped on the wagon. I might be risking being completely unfair but...
Or maybe was Moar that started it?
Why weren't you comfortable then but are now?
