Mafia Game: Cheers/Frasier Theme

@pharphis
Ok, I understand your thinking now. Thanks for clarifying. You have a point there. We'll know by tomorrow as there is role and name reveal and as stated several times before, not voting frozzzen today with vote 2 will be scum reveal. So that should get done anyway.

I am very suspicious about Pyro. He's my prime candidate for vote 1 today, but I'd like to hear from him before I cast my vote. We still have good time.
 
Good Christ, 414,599 posts since I last logged on to this thread. Speed read my way through it, I have no brain for this. Couple of things or so stuck in my mind concerning the game thus far. Nothing insightful enough to discuss yet.

If the target of Vote 1 flips town, that's Jcakes's card marked. I like cakes' assessment of the Vote 2 mechanism i.r.o. frozzzen though ...

Over-fussy voting rules are over-fussy. I may already have mentioned this.

Vote 1: pancakeman
Vote 2: frozzzen
 
pharphis said:
Frozzzen and his buddies thought about who in either show sounded the most like a doc,and decided the next one of them found guilty will claim that role, and as SK. SK so that they could push more doubt on CG (By claiming the cop and some innocents are mafia - like Martin said)
Daphne was the character they chose, and because they can't choose any other dead people they went with it. (meaning Daphne is still alive, if there is one). They would have done this in hopes of a counter-claim by Daphne, so they would know who the doc probably is.
Click to expand...

Interesting. Didn't think about that possibility, but seems like solid logic to me. Is Daphne a major character in the show?

Caluin Graye said:
Noodle is a tough read; lurkers usually are. The two botched votes are suspicious. The complete lack of participation after day 1 is suspicious. Usually Noodle pops in and asks simple, concise questions. He's not doing this game. He seems almost content to hang back and let others do the work, which is something I expect of mafia Noodle.

I'd also say that coju is acting very scummy, even more than coju normally seems. Am I the only person seeing it? It may just be my overly suspicious nature, but to try casting doubt on the cop who's caught us two scum at this point in the game...
Click to expand...

Agreed about Noodle, he went from active the first day to absolutely nothing since. Normally we at least get questions with votes.

Honestly coju and flubb are a complete mystery to me. I think they are scummy every game, and have a hard time telling the difference between town and mafia for both of them.

Noodle is my top choice, but I can also see myself voting for pancake or coju.


 
flubbucket said:
Sounds reasonable. Hopefully you bringing it to light will allow the doc to continue to remain anonymous. We will be lynching frozzzen regardless of his eeeeevil scheme. We now need to agree on a Vote 1.
Click to expand...
Yeah, two reasons why I wanted to get it out there;
1. So the doc doesn't hastily claim - though it seems unlikely they would, anyway
2. So the rest of us can consider this possibility instead of having any doubt on ML + Mal + CG like his post admittedly caused me at first.
However, I still don't have any reason to not think CG could be the SK or something. I do doubt he is mafia, now.

@Gwaihir,
I have no idea about Noodle ever, and it's frustrating. If our cop lives again and noodle isn't lynched I can see him being a good target for an investigation. . . Or cakes, or pcm, or CG, or anyone!

TBH I haven't really noticed much from coju but lots think he has been scummy so I'll have a look at his posts later in the day when I'm home.


 
Main aspects of coju is that he has been coasting buy quite easily, flying low under the radar, with the wagon on me his vote was suspicious. I'm still looking though all the pages again, less than 1/2 way there! Lot's of posts to read!!
 
Noodle, can you give us some insight on your thoughts as to who is scummy? I mean, it's fine to lurk (maybe) but if you're a townie you should at least try to help a bit more. Especially since this game you haven't.
 
Son of a . . .

Vote 2: frozzzen


Pharphis, honestly I still need to go back and read several pages. I've been popping in for a minute or two here and there, but nothing that's allowed me to do more than scan a couple quick posts, and rush to place a vote. I'll admit upfront that I've allowed myself to get lazy and have become accustomed to a more relaxed vote acceptance policy that we've seen in several recent games in Community. This absolutely isn't a shot at Thy, because a strict vote acceptance polcy is both traditional and entirely within reason.
 
My apologies to Martin; I had indeed missed 809. Presumably I'd ran out of fingers by then.

If anyone spots stuff like that, feel free to PM me.

For those completely confused about voting rules: I'm using ThunderCats with the stipulation that I'm not as fussy with spacing but do want votes at the end of the post. If you prefer, I'll switch to TC's and get all anal about spacing and capitalization of "V"'s. TC suggested I get people to PM me with votes but I'm sure we don't want that!
 
Thyiad said:
For those completely confused about voting rules: I'm using ThunderCats with the stipulation that I'm not as fussy with spacing but do want votes at the end of the post. If you prefer, I'll switch to TC's and get all anal about spacing and capitalization of "V"'s. TC suggested I get people to PM me with votes but I'm sure we don't want that!
Click to expand...

No, leave it as is. Changing rules midway through the game just makes things tougher. This new voting scheme has actually grown on me a bit. It's become quite hilarious in its own way.



 
the franklin, i love how you go wow at noocles many failed votes and then fail one yourself

so many V1targets that we can assure thatsome of them are town, therefoer i think it is best not to rush blindly into alynch, we dont have anything real agaisnt anyone ( apart from frozzzen ofc ) yet, but if i am convinced of a persons scuminess ill happily jump onto the wagon. We still have to be careful though


My Scum List (people who i think may be scum but might not be)

-Noodle- acting very odd this game, extra lurky and nothing going on
-Autti- Justr playing with scumminess, he maybe a mason but if anybody was to be a spy in the masons it would be him IMO
-Uraj- hasn't done anything

and these people i have less of a bad feeling about but are still options

-PCM
-Jcakes
-CG

Just my 2 cents
 
I said "lol" after my vote in a display of sarcasm.

I was once a mafia traitor, and to get recruited they have to attempt to nk you. Now, when I was a traitor it was worthless because neither mafia or town knew me as such. In this case, a mafia traitor in the mason group would be glorious. This is the best reason for the masons stay hidden. Jcakes role says anti town night "actions," plural.

There was a game where the traitor knew they were one, and one where they didn't.

PS I think it was jcakes, don't have a cow if I misremembered.
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top